Espreso. Global

Are NATO strategies flawed? Lessons from Ukraine's summer offensive

12 December, 2023 Tuesday
17:20

Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of Ukraine's National Security and Defense Council, questions the effectiveness of NATO strategies after the summer counteroffensive fell short. But, were these strategies flawed from the start?

Defense Express writes about this.

In an interview with the BBC, Danilov acknowledged that optimism about Ukraine's counteroffensive, based on NATO predictions, may have been misplaced. He suggested these “textbooks”, once integral to Ukrainian brigade preparations, might need to be disregarded.

Notably, as of April 2023, the Pentagon had conducted mathematical simulations of Ukraine's counteroffensive, incorporating scientific insights and intelligence data. Command and staff games tested offensive strategies, including practical exercises mirroring potential combat scenarios.

However, the execution fell short, the publication notes. Unrealistic assumptions, such as overcoming dense minefields and countering long-range enemy strikes, were unaddressed. The envisioned total air superiority clashed with the reality of navigating intricate minefields.

In essence, Ukraine's experience raises doubts about the applicability of NATO strategies in real-world scenarios, pointing to critical gaps in planning and execution.

Despite astronomical losses and successful territorial defense, Russia continues to pour resources into war, rendering NATO's concept of air superiority obsolete. Ukraine, with limited tactical aviation and aging anti-aircraft systems, defied the odds against Russia's vast air fleet.

Looking ahead, there are doubts about NATO's confidence in numerical and technological superiority over Russia. The Ukrainian perspective suggests discarding old NATO strategies, highlighting the need for practical tools and unconditional support to counter Russia. Urgent implementation of strict sanctions and holding nations accountable for supporting Moscow is crucial in breaking the Kremlin's influence.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Saturday
24 February
17:50
Exclusive
Putin is forced into conditions where he cannot stop his aggression against Ukraine - General Mussayev
17:21
West's decision to ban Ukraine from striking at Russian territory is wrong - future commander of Estonian army
16:52
Exclusive
New US sanctions against Russia may affect Chinese companies - US politician Fried
16:24
Two years of Ukraine inspiring world: Western leaders on second anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion
15:55
OPINION
Zelenskyy's interview with FOX: main points
15:28
UK intelligence estimates Russian losses over two years of full-scale war in Ukraine
15:00
Ukraine uses American chemical munitions against Russian army: Kremlin media spread another fake
14:32
Exclusive
Diplomat Chaly comments on preparations for 'congress' in Russian-occupied Transnistria
14:04
Review
Ukrainian counterattacks, liberation of territories in south, situation near Avdiivka: weekly military results by Serhiy Zgurets
13:35
Russia deploys dozens of Soviet T-62 tanks to Crimea - Atesh
13:07
ISW assesses risks of invasion of Ukraine from Transnistria
12:39
Exclusive
Aviation expert names complex used by Ukraine to destroy Russian A-50 aircraft
12:11
Ukrainian army destroys 770 Russian soldiers, 36 artillery systems, aircraft - General Staff
11:42
Ukraine intercepts conversation confirming downing of Russian A-50U aircraft
11:15
Ukraine's Air Force destroys 12 Shahed drones, 2 missiles overnight
10:49
Russian Su-34 firing missiles at Ukraine shot down in Kherson region - media
10:24
Updated
Ukraine’s forces target another Russian A-50 radar aircraft
2024, Friday
23 February
21:40
Review
Victorious news of 730th day of war: destroyed Russian Tor-M2 and Strela-10, €1.8bn in military support from Denmark
21:20
Ukrainian army repels 18 Russian attacks in 5 directions - General Staff
21:00
DPRK supplies Russia with 1.5 million ammo produced in 1970s-1980s - Ukrainian intelligence
20:45
Canada announces additional sanctions against Russia
20:15
Russian army destroys almost 500 tons of grain overnight in Donetsk region
19:50
Ukrainian officials arrive at Poland's border, but do not meet with Polish counterparts
19:30
Updated
Russia’s missiles, attack drones kill at least four in Ukraine
19:12
Exclusive
Japan provides record aid to Ukraine, thus supporting US and EU - Zhevago
18:50
Ukrainians, your fight is our fight: Polish media thanks Ukraine for resisting Russian aggression
18:20
Ukraine war is giant Ponzi scheme: fake news for February 23
17:50
Russian forces use chemical weapons in Tavria sector - General Tarnavskyi
17:20
What long-range weapons can Germany provide to Ukraine?
16:50
Russia can use almost 300 combat aircraft against Ukraine - intelligence
16:20
Situation in eastern Ukraine isn't critical - Ukrainian military
15:51
Exclusive
Putin promises to give Transcarpathia to Orban as loyal ally - former Aidar battalion commander
15:30
Zelenskyy arrives in Lviv, signs security agreement with Danish PM Frederiksen
15:10
Biden announces new sanctions on Russia for second anniversary of full-scale invasion
14:55
Exclusive
Russian troops afraid to move around Avdiivka even after capturing city - military expert Zgurets
14:36
British intelligence explains why Putin needs to "clean up" information space in Russia
14:13
Exclusive
Scholz holds key: Military expert Zgurets reveals number of Taurus missiles Ukraine could acquire
13:58
Zelenskyy names reasons for Zaluzhnyi's resignation and change of military command
13:34
Pro-Soviet narratives imposed on deported Ukrainian children in camps in Belarus - Skhemy
13:14
 OSCE opens Living The War exhibition on Russian war crimes
More news