Espreso. Global
OPINION

Fico, Szijjártó, and Orbán use "gas" statements to portray Ukraine as unreliable. Vitaly Portnikov column

14 January, 2025 Tuesday
12:23

It would be more profitable for Hungary to source gas from global exchanges, as Russian gas is more expensive. In reality, the claims about an alleged Ukrainian attack on the TurkStream are likely intended to portray Kyiv as unreliable

client/title.list_title

Russia's Ministry of Defense accused Ukraine of a drone attack on the "Ruskaya" gas compressor station in the Krasnodar region of Russia. This station is part of the infrastructure connected to the TurkStream route, which is essentially the last Russian pipeline supplying gas to Turkey, Hungary, and other countries in Southern Europe. It should be noted that Kyiv has not commented on the Russian Ministry of Defense's statement, but it was immediately addressed in Budapest.

Clearly, Hungary's Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó, one of Viktor Orbán's closest allies, immediately blamed Kyiv for undermining Europe's energy security and emphasized the importance of maintaining stable gas supplies to European countries, particularly Hungary. It is telling that the foreign minister made these remarks and accusations against Ukraine before waiting for any official comments from the Ukrainian side, solely based on the statement from Russia's Ministry of Defense. This aligns with the efforts of Hungarian and Slovak prime ministers in recent weeks to not only portray Ukraine as unreliable in negotiations but also suggest that Kyiv seeks to undermine Europe's energy security.

Before January 1, 2025, when the transit contract between Russia's Gazprom and Ukraine's Naftogaz expired, Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico made accusations and threats against Kyiv, even visiting Russian President Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin. Fico blamed Ukraine for the suspension of transit, not Moscow, where the decision to start the large-scale war against Ukraine and consequently the severing of all energy and economic relations was made. According to Fico, Kyiv rejected the deal on gas transit proposed by Bratislava and, presumably, Moscow as well. Kyiv did not agree to substitute Russian gas in Ukrainian pipelines with so-called Azerbaijani gas, despite the fact that Baku does not have additional gas volumes to facilitate transit through Ukraine's gas transportation system.

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán unexpectedly joined the criticism of Kyiv's refusal to extend gas transit through the Ukrainian gas transportation system. This is notable given that, even before the large-scale attack on Ukraine, he had already reached an agreement with Moscow on a new gas contract.

It is worth noting that this is a preferential contract under which gas supplies to Hungary occur via the TurkStream. Moreover, Gazprom set the condition of changing the transit route as a key part of its offer to provide Budapest with a discount on Russian gas. This is despite the fact that the current price of Russian gas is higher than the price of gas that can be purchased on global markets.

Thus, we can talk not so much about the benefits for Hungary or Slovakia, but rather about the involvement of their elites in yet another round of Russian corrupt energy deals. However, even from this perspective, it remains completely unclear why Viktor Orbán was so concerned about the fate of transit through Ukraine's gas transportation system when the Hungarian Prime Minister was actually interested in having gas for his country supplied via a completely different route, independent of Ukraine.

Now we understand why Viktor Orbán not only wanted to assist Robert Fico in his unprecedented attack on Ukraine but also sought to continue demonstrating that Ukraine's leadership is irresponsible. It is worth recalling that this was related to Orbán's statements about the so-called Christmas ceasefire, which he claimed to have negotiated with Russian President Vladimir Putin, while Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy rejected such an agreement.

And now Budapest continues the same line of creating an image of an unreliable and dangerous Ukraine. Just hours after the Russian Ministry of Defense's statement about the alleged Ukrainian attack on the TurkStream (which, in this statement, specifically refers to Russian territory), Hungary's Foreign Minister who, by the way, is the only foreign minister of an EU and NATO member country to have regularly visited Moscow throughout the three years of the full-scale Russian-Ukrainian war joins in with the accusations from the Russian Ministry. By doing so, he essentially legitimizes these claims, leaving no doubt that they are truthful and accurate.

Péter Szijjártó doesn't even attempt to contact his Ukrainian counterpart, Andrii Sybiha, or any other Ukrainian official to at least find out the details of whether such an attack actually occurred or whether it truly posed a threat to Hungary's security regarding Russian gas supplies.

I won't even mention that Orbán's country should have long since rejected Russian fuel: of course, such a complex moral choice is hardly something for the far-right politicians of today, who dream of restoring relations with Russia to the pre-2022 period and hope that, soon, a new American administration of which Viktor Orbán is an ally will create the conditions for such economic recovery.

But even for Szijjártó's diplomatic statement to appear not as propaganda, but as a genuine expression of concern, it would have been worth finding out the Ukrainian side's response to the Russian Ministry of Defense's statement.

Of course, this would be the approach if the goal was to truly understand the situation with gas supplies in Hungary, rather than merely becoming another mouthpiece for portraying Ukraine as dangerous and unreliable.

Source

About the author. Vitaly Portnikov, journalist, winner of the Shevchenko National Prize of Ukraine

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Saturday
15 February
19:45
U.S. to mediate Ukraine-Russia talks, no direct role for Europe — Kellogg
19:23
Russia ramps up attacks on Ukraine to boost leverage as Munich Conference unfolds
19:00
Exclusive
U.S. lacks capacity to counter Russia, China — diplomat
18:37
Exclusive
Fixing frontline doesn’t mean renouncing Ukraine’s 1991 borders — diplomat Fried
18:19
Trump envoy Kellogg pledges 180 days to end war in Ukraine
18:00
Russia must withdraw to Ukraine’s pre-full-scale invasion borders — Zelenskyy
17:41
Trump team proposes deploying U.S. troops to protect Ukraine’s rare earth mineral deposits
17:17
OPINION
Trump doesn’t like Zelenskyy: how presidential sympathies may shape Ukraine's future
16:50
Exclusive
U.S. pledges air support for Europe if Russia launches new offensive — diplomat Fried
16:29
Putin reportedly planning 'end of Ukraine war' concert in Moscow this summer
16:08
Exclusive
Ukrainian territory concessions may trigger Russian aggression in Baltic states — diplomat
15:45
Group of European countries quietly drafting plan to deploy troops to Ukraine
15:24
OPINION
Trump's election proposal for Ukraine may play right into Putin's hands
15:02
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 29 – February 5
Russian forces intensify attempts to cross Oskil River using boats, makeshift rafts — Achilles Regiment
14:41
Human rights organizations react to Zelenskyy’s sanctions on Poroshenko, Zhevago, Kolomoisky, Bogolyubov
14:23
Ukraine wouldn’t have lost 4,000 km² of territory if U.S. hadn’t delayed aid — Zelenskyy
14:00
'Without Ukraine’s army, Europe alone can’t stop Russia': Zelenskyy calls for creation of European Armed Forces
13:52
Exclusive
Ukrainian woman takes her life to avoid collaborating with Russian forces in occupied Kherson
13:29
Review
Ukrainians learn to defend against guided bombs: how Soviet-era ZU-23-2 guns help counter Russian threat
13:07
Review
Ukraine must expand its army to 1.5 million troops without U.S., EU security guarantees. Serhiy Zgurets' column
12:45
Exclusive
Trump administration caves to all of Putin’s demands on Ukraine — political analyst
12:27
OPINION
Zelenskyy fears both Trump and his own people
12:10
Hungary blocks launch of Ukraine’s EU membership talks
11:53
Ukraine reports 112 clashes at front on Feb. 14, repels 36 Russian assaults in Pokrovsk sector
11:31
Russia reports drone attack on 4 regions: fire breaks out at industrial site in Kaluga
11:14
Ukrainian Air Force strikes Russian platoon strongpoint in Kursk region
10:56
Exclusive
White House sees Europe, not Russia, as key rival: international journalist on Munich Conference
10:35
Russia loses 1,180 soldiers, 59 artillery systems, air defense system in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Friday
14 February
22:53
Russians angered by lack of official updates on Bryansk explosions – Ukraine's intel
22:38
We seek lasting peace: U.S. VP Vance after meeting Zelenskyy as Ukrainian president ready for “real peace”
22:13
Writers from Ukraine, Poland, Germany, and Kazakhstan withdraw from Indian festival in protest of Russian participants
22:00
Exclusive
Chornobyl NPP attack: Consequences of Russia's strike have been contained
21:52
Chornobyl NPP safety at risk: History of protective arch and its ability to withstand impacts
21:33
Ukraine to be immediately accepted into NATO if Russia attacks again, says Senator Graham
21:15
Moldova hopes for Russian troop withdrawal from Transnistria as part of Ukraine peace talks
20:55
Exclusive
Europe realizes it must shoulder lion's share of responsibility — Ukraine's former PM
20:30
U.S. has never seen Ukraine in NATO, Zelenskyy says
20:14
Ukraine reveals details of experimental contract with Armed Forces for citizens under 25
19:51
“We’re more confident than before”: Zelenskyy reports improvement on critical Pokrovsk front
19:32
Russia's military transport aviation in crisis: Challenges and failures
More news