Espreso. Global
OPINION

Offensive on Kharkiv. Russians are learning

16 May, 2024 Thursday
14:22

But what kind of Russians? Soldiers at the tactical level, commanders at the operational level, but do stupid Soviet generals learn and can they learn at the strategic level?

client/title.list_title

Actually, I don't believe in it, but we will be able to see for ourselves in the coming months in Kharkiv.

The fact is that an attack on Kharkiv would be a colossal strategic miscalculation by the Russian command. Why? Because it already happened in February 2022. Now the Russians are attacking along the entire front: Robotyne, Krynky, Vuhledar direction, Chasiv Yar, Krasnohorivka, Kupyansk direction. They suffer huge losses every day and need huge replenishment.

 And in the absence of major breakthroughs, they open up another direction. Of course, the goal is to stretch Ukrainian resources. But we are defending ourselves and suffer much less losses. So for the Russians, this means another area of losses in equipment and people, which must be constantly replenished.

I understand that many "smart people" will now start writing to me, saying something about Putin's unlimited meat and resources. I heard it all back in March ‘22, when I argued that the Russians would have to retreat in many areas. There are no unlimited resources, and the more they are spent, the sooner they will run out.

Putin does not like defeats, even the smallest ones. Therefore, there must be advancement in all directions, which means even more forces and resources, which in fact are simply spread over a very long distance of the frontline. At the same time, each kilometer of advance costs hundreds of soldiers and dozens of equipment units.

So, in fact, the opening of the Kharkiv direction is a strategic mistake that they have already made. It was the spreading of troops on 7 invasion directions that led to the disaster of Putin's plans in 2022.

Now for a bit of unpleasant truth. At the strategic level, war looks completely different. It requires maneuvering, stretching the Russian forces, sacrificing something, imposing unwanted battles on them, exhausting them, etc. Therefore, the first and foremost thing that everyone should learn is that a lost territory or settlement is not a catastrophe or defeat. Yes, these are our lands, yes, these are our people, but we need to think about how to win the war, not every battle that the enemy imposes. We are smaller, and with disabled partners, we will never win a war head-on. We need to maneuver, retreat somewhere, counterattack somewhere. The war can only be won by inflicting losses on the enemy that will prevent them from continuing to fight. This is the law of war, which does not depend on our wishes.

As of now, the occupiers' grouping in the Kharkiv direction is almost the same size as in Chasiv Yar. However, Kharkiv is not Chasiv Yar, where the Russian advance is stalled. Therefore, it is obvious that no large-scale offensive on Kharkiv is currently planned. The enemy's goal is to capture a number of settlements and bind Ukrainian forces in their attempts to recapture them.

So should we go along with this plan, when the real direction of the orcs' attack is Chasiv Yar and Vuhledar?

As a military man, I can tell you that I had a full understanding of the Russian actions in the Kharkiv region from the inside. Believe me, they were expected, and the defense forces are more than sufficient. There is a certain plan that our command is implementing, and the Kharkiv direction is a story in which you should trust the Ukrainian Armed Forces. And there is no need to get hysterical at the first bad news. Unfortunately, I am less optimistic about other areas.

Western aid has reached us in a very limited form. If we had everything that has already been allocated, the occupiers would not even be able to cross the border. But this is not the case. When you start writing about mining, you don't realize that we already have serious problems even with mines. And fighting with limited resources and exhausted brigades is really about military talent.

So, amid the bad news about the occupied villages of Kharkiv region, there is also good news - the Russians  continue to be led by the same stupid creatures who planned the worst invasion operation in history. Sooner or later, this will affect the war. Just like it did in ‘22.

Source

About the author. Victor Andrusiv, political and public figure, analyst and publicist.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Thursday
9 January
21:30
Russia's attack on Zaporizhzhia causes highest civilian casualties in two years - UN mission
21:15
Exclusive
Russia loses fuel for strategic aviation after drones damage Engels oil depot
20:58
Exclusive
Penalties, export bans kill Ukraine's defense industry - MP Yanchenko
20:41
Exclusive
War for Arctic, Antarctic: diplomat on Trump's statements on Greenland
20:25
OPINION
Zelenskyy explains civilizational difference between Ukraine and Russia
20:08
IRIS-T air defense system
Germany to donate 6 IRIS-T systems to Ukraine in 2025
19:51
United Kingdom, allies to provide Ukraine with 30,000 drones
19:34
Exclusive
Russia struggles to replenish resources despite limitless supplies of men
19:15
OPINION
Trump: realist who knows the world isn’t Hollywood movie
18:58
Russia steps up mobilization in occupied Zaporizhzhia, Kherson regions - intelligence
18:41
New law allows military reinstatement after AWOL until March 1
18:25
Exclusive
'Negotiating trick': expert on Trump's statements on Canada, Greenland, Panama
18:06
Ukraine recognizes genocide of Circassian people by Russian Empire
17:50
Updated
Zelenskyy calls for deployment of partner contingents in Ukraine
17:47
Biden ramps up Ukraine support with new sanctions, military aid ahead of Trump’s presidency
17:29
Exclusive
Ramstein 25: military analyst warns of potential shift in format
17:09
Ramstein meeting approves roadmaps defining Ukraine's strategic goals through 2027
16:50
Russian intel accused of funding Afghan terrorist groups to target U.S., coalition forces
16:32
Exclusive
Trump’s Greenland, Panama statements tied to countering China's ambitions — expert
16:20
Updated
Russia bombs Zaporizhzhia, killing at least 13, injuring over 100
16:15
Musk-Weidel interview: Rallying point for far-right supporters and pro-Kremlin messaging
15:56
Austin unveils last U.S. aid package for Ukraine under Biden
15:31
Ukraine's Armed Forces receive €538M in weapons via "Danish model" in 2024
15:16
Ukraine to receive AI-powered FDI FALCON 127M combat module for battlefield control
14:55
Russian airstrike on Ukraine's Kherson leaves civilians injured
14:33
Russian propaganda films to screen in Italy, Ukraine responds
14:15
Ukraine passes bill for women in military registry, easier registration for young men abroad
13:52
Romanian presidential elections rescheduled for May 4 after alleged foreign influence results canceled
13:32
Ukraine’s 47th Brigade repels massive Russian assault in Kursk: video
13:14
Exclusive
Aside from Pokrovsk, Russia eyes three other key directions — military expert
12:54
"Big work ahead": Umerov meets Austin ahead of Ramstein meeting
12:30
OPINION
As Russia revises borders, U.S. could reclaim Arctic sovereignty — but will Trump stand up to Putin?
12:07
North Korea gains war experience against neighbors by fighting Ukraine, U.S. warns
11:50
Russian oil spill may reach Ukrainian shores in Odesa, Mykolaiv — official
11:32
Review
Strikes on Engels oil depot, Trump's unexpected remarks, and last "Ramstein" under Biden. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:12
OPINION
Nuclear weapons for Ukraine: How propaganda affects the grasp of reality
10:51
Ex-FBI informant, who falsely claimed Biden took Ukrainian bribe, sentenced to 6 years
10:32
192 clashes at frontline: Ukrainian army repels 42 attacks near Pokrovsk, 48 in Kursk
10:13
Exclusive
Russian troops struggle to secure foothold on Oskil's right bank — Ukrainian officer
09:56
Biden administration likely to miss spending billions from Ukraine aid package — Pentagon
More news