Espreso. Global

US disappointed in Israel's preparations for Hamas attack, investigating intelligence failures

8 October, 2023 Sunday
13:40

Despite prior warnings indicating that Palestinian militants were preparing an attack, and the fact that the US had granted Israel USD 3.3 billion for defense in 2022, Israel was not adequately prepared for an effective defense

client/title.list_title

Bloomberg reported the information.

The attack by the Palestinian group Hamas on Israel could be one of the biggest failures of Israeli intelligence since the 1973 Yom Kippur War, according to American experts.

"It’s shocking to me that they were able to do it without Israel or the United States picking up on it. Failure to prepare. Failure to have troops along the border, failure of the fence along the border that they paid millions of shekels for," said Martin Indyk, a former US ambassador to Israel and a fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.

Israeli officials have been saying for months that Hamas was preparing to commit terrorism, announcing the time and scale of the attack, but Israel's leadership was not prepared for effective resistance, despite the fact that the US has allocated USD 3.3 billion for Israel's defense in 2022. The US compares the attack to the Yom Kippur War in 1973, when Israel was unable to repel a surprise attack by Egypt and Syria on the Jewish holiday of Yom Kippur. Israeli officials rejected any comparison to 1973.

"Please don’t give Hamas the sophistication of the Yom Kippur War. I know there are a lot of questions about the intelligence. Please stop asking. Right now we’re fighting. I’m sure there will be a lot of discussions about the intelligence down the road," said IDF spokesman Richard Hecht.

One of the reasons for Israel's lack of readiness to defend may have been that it was a national holiday in the country or that the Israeli army and intelligence services’ attention was diverted to internal matters.

"The real problem here is likely that the Israelis simply did not believe that Hamas would risk a cross-border infiltration. The lack of sufficient Israeli forces in that area was a grievous failure," said Aaron David Miller, senior fellow at the Carnegie endowment for international peace and a former state department Middle East negotiator.

Events in Israel: latest updates

On the morning of Saturday, October 7, 2023, the Palestinian armed groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad launched a massive air and land attack on the state of Israel in several places. The head of the Hamas military wing, Mohammed Deif, said that his militants had launched the Al-Aqsa Flood operation. According to him, these actions are intended to protect the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem.

The Palestinians launched 2,000 to 3,000 missiles at Israel and simultaneously seized 7 communities in the south.

In response, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) announced the mobilization of reservists and the launch of the Iron Swords counterterrorism operation. For the first time in 50 years, the government introduced martial law in the country

The IDF actively used aviation to strike Palestinian command posts. It has also begun clearing Hamas-occupied communities.

In addition, there is a great threat that the Shiite Hezbollah could attack Israel from the north, as its main partner and supplier, the Islamic Republic of Iran (IRI), has called on jihadists to "liberate Jerusalem."

On the morning of October 8, the Saudi television channel Al Arabiya published the losses of both Palestinians and Israelis during the first day of the renewed military conflict. According to the channel, Israel lost 300 people killed and at least 1,600 wounded. The number of casualties from the Palestinian-populated Gaza Strip is 232 killed and 1,627 wounded. 

On October 8, Israeli troops claimed that Lebanon had attacked their territory, so the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) attacked in response. In particular, Israeli aviation struck a complex belonging to the head of Hamas' intelligence.

Militants of the Lebanese military-political organization Hezbollah fired at Israeli positions on the border with the disputed Golan Heights and supported Hamas in its operation against Israel.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Tuesday
14 January
21:40
Exclusive
Trump to nullify International Criminal Court warrant by meeting with Putin - expert
21:25
Zelenskyy releases video showing interrogation of captured North Korean soldier
21:10
South Korea ready to take DPRK soldiers captured by Ukraine
20:52
OPINION
Biden took the “safe route”
20:30
NATO starts Baltic Sentry mission, Tusk announces increased presence
20:07
46% of Ukrainians prioritize NATO membership over EU accession – KIIS survey
19:46
Exclusive
“Breaking new ground”: Defense Express on Ukraine’s largest strike on Russian military targets
19:25
Updated
Ukrainian Air Force technicians report mass transfers to infantry; General Staff responds
19:06
Volker expects “decisive approach” in Trump’s Ukraine policy
18:45
Depletion of Russian air defense exposes rear regions to strikes
18:24
Ukrainian exports entered 16 new markets in 2024
17:59
Slovak opposition to call no-confidence vote against Fico government over shift to Russia
17:38
Russia’s military aviation: What happens to 1,100 aircraft not in combat over Ukraine?
17:13
Ukraine may cease to exist in 2025, negotiations should be with U.S., says Putin's aide. Ukraine responds
16:52
Military exercises in Gomel District, Belarus, pose no threat to Ukraine – SBGS
16:34
Ukraine sets up 36 working groups to prepare for EU membership negotiations
16:14
Russian "court" sentences seven Ukrainian POWs involved in Kursk operation
16:03
Updated
Ukraine launches massive strike on Russian military targets, up to 1,100 km deep
15:57
Russian agents exploit families of Ukrainian POWs for sabotage
15:37
Exclusive
'Trump is unpredictable but farsighted': VOA's Myroslava Gongadze on Greenland controversy
15:16
Russian oil tankers stalled as U.S. sanctions bite
14:52
Ukraine's largest long-range strike to date hits key Russian military and industrial sites
14:38
Ukraine exports almost $25 billion worth of goods to EU in 2024
14:17
OPINION
Mobilization of 18-year-olds: the West's excuses for its own failures
13:50
Exclusive
From Bryansk to Kazan: Ukraine targets Russian defense industry with precision strikes
13:31
OPINION
Biden in his last presidency days finishes off Russian economy
13:03
Review
Ukraine receives world's most advanced self-propelled gun from Germany: Column by Serhiy Zgurets
12:42
Exclusive
Challenges in Kursk region now are future challenges for Seoul – military expert Selezniov
12:23
OPINION
Fico, Szijjártó, and Orbán use "gas" statements to portray Ukraine as unreliable. Vitaly Portnikov column
11:53
Ukraine repels 77 Russian attacks near Pokrovsk, 166 clashes along frontline
11:36
Exclusive
All border settlements with Russia destroyed: Ukrainian border guard on Sumy situation
11:12
Exclusive
China builds icebreaking navy: expert Lakiychuk on Arctic struggle
10:53
Russian troops cut two roads in Donetsk to push Ukrainian forces from Pokrovsk, Myrnohrad — ISW
10:33
Germany's Defense Minister Pistorius makes unannounced visit to Kyiv
10:14
Biden and Zelenskyy highlight historic U.S. presidential visit to Ukraine in new video
09:34
Russian army loses 1,330 troops, 3 tanks, 47 artillery systems in day of war in Ukraine
2025, Monday
13 January
20:55
Russia accuses Ukraine of attack on gas station in Krasnodar, Hungary calls it threat to sovereignty
20:38
Slovakia: a student with Ukrainian symbols refused to shake the president's hand
20:36
UK to fund Ukraine’s production of air defense systems, long-range weapons
20:18
Iran in secret talks with Russia for assistance on nuclear program – media
More news