Espreso. Global
OPINION

Crimea, Sikorski, and insults: does Ukraine have Plan B for Crimea?

20 September, 2024 Friday
18:18

It seems that the Ukrainian government has found a new enemy. And no, it’s not Putin, it’s Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski, who made 'unacceptable' comments about Crimea and its future

client/title.list_title

The source of the conflict can be traced back to a meeting Sikorski with Zelenskyy on September 13. At that time, the Ukrainian president spoke critically, blaming Poland for not providing enough support on Ukraine’s path to the EU.

This was followed by a domestic incident at Krakow airport involving the famous athlete Oleksandr Usyk. Airport workers asked if he was fit enough for the long journey to Valencia. The president got involved in this private quarrel, leading the Foreign Ministry to intervene and threatening a note of protest to the Poles.

So let’s be honest: Radosław Sikorski was already on edge when he attended the YES forum, organized annually by the Victor Pinchuk Foundation - and not for positive reasons.

Earlier, the elite conference on political and business ideas was held in Yalta. However, since the resort town has been under occupation for a long time, it was logical that the topic of Crimea would also be addressed.

"I don’t see anything wrong with professional Western politicians offering their own solutions to the Crimean issue. If there is a lack of meaningful options, and if our current leaders are unable to generate their own, it’s worth listening to what others with experience and status in the West have to say. After all, discussions about Crimea reflect only Sikorski’s perspective. Platforms are organized for such purposes."

I respect the Mejlis's statement and have carefully read the comments from Yermak and the Foreign Ministry affirming that Crimea is Ukraine. But let’s be honest: after the shock of February 24, 2024 - when the offensive from Crimea was highly successful for the enemy - it’s not enough to simply enjoy a cheburek for the sake of Crimea, or to buy a ticket to a concert in Yalta by a band that previously released a hype song about the Bakhmut fortress.

Crimea under Russian control, functioning as a large military base with dominance over a significant portion of the Black Sea, has been a sentence for many Ukrainians. They were promised shuttles to Chonhar, but in reality, they faced torture and death under occupation.

"The ruined Mariupol is the result of a blind eye turned to Crimea. The depopulated Kherson near the frontline is the result of infantile politics. And if we consider the seized Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant and the regular threats from the Russians to blow something up, this too is the outcome of numerous politicians enjoying baklava for the sake of Crimea, rather than seeking ways to actually reclaim it."

The frivolous attitude toward Crimea - the belief that our people are there, waiting for Ukraine to return and that we just need to release a little water from the Kakhovka reservoir - has lulled many into complacency. The enemy dealt the most painful blow this winter not from Donbas, but from Crimea. The entire occupied South is a result of incompetent policy regarding Crimea.

That is why it is surprising that in the context of searching for options to end the war, and amidst daily statements about a peace summit with or without Russia, we have only one position on Crimea: “Crimea is Ukraine” - without specifying what we will do to demilitarize it and make life unbearable for the hundreds of thousands of Russian security forces who have arrived. These young people have children born in Crimea, and it is logical to think that in a few years, they will claim this land as their own.

What did Sikorski say at Pinchuk's event? "Crimea is symbolically important for Russia, especially for Putin, but it is strategically important for Ukraine. I do not see how peace can be achieved without the demilitarization of Crimea." I don’t see anything wrong with these words, because it is well known that not only Putin but also fashionable Russian opposition figures, will break 100% on the Crimean issue.

Sikorski offered one option. It was an option, not a demand or an ultimatum. “We could put it under a UN mandate with a mission to prepare a fair referendum after verifying who the legitimate residents are... And we could postpone it for 20 years.”

In my opinion, there is nothing critical or wrong here. First of all, we need to audit who the legal residents of Crimea are. A simple test is whether a child born to a couple of occupying soldiers should have the right to live in Crimea, or the son of our local resident and a Russian GRU special forces officer who has killed children in Mariupol. What about holders of Ukrainian passports who later took Russian passports and are happy to work on ships and planes that launched missiles at our cities from the rear?

"Regarding the UN mandate, Ukrainian society often complains that the bureaucrats there are greedy, lazy, and out of touch with the realities of today. They have to handle the issue of Crimea; they should focus on basic monitoring of the lives of those who will continue to live on the annexed peninsula."

When there is a lack of military forces and government experts at this historical moment, it is sometimes better to wait. At one time, China waited nearly 100 years for Hong Kong. And now, it is the only way to supply chips to the Russian military-industrial complex.

Ukrainian leaders can be offended by Sikorski as much as they want. However, the proposal to catalog everything on the peninsula and place them under the supervision of a UN mandate is better than nothing.

What realistic proposals have we heard from our government officials instead? Proposals to plant medical cannabis in the Crimean mountains? Announcements about creating a personnel reserve to take power in Crimea? However, an essential question remains: whose hands should be used to liberate Crimea? After all, the summer counteroffensive of 2023 and the PR surrounding it showed that this is not an easy tourist bike ride.

Meanwhile, textbooks for Ukrainian seventh-graders are printing maps of Ukraine without Crimea. I don’t know whether this is a designer’s mistake or a crisis of professional staffing in the Ministry of Education.

The truth remains: the longer we keep saying that “Crimea is Ukraine” without plans A and B, the stronger Russia will grow on the occupied peninsula.

Finally, any peace summit will not bring peace without resolving the Crimean issue. This includes demilitarization and the return to Russia of everyone involved in the occupation and shelling in Ukraine. And you know, I don’t care if these people have Ukrainian passports and Ukrainian blood. Otherwise, these murderers will repeat their actions. They are fixated on capturing Odesa - from the Black Sea.

Especially for Espreso

About the author: Maryna Danyliuk-Yarmolaieva, journalist.

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the authors of blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Saturday
12 October
20:08
94 clashes occur on Russian-Ukrainian frontline, with Russia pushing in Kurakhove direction
19:40
OPINION
On war fatigue and ending scenarios
19:15
Military expert comments on North Korean soldiers in Russia
19:02
Exclusive
Russia fails to fully benefit from capturing Vuhledar - former U.S. Army Commander in Europe
18:35
Russian army strikes civilian car with FPV drone in Kupyansk, injuring two
17:59
OPINION
NATO's perspective: Ukraine is not Germany
17:33
Ukrainian football coach awarded Golden Cross killed in action
17:02
Six days later: Crimean oil depot fire still burning after Ukrainian attack
16:33
Exclusive
Three reasons Moscow won't use nuclear weapons, according to political scientist
16:02
Russian army attacks warehouses in Ukraine's Mykolaiv region in random strikes
15:29
Over 300 chaplains from 13 religious organizations serve in Ukraine’s Armed Forces
15:05
Exclusive
Resource factor may play decisive role in battle for Toretsk - military expert
14:43
Interview
War in 19: Ukrainian combat medic Sandra on Hospitallers, her love for people, and Sudzha
14:12
Russia conducts 21 strikes in Donetsk region, killing two, wounding three people
13:40
Review
Russian army conducts assault operations in Kursk region, intensifies offensive with use of equipment in Kupyansk sector. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
13:01
OPINION
What are allies preparing for Ukraine?
12:33
Army chief Syrskyi: "Ukraine has positive dynamic in destroying enemy targets with drones'"
11:59
Russia plans to manufacture Shahed drones at captured factories in Ukraine
11:35
Russian forces attack Ukraine with Shaheds, KABs overnight
10:59
Russia loses 1,290 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
10:33
Ukrainian military destroys Russian fuel depot in Luhansk region
2024, Friday
11 October
21:28
Slovakia intends to expand repair base for Ukrainian military equipment
21:05
Europe won't be secure until Ukraine is in NATO - former U.S. ambassador
20:47
Updated
Ukraine to share list of journalists in Russian captivity with Vatican after Zelenskyy-Pope meeting
20:31
OPINION
What's behind word 'peace'?
20:08
Deceased journalist Roshchyna held in Russian detention center known for brutal torture
19:49
Affiliate Material
Rebuilding Ukraine: Sumy region's recovery from Russian occupation
19:30
Exclusive
Delivery of Mirage 2000-5 fighter jets to Ukraine set to outpace F-16 timeline
19:12
Ukraine’s strikes on ammo depots poise Russia to face shell crisis - Estonian intelligence
18:55
78 clashes occur at front on Oct. 11: Ukraine's General Staff names hottest areas
18:33
Affiliate Material
Reconstruction progress in Odesa region: сompensation timeline, application process
18:10
Scholz pledges €1.4 billion in aid for Ukraine during talks with Zelenskyy
17:51
Exclusive
Russia's advance in Kupyansk sector: Ukrainian military reveals strategic objectives
17:32
Interpol-wanted Islamic State member detained in Kyiv
17:13
Russian troops advance in Toretsk, reinforce defence near Chasiv Yar - Ukrainian military
16:54
Russia damages at least 1,641 schools in Ukraine, destroys 201 more
16:36
OPINION
Is Ukraine just one step from NATO and victory?
16:15
Exclusive
Kim Jong-Un will not send troops to Ukraine due to U.S. threat — Ukrainian general
15:59
Russian troops face logistical crisis following destruction of Feodosia oil depot — Atesh guerrillas
15:41
Exclusive
Ukrainian general names timeline for delivery of French Mirage aircraft
More news