Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Expert explains Ukraine's "military miracle" in Kursk, challenges near Pokrovsk

Alona Myshakova
20 August, 2024 Tuesday
20:57

Defense Express military expert Ivan Kyrychevskyi has explained why Ukrainian defenders achieved a “military miracle” in Russia’s Kursk region

client/title.list_title

He shared his view on Espreso TV.

A military expert said, “The Russians haven’t had any real issues with manpower or resources, even in the Kursk region. The problem seems to be with their management. To understand why we saw military success in Kursk but are facing difficulties near Pokrovsk, consider this: In Pokrovsk and other eastern areas, Russian forces are trying to attack with full army units, not only smaller units like an army corps or division.”

According to him, in the Kursk region, Russia is using a so-called “hodgepodge” approach.

“In the Kursk region, the Russians are using what is often referred to as a ‘hodgepodge.’ This means that several brigades are involved, but they are varied in terms of personnel quality, weaponry, and even command structure. That’s why we see a paradox: based on public estimates, Ukrainian troops are fighting against a superior enemy with fewer numbers,” Kyrychevskyi said.

At the same time, he noted that the operation in the Kursk region was worthwhile.

“There are interesting stories about how Russia's Akhmat unit did not engage in combat but instead allegedly followed a strategy reminiscent of the “great” Russian commander Kutuzov, performing a parallel march. This means moving in such a way as to avoid direct contact with the enemy. 

Given their different management culture, this explains why Ukraine could not stop the enemy at Pokrovsk and why the situation didn’t improve there. In the Pokrovsk and Toretsk directions, the Russian military units responsible for their operations chose not to engage in internal factional struggles and won in that regard - the Russian command didn’t withdraw additional troops and reserves from those areas. Nevertheless, whether or not it went according to plan, it is clear that the Kursk operation was necessary,” the expert added.

Ukraine’s cross-border incursion in Russia’s Kursk region

On August 6, the authorities of Russia's Kursk region stated that the Ukrainian Armed Forces allegedly tried to break through the Russian border, but were allegedly pushed back. Later, the Russian Defense Ministry reported that "the Ukrainian sabotage and reconnaissance group retreated to its territory.”

Ukraine's Main Intelligence Directorate refused to comment on the statements regarding the Kursk region. However, NV media, citing its own source in Ukrainian intelligence, wrote that the events in the Kursk region "definitely did not involve fighters of the Russian Volunteer Corps, who are fighting as part of Ukraine's Armed Forces.”

The Institute for the Study of War noted that the Russian Defense Ministry, acting governor of the Kursk region Alexei Smirnov, and some propagandists have different versions of the events in the Kursk region.

On August 7, Kremlin leader Vladimir Putin convened the Russian military leadership to discuss the situation in the Kursk region, which he called a "large-scale provocation." At the time, Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova called on the international community to "strongly condemn the Kyiv regime's criminal attacks on Russian territory."

On the same day, Russian media reported that workers at the Kursk nuclear power plant feared that the plant's management had not prepared for a possible attack by the Ukrainian armed forces.

Additionally, in the Kursk region, Russians have begun forming UAV operator units from civilians, providing them with up to 10 hours of training.

On August 7, a state of emergency was introduced in the Kursk region.

On August 8, the Institute for the study of War reported that Ukrainian troops confirmed advancing up to 10 km deep into the Kursk region as mechanized offensives continued.

On August 8, Russia’s National Guard announced that it had implemented additional security measures at the Kursk Nuclear Power Plant to protect a "particularly important facility."

The Washington Post reported that Ukraine has taken control of the gas metering station in Sudzha, Kursk region. Previously, Russia claimed that the Ukrainian Armed Forces had occupied several border villages and part of the town of Sudzha.

Deputy Pentagon Press Secretary Sabrina Singh stated that Ukraine’s actions in the Kursk region in Russia "are consistent with U.S. policy" and do not cause any escalation.

On Friday, August 9, it was reported that mercenaries from PMC Wagner intend to fight for Russia in the Kursk region.

The Wall Street Journal, citing its own sources, reported that Russian military leaders have decided to withdraw some of their forces from Ukraine to redeploy them to the Kursk region in response to Ukraine’s military operations.

On August 13, John Kirby, Strategic Communications Coordinator at the White House National Security Council, suggested that if Kremlin leader Vladimir Putin is concerned about the developments in the Kursk region, he could choose to end the war.

Since the start of August 14, the Ukrainian Defense Forces have captured over 100 Russian soldiers.

At a meeting with the president on August 15, Ukrainian Armed Forces Commander-in-Chief Oleksandr Syrskyi said that Ukraine had established the first military commandant's office in the Kursk region to provide humanitarian aid to local residents.

At the same time, Ukraine's Ministry of Reintegration of the Temporarily Occupied Territories, together with the military, is currently working on a possible route for a humanitarian corridor for civilians from Kursk to Sumy.

On August 15, The Independent reported that about 2,000 Russian servicemen were captured during an operation by the Ukrainian Armed Forces in the Kursk region.

Ukrainian troops continue to operate in the Kursk region. As of August 19, the Ukrainian Armed Forces took control of 92 settlements.

On August 20, Russian leader Vladimir Putin ordered the military to push Ukrainian forces out of the Kursk region by October 1, 2024.


 




 
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Friday
10 January
19:30
Ukraine reports 166 combat clashes today, Pokrovsk sector sees heaviest fighting
19:13
Exclusive
Putin may rethink war due to economic decline — ex-chief military prosecutor
18:53
OPINION
Alice in Muskland. Will Trump's ally help triumph of far right in Germany?
18:32
Syrian government refuses Russian ships access to port in Tartus
18:14
Ukraine's Neptune destroys Russian ammo depot near Rostov-on-Don: strike details
17:56
Exclusive
"Great irresponsibility": public figure Materniak on candidate Nawrocki’s Ukraine comment
17:50
Ukrainian forces strike Russian command post in occupied Svitlodarsk
17:30
Putin guarantees gas deliveries to Slovakia, PM Fico claims
17:05
Halting Russian oil transit via Ukraine would violate EU pacts, Ukraine’s PM says
16:45
British Prime Minister Starmer to visit Kyiv in coming weeks
16:45
OPINION
On Canada, U.S., and Trump’s statements
16:21
Ukrainian forces target drone storage facility in Russia's Rostov region
16:18
Updated
Putin ready to meet with Trump without preconditions, Kremlin says. Ukraine responds
16:03
Understanding military operation in Kursk region: expert’s perspective
15:45
Trump's special envoy Kellogg postpones his visit to Kyiv 'for legal reasons'
15:09
Mi-24 helicopters donated by North Macedonia spotted in Ukraine
14:49
Updated
Zelenskyy in Italy meets PM Meloni and President Mattarella: Key topics discussed
14:33
Exclusive
U.S. stance on Ukraine to be shaped after Putin-Trump meeting - official
14:11
Russian aviation – threat to NATO: Su-24 fleet, capabilities, losses
13:50
EU transfers first €3 billion from G7 loan to Ukraine
13:26
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces in Kursk region limit Russian advances, inflicting heavy losses — military expert
13:00
Exclusive
Russian troops attempt to breach defenses to advance toward Siversk - Ukrainian commander
12:38
Exclusive
Russia to keep pressuring Ukraine's defenses despite reaching its peak capabilities - military expert
12:17
German chancellor blocks €3 billion weapon allocation for Ukraine - Spiegel
11:59
Japan imposes new sanctions on Russia, North Korea, China
11:41
Trump announces plans to meet with Putin - media
11:20
Review
Ramstein meeting: security agreements, troop deployment in Ukraine. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
10:58
161 combat clashes take place at frontline on Jan.9: Ukrainian troops stopped 42 attacks in Pokrovsk direction
10:39
Drone strikes spark fires in Russia’s Leningrad, Rostov regions
10:20
Russian troops capture 3 settlements in Donetsk region, 3 in Kursk
10:03
Updated
Russian drone fragments hit high-rise building in Kyiv, damaging dozens apartments
09:46
Umerov reports on 25th Ramstein: 6 countries to provide military aid to Ukraine
09:24
Russia loses 1,830 soldiers, 3 air defense systems, 10 tanks in day of war in Ukraine
2025, Thursday
9 January
21:30
Russia's attack on Zaporizhzhia causes highest civilian casualties in two years - UN mission
21:15
Exclusive
Russia loses fuel for strategic aviation after drones damage Engels oil depot
20:58
Exclusive
Penalties, export bans kill Ukraine's defense industry - MP Yanchenko
20:41
Exclusive
War for Arctic, Antarctic: diplomat on Trump's statements on Greenland
20:25
OPINION
Zelenskyy explains civilizational difference between Ukraine and Russia
20:08
IRIS-T air defense system
Germany to donate 6 IRIS-T systems to Ukraine in 2025
19:51
United Kingdom, allies to provide Ukraine with 30,000 drones
More news