Espreso. Global
OPINION

What do we call what's happening in Kursk region?

19 August, 2024 Monday
18:57

A key marker of sovereignty is the power to name events and realities. Not merely borrowing names but creating your own, and getting others to use them

client/title.list_title

On August 6, Ukrainian forces entered Russia's Kursk region. Since then, they’ve taken control of dozens of settlements, including Sudzha, a district center with about five thousand residents. Over one hundred thousand people have been evacuated from the region.

Khurshudyan’s article lays out the entire operation, which includes expanding the war into Russian territory. We’re calling this an "operation" or an "offensive." After all, a country has the right to self-defense against an aggressor, even if that means military actions near the enemy’s borders.

Meanwhile, the Russian side avoids the term "invasion." The Russian Ministry of Defense speaks of an "invasion attempt." Putin uses phrases like "large-scale provocation" and "the situation developing in the Kursk region." The Russian Central Bank opts for the vague "events that have taken place." Putin doesn’t want to acknowledge the gravity of the situation. If, for the first time since World War II, Russian territory isn’t under Russian control, something is clearly wrong. Hence the euphemisms like "the situation developing" or "the events that are happening."

Naming or not naming events reflects control over the narrative.

After Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, the BBC refused to use the word "terrorists," supposedly to avoid labeling one side of the conflict as the "bad guys."

In the end, history textbooks will give the events in the Kursk region their name. What words will Ukrainian textbooks use?

How should we describe what’s happening?

It's clear that, for now at least, the Ukrainian government isn’t aiming to annex the Kursk region. At some point, though maybe not soon, control of these areas will likely be handed back to Russia’s next government — or the current one — in exchange for something.

The Ukrainian military’s operation in the Kursk region has exposed the Kremlin’s inability to protect and care for its citizens. Now, Russia is bombing its own territories. Soon enough, they’ll probably be "bombing Voronezh."

We can't realistically talk about the Kursk region gaining independence either (however, no one initially expected Luhansk and Donetsk to become so-called "people's republics," but achieving that would require massive administrative resources, which Ukraine lacks.) Plus, there are no oppressed peoples in the Kursk region in need of protection by the Ukrainian parliament.

By process of elimination, we can say that the Ukrainian Armed Forces are enabling the forced re-federalization of the Kursk region. In this process, the region’s population and leadership reject the war against Ukraine and demand the withdrawal of all Russian troops from sovereign Ukrainian territory.

This is how the Kursk region asserts its subjectivity within the Russian Federation, as it is still a full-fledged subject of Russia, represented by its governor, senator, and legislative assembly.

The concept of re-federalization is backed by a European Parliament resolution.

According to this resolution, the Ukrainian Armed Forces, in compliance with the European Parliament’s directives, are carrying out the de-imperialization, decolonization, and re-federalization of the Kursk region within the Russian Federation.

Thus, I propose calling these events the re-federalization of the Kursk region.

Source

About the author. Dmytro Zolotukhin, former Deputy Minister of Information Policy of Ukraine, expert on information warfare and competitive intelligence

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Sunday
24 November
20:05
Oreshnik strike on Dnipro: SSU displays missile wreckage
19:40
OPINION
Escalation is real, describes Russia's whole war against Ukraine, and we are all witnessing it clearly
19:21
Russia deploys S-300 air defense systems on Cape Fiolent in occupied Crimea
19:00
Interview
Trump to seek Ukraine deal that prevents future Russian pressure - diplomat Bryza
18:33
Russian strikes take Kurakhove thermal power plant offline, destroying even pipes
18:15
Russian soldiers shoot dead two civilians in Toretsk, Donetsk region
17:40
Türkiye stops Russia from seizing Odesa, Mykolaiv by closing Bosporus, Dardanelles Straits - Ambassador
17:21
Ukrainian drones strike Rosneft oil depot in Kaluga
16:51
OPINION
We must all decide whether our nation wants shame or glory
16:25
Exclusive
No more talk of “ending the war in 24 hours”: politician explains shift in Trump team's tone
15:58
Russian army advances in Kursk, Donetsk, Kharkiv regions – DeepState
15:28
Taiwan’s former president urges U.S. to put Ukraine's needs first
14:58
Exclusive
Why Republicans won’t cut Ukraine support – Russian opposition expert
14:22
Exclusive
Holding Kursk region territory is strategically impractical – Ukrainian Army General Malomuzh
14:17
Updated
Russia shells Kherson region: three elderly people seriously wounded
13:28
Ukrainian forces strike S-400 air defense missile system in Russia's Kursk region
13:06
Russians claim to shoot down 2 missiles, 36 drones across 5 regions
12:27
Exclusive
Putin thinks escalation could strengthen his hand with Trump – journalist Portnikov on nuclear threats
12:05
OPINION
Blockade on Polish border: Who stands to gain?
11:33
Ukrainian air defenses down 50 of 73 Russian drones in latest attack
11:02
Russia loses 1,020 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
10:31
Russia launches drone attack on Ukraine’s Kyiv: air alert lasts over 3 hours
2024, Saturday
23 November
20:10
Putin orders to dislodge Ukrainian forces from Kursk before Trump’s inauguration - Zelenskyy
19:50
Ukraine's ex-top general warns of potential Russian technological breakthrough by 2027
19:30
Exclusive
Kremlin to set Trump its terms for ending war - Russian opposition expert
19:11
Exclusive
Without security guarantees for Ukraine, negotiations are meaningless - U.S. diplomat
18:50
Ukraine can intercept new Russian Kedr missiles capable of carrying nuclear warheads
18:27
Russia steals over 785 Ukrainian cultural heritage artifacts
18:05
Exclusive
Russia's stockpile of such missiles is limited — aviation expert on Dnipro strike
17:40
Russia trains specialists for prisoner torture system - Ukraine’s intelligence
17:15
Exclusive
Biden administration never tried to ensure Ukraine's victory - U.S. diplomat
16:44
OPINION
Ukraine-Russia peace talks: possible as process, unlikely as outcome
16:15
Exclusive
Turbulence before Trump’s inauguration to bring 60 to 90 days of uncertainty - Russian opposition expert Morozov
15:49
U.S. intelligence links Kremlin to killings of Putin’s critics abroad
15:21
Russian general likely killed in Storm Shadow strike on Kursk headquarters - media
14:50
OPINION
Does Trump have plan?
14:20
Russia plans to test-fire ballistic missiles again in coming days - ISW
13:50
Russian attack on Zaporizhzhia: 11-year-old boy injured, 55-year-old man killed
13:25
Admiral Nakhimov nuclear-powered cruiser of Russian Fleet
How Russia's war on Ukraine stalled its Navy modernization - Defense Express
12:55
Russia trades missiles, air defense systems, oil in exchange for North Korean troops - ISW
More news