Espreso. Global
OPINION

Will Ukrainian soldiers replace American ones in Europe?

Sofia Polonska
3 December, 2024 Tuesday
19:47

The plan to replace the U.S. military in Europe with Ukrainian troops is not so absurd. Of course, not literally, but as a new and important component of the overall European security system

client/title.list_title

European leaders are now hotly debating what the security architecture in Europe should look like if Trump fulfils his promise and puts the security of Europe solely on the shoulders of Europeans. Europeans are also worried about the fact that there are not many armies in Europe that are capable of fighting. There are also few citizens who, after decades of comfortable living, have the will and desire to take up arms and defend their freedom.

This means that politicians will have to make unpopular decisions, such as returning to universal military conscription, which is already being discussed in France and Germany, or cutting social programmes and increasing military spending instead.

And this is where the question arises: who will fight for Europeans? There are not many more or less capable armies in Europe. These are certainly the British army (although it is not a member of the EU) and France. The undisputed leader in investing in its own security is Poland, which, at the current rate of army modernization, will have the most powerful ground army among EU members in a few years.

As for the rest of the European armies, there are only questions... And so it turns out that the Ukrainian army and Ukraine, if included in the European security system, can become one of the shields that will protect the old Europe from Russian expansion. Of course, not for nothing. It's for money (the Ukrainian army has to become professional) and for access to EU political decisions.

That is why the prospect of replacing American soldiers with Ukrainian ones is not a ‘Trump's fantasy’, nor is it just Ukraine's wish. The very logic of events and the EU's capabilities will encourage Europeans to involve Ukraine in the new European security architecture.

This process will be supported by the Americans, both because Trump promised it and because it will definitely increase Europeans' responsibility for their own security.

Recently, the West has even expressed the view that this could become part of a bargain with Russia — that when Putin demands a reduction of the Ukrainian army in possible ‘negotiations’, it could be suggested that this Ukrainian army should simply be located in the EU, away from Russia's borders, but in the event of a new war, it could quickly return home.

By the way, another country that will get a chance for new European integration is Turkey. It also has a capable army, so with the right diplomatic approaches, Turkish European integration could get a second wind.

Of course, the involvement of Ukrainians (and possibly even Turks) in the European security system may not be accepted in some EU countries. But here, Europeans will have to choose — either their own very unpopular decisions or inviting those who can protect them to European structures. I repeat — not for nothing. It is for money and political influence on the fate of the whole of Europe.

Source

About the author. Serhiy Taran, political scientist

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

 

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Sunday
12 January
19:48
OPINION
Boris Johnson's misguided view on Russia: Blind spot in Western politics
19:32
Interview
From Putin's point of view, Trump's statements are imperialistic aspirations - U.S. diplomat
19:11
German election forecast: impact on Ukraine
18:52
Russia claims "controlled burn" as fire rages at Engels oil depot after Ukrainian drone strike
18:26
Ukraine reports 75 clashes at front, repels 22 attacks in Pokrovsk sector
18:03
Exclusive
Russian forces outflank Pokrovsk to cut logistics, avoiding urban combat - military expert
17:45
NATO, Ramstein decisions on Ukraine air defense remain unfulfilled – Zelenskyy
17:20
Ukraine's Usyk awarded best boxer of year by The Ring
16:55
Unable to enter port, fuel tanks leak: Ukrainian intelligence on Russia's struggles to evacuate military gear from Syria
16:44
Updated
Russian army targets Kherson, its outskirts, injuring civilians, damaging critical infrastructure
16:31
Paperwork delays Lithuanian drone deliveries to Ukraine
16:10
Elderly man injured in Russian drone attack on Ukraine’s Mykolaiv region
16:00
Russian bus crashes in Ilovaisk, killing passengers
15:44
Ukrainian forces scale up experiment with new method to down Russian Mavics - Defense Express
15:25
Ukraine strikes Russian command post in occupied Donetsk region
15:04
Poland rules out boots on the ground in Ukraine
14:59
Zelenskyy calls on Western allies to honor promises on weapons supplies to Ukraine
14:33
Exclusive
“Army is running out of people”: Authorities need to hold honest conversations with the Ukrainian people – official
14:02
OPINION
Success on his opponent's turf: Another take on Zelenskyy's interview with Fridman
13:33
OPINION
Serbia's "knife in back" of Russia
13:00
Russian airstrike on senior care house in Kursk region leaves woman dead
12:15
Partisans identify secret Russian nuclear unit in Far East
11:29
Ukraine destroys 60 of 94 Russian drones overnight
11:02
Russian stormtroopers attack Ukrainian positions in Lyman sector
10:55
Switzerland proposes hosting Putin-Trump meeting
10:29
1,750 Russian soldiers eliminated in Ukraine in single day
2025, Saturday
11 January
19:40
Exclusive
Russian opposition expert Morozov outlines three key aspects of Putin's potential communications with Washington
19:00
Exclusive
U.S. military support for Ukraine will continue, says diplomat Bryza
18:35
Exclusive
Russia's shadow tanker fleet hit: Economist Pendzin on new sanctions package
18:10
Biden administration extends special status for Ukrainian refugees by 1.5 years
17:48
"Our task is to make 2025 a record year for drone production" – Zelenskyy
17:22
Exclusive
Trump unconcerned with terms of Ukraine-Russia peace deal – diplomat Bryza
16:55
Exclusive
"Without people, strength, and resources, we can't hold Kurakhove" – Major Hetman
16:31
Ukrainian army's retreat from Kursk will trigger Russian offensive
16:05
Exclusive
No Trump-Putin meeting in 2025, Russian opposition expert Morozov says
15:40
OPINION
Meeting with Trump. Putin wants to show he is being talked to
15:14
Two North Korean soldiers captured in Kursk region brought to Kyiv
14:50
Exclusive
First underground school built in Sumy region: costs revealed
14:23
Exclusive
Kurakhove issue remains unresolved: serviceman on Russian attacks in this sector
13:58
Exclusive
Preparing launching pad: political scientist Reiterovych on Trump's geopolitical statements
More news