Espreso. Global

What’s behind Trump’s claim to end war in 24 hours

8 November, 2024 Friday
20:41

The world misunderstood Trump’s words about “ending the war in 24 hours.” According to journalist Orest Sohar, the Republican leader was referring to a simple ceasefire, not an actual resolution. In reality, Ukraine could remain in a state of war with Russia for years to come, much like the ATO

client/title.list_title

Trump's intention to “end the war quickly” is starting to take shape. The latest reports from his campaign headquarters, shared by The Wall Street Journal, shed light on his plans. Sohar, summarizing these reports, outlines the proposed plan.

The plan involves freezing active hostilities, even if it means making significant concessions from Kyiv. The proposal includes handing over 20% of the occupied territories to Moscow and preventing Kyiv from seeking NATO membership — for 20 years, according to one version, or possibly indefinitely, according to another.

Sources suggest that Trump might also block Ukraine's integration into other "allied institutions," effectively the EU.

Once the front lines are frozen, the proposal includes establishing a 1,287-kilometer demilitarized zone between Ukraine’s Defense Forces and Russian troops, though it’s unclear who would control this area.

Formally, Trump’s main leverage is arms supplies. According to Sohar, to pressure Kyiv, Trump could stop sending weapons; to provoke Moscow, he might instead give the Ukrainian Armed Forces unlimited access to American arsenals.

However, Sohar notes that war is not like a presidential limousine that can be stopped overnight, because the aggressor and the defenders have very different views of justice.

No matter how difficult the situation may be, the Ukrainian government will not sign an act of partial surrender, giving up a fifth of its territory or, for example, agreeing to reduce the size of its Armed Forces, as Moscow would like. In politics, such demands turn into a long, drawn-out negotiation process, where the final decisions will likely be left to the next generation of leaders. Sohar points out that something similar was planned in the Istanbul agreements, where Donbas and Crimea were supposed to receive special status for years, until some future resolution could be worked out.

The "freeze plan" doesn’t address the security guarantees that Ukraine has been seeking, the wording of which has been crafted with the help of European partners. The lack of security guarantees is a major risk, leaving the door open for renewed aggression from Moscow.

It is becoming clear that Trump is not willing to offer Ukraine strong guarantees, neither NATO membership nor the status of the Alliance's main partner. Therefore, Brussels and Kyiv will need time to negotiate a local security agreement. Sohar suggests that the UK, Poland, the Baltic states, and possibly France could be involved. From today’s perspective, this is the most that can realistically be expected.

Putin will also complicate Trump’s situation by presenting his own wish list. If Washington fully meets Moscow’s demands, the Kremlin's leader will appear as the victor, while the new president will look like a loser who capitulated to dark forces. 

This is yet another reason why the White House will likely need to keep the situation "frozen" for a while — giving time to establish relations with the Kremlin.

In other words, Trump’s “freeze diplomacy” seeks to end the hot phase of the war by shifting the toughest battles to diplomats. First, the two sides will agree to stop shelling civilian infrastructure and exchange prisoners. After that, Sohar suggests, who knows — maybe an American ultimatum to pull back.

  • On November 6, Volodymyr Zelenskyy spoke positively about Donald Trump's victory in his evening address. He noted that “we have the potential for stronger cooperation.”
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Thursday
21 November
18:11
Over 60 Crimean political prisoners need urgent medical care
17:50
ICC issues arrest warrants for Israeli PM Netanyahu, Defense Minister Gallant, Hamas leader Deif
17:31
OPINION
Moscow targets Western minds with Rubezh missile
17:13
EU comments on Russia's use of intercontinental ballistic missile against Ukraine
17:03
Updated
Russia may have used Rubezh intercontinental ballistic missile in attack on Ukraine's Dnipro
16:56
Ukraine approves bill allowing voluntary return to service for first-time AWOL
16:35
Ukraine commemorates 20 years since Orange Revolution on Day of Dignity and Freedom
16:13
Exclusive
Is Rubezh missile used to strike Ukraine's Dnipro Russia's new "wunderwaffe"?
15:54
Volunteer-turned-spy sentenced to 15 years for FSB espionage
15:34
Russia strikes administrative building in Kryvyi Rih, injuring 26, including children
15:17
OPINION
Beijing supplies weapons to Moscow: how to explain it to Trump?
14:54
Ukrainian minister outlines conditions for Ukraine resuming flights
13:48
Russia’s Doppelgänger disinformation campaign linked to defense ministry
13:40
Russia promotes plan to West dividing Ukraine into three parts, threatening its statehood
13:16
Hungary to deploy additional air defense systems near Ukrainian border
12:56
Ukraine experiences nationwide Internet speed drop following S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 release
12:33
153 combat clashes erupt on Russia-Ukraine frontline, with 34 in Pokrovsk sector
12:16
OPINION
How Ukraine's Kursk operation shattered Russia's hopes to freeze war
11:58
Exclusive
Life in a frontline city: curfews and struggles of daily life in Kherson
11:42
Exclusive
Russian troops advance to Oskil River in some areas, says Kupyansk official
11:27
Exclusive
Biden, Trump coordinated to authorize Ukraine’s ATACMS use, says Ukrainian officer
10:59
Review
Why embassies in Kyiv closed, what is Russia's Rubezh missile, and defective mines. Serhiy Zgurets' column
10:33
Exclusive
Kremlin will be afraid to use nukes – Ukrainian Major Omelyan
10:15
Russia loses 50 artillery systems, 8 tanks and 1,510 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
09:55
Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant near blackout after Russian strike damages power line
09:38
Russia targets Ukraine with missiles, hitting Dnipro rehabilitation center
2024, Wednesday
20 November
21:45
Ukraine returns 3,767 citizens from Russian captivity since February 2022
21:26
Exclusive
'Kremlin realizes that time plays against them': political analyst on power shift in U.S.
21:11
800 people remain in embattled Kurakhove, Donetsk region
20:52
OPINION
Where are sanctions against Rosatom?
20:36
Low-quality mines are delivered to frontline, journalist Butusov says
20:20
Russian military executes Ukrainian POWs in Kursk region, Ombudsman reacts
20:06
South Korea reports North Korean soldiers assigned to Russian airborne, naval brigades
19:50
Ukraine likely used Storm Shadow missiles to target Russian presidential facility in Kursk region
19:35
Ukrainian Air Force Su-24, probably with Storm Shadow missiles, summer 2023, image from open sources
Ukraine uses British Storm Shadow missiles against Russia for first time - media
19:20
Exclusive
Russia’s potential deployment of RS-26 Rubezh missile sparks grounded alarm - expert
19:01
Poland prepares 45th support package for Ukraine - Prime Minister Tusk
18:45
North Korean soldiers rape teacher in Russia's Kursk region
18:25
Greenpeace: new Russian strikes on Ukrainian substations may lead to large-scale blackouts 
18:08
Germany announces new military aid package for Ukraine: what's included
More news