Espreso. Global
Exclusive

"Definitely not 47,000": military expert on Russian losses in Avdiivka

21 February, 2024 Wednesday
20:45

Analyzing the losses of the Russian military in Avdiivka, expert and former Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) officer Ivan Stupak stressed the importance of the information accuracy and its impact on public opinion, pointing out the possibility of misinterpreting large numbers

client/title.list_title

He stated this on Espreso TV.

"I saw it too optimistically, honestly, I'm not trying to scare people, but it looks very optimistic. What confused me, what do I disagree with? The losses of Russians near Avdiivka, they are definitely not 47,000. It is important to say this because Ukrainians may have such thoughts, that is, almost 50,000 were killed, which is 10% of what they have. This would be wrong, it would be misleading," Stupak explained.

According to him, there are three figures that represent the probable losses of the Russian army in the four-month active phase of the Avdiivka defense operation.

"The first, very conservative and very cautious figure is 4,000 Russians who, excuse me, are firmly embedded in Ukrainian soil, they will not return, even if they are covered with holy water or some relics of Russian saints. There is a more optimistic figure - 13,000 Russian soldiers. That is, 4,000, 13,000 - it's obviously impossible to count, because the fighting is very active," the military expert explained. 

"The Russians themselves, the Russian military correspondent who runs the public account "We hear from Yanina", committed suicide today and before that he mentioned the figure of 16,000 Russians who laid down their lives in Avdiivka. Until now, they could not even show this city on a map without a mistake, and they gave their lives there."

Stupak stressed that the 47,000 figure may be true if we count not only the dead, but also the lightly, moderately, and severely wounded, missing, and those who were taken prisoner by Ukrainians: "That is, plus or minus such a figure can draw - it is important to note and say this so as not to mislead Ukrainians, so that they can correctly assess the situation."

He emphasized that an important aspect of our struggle is the assistance from the United States.

"The United States has already informed Ukraine that if we fail to agree on aid, you, the Ukrainians, will have to decide which cities will have to be left to the Russians because the aid is not coming. Since October, President Biden has been persuading congressmen to vote, but we were expecting in December, before the Christmas holidays, then right after the New Year holidays, and now I'm looking at March, and there is no aid yet. The lower House of Representatives is on break until the 28th of March. The upper house has voted, but the lower house would rather go to the stake rather than vote. Perhaps the fact that we left Avdiivka will somehow influence the Americans," added the former Ukraine's Security Service officer.

For reference. "We hear from Yanina" is a Telegram channel that discusses the events of the war in Ukraine. The latest messages consider the freezing of the conflict as a respite for the Ukrainian Armed Forces, but with the possibility of even greater losses. 

What happened before

On February 17, in order to avoid encirclement and save the lives of the military, Ukrainian military command decided to withdraw from Avdiivka and move to more favorable positions.

Ukraine's Defense Minister Rustem Umerov said that the decision to withdraw from Avdiivka was the right one and that Ukrainian soldiers are in need of some weapons and equipment.

Ukrainian defenders near Avdiivka inflicted huge losses on Russian enemy. In terms of personnel alone, they exceeded 47,000 soldiers, said the commander of the Tavria Operational and Strategic Group of Forces, Oleksandr Tarnavskyi.

In Russia, military and propagandist Andrei Morozov, call sign Murz, claimed 16,000 Russian army soldiers killed in the battle for Avdiivka. It is also important to note that he ran the Telegram channel 'We hear from Yanina'. Today it became known that he probably committed suicide. Morozov served for a long time in the armed formations of the so-called DPR and was a member of the Russian army.

The day before, Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu reported to terrorist leader Vladimir Putin that the Russian army had allegedly taken control of Krynky on the left bank of the Kherson region.

The Southern Ukrainian Defense Forces later denied Shoigu's statement.

"Both Shoigu's statements about enemy losses near Avdiivka and about Krynky are false," said Serhiy Zgurets, director of the information and consulting company Defense Express. 

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Tuesday
21 January
11:30
Exclusive
'War here feels like Vietnam': Ukraine’s 13th Brigade on situation in Kharkiv region
11:13
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 8-15
Street battles rage in Toretsk, says military administration head
10:52
OPINION
Trump’s team lacks clear plan to end war in Ukraine
10:35
Drone attacks hit Smolensk aviation plant and Voronezh oil depot, Russia reports
10:13
Russia’s war against Ukraine: Trump plans to meet with Putin for talks
09:56
'Each side is going to have to give up something': U.S. Secretary of State Rubio on Russia-Ukraine war
09:35
Russia loses 1,600 soldiers, 12 tanks, 130 UAVs in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Monday
20 January
21:30
“Today is day of change”: Zelenskyy congratulates Trump on his inauguration
21:15
Ukraine receives military aid from Latvia, including drones, generators
20:59
Trump does not mention Ukraine in his inaugural address
20:38
Exclusive
Trump won’t betray Ukraine as it means his defeat – Chairman of Ukrainian American House
20:20
Exclusive
'Mixed expectations': Espreso journalist on EU reactions to Trump’s presidency
19:59
Exclusive
Military base for training Russia's new assault forces stretches from Mariupol to Berdiansk
19:38
Exclusive
Trump’s team likely to follow 'Kellogg's plan,' says political analyst
19:15
Ukraine cannot defend itself against missiles like Oreshnik. Why Patriot and even THAAD won't help?
18:51
Exclusive
Defense Express: Strikes in Kazan target key military facilities
18:30
What Trump will focus on in next 3 months – and it’s not about Ukraine
18:04
Putin says Russia open to dialogue with Trump administration
17:55
Exclusive
Lawyer clarifies mobilization rules for those over 50 in Ukraine
17:34
Locomotive supporting military logistics set on fire in St. Petersburg
17:15
OPINION
Trump tests new method of communication with Putin
16:56
Ukraine identifies Russian paratroopers behind Bucha massacre
16:35
Interview
“After constant control in captivity, all we want now is peace”: Azov soldier on returning from Russian captivity
16:15
Lyptsi: How Ukrainian forces turned Russia’s offensive into a “meat grinder”
15:56
Ukraine adapts to Russian drone upgrades with EW countermeasures
15:32
Latvia to ban Russians, Belarusians from critical infrastructure management roles
15:14
China’s crude oil imports from Russia hit record high in 2024
14:57
OPINION
Trump doesn’t ask — he demands. And not from God, but from the rest of the world
14:31
Exclusive
Trump has no plan for Ukraine war resolution, but there are outlines — Ukrainian politician
14:13
Ukraine’s strike on Kazan aircraft plant raises doubts over Russia’s production capabilities
13:52
Ukrainian Ministry of Justice restores all state registries after Russia’s cyberattack
13:31
Exclusive
Iran may backtrack on Moscow-Tehran 'strategic partnership' deal, says expert
13:15
Slovak mental health experts call for PM Fico’s resignation over recent behavior
12:57
Russian artillery shell use halved after strikes on military industry – Ukraine's top general
12:40
Zelenskyy shares footage of captured North Korean Soldier’s interrogation by SBU
12:19
Ukrainian forces regain positions in Kursk and Donetsk regions – DeepState
11:59
Russia launches disinformation campaign to influence German chancellor elections — analysts
11:45
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 8-15
Russian troops advance with heavy equipment: Ukraine reports escalation in Kurakhove sector
11:17
OPINION
Biden trap: cost of delayed decisions in Ukraine’s fight for survival
10:56
189 clashes at Russia-Ukraine frontline: Russian army loses 1,690 troops in one day
More news