Espreso. Global
OPINION

Ukraine - Poland. We should change our mindset about history

4 March, 2024 Monday
13:35

Is historical background one of the reasons for the current deterioration of relations between Ukraine and Poland? Yes

client/title.list_title

But I definitely don't mean the primitive explanation that history shows that the Poles have always disliked us.

Because in fact, the historical relations between Ukrainians and Poles mirror those between any neighboring nations. They encompass a spectrum of enmity, animosity, wars, cooperation, and shared struggles.

It falls upon us, the present generation, to determine how to utilize this historical experience, discerning what is worth replicating and treasuring, and what to remember to ensure a "never again" scenario. Thus, current relations are not solely influenced by history; history stands as immutable, it is something that has already occurred and cannot be changed.

What is important is our attitude to history.

The manner in which for the last fifteen years Polish politicians have predominantly portrayed the historical relationship between our peoples, focusing largely on the prism of conflict, indeed fosters an atmosphere conducive to misunderstandings. This approach reinforces the thesis that Ukrainians are seen as neighbors who cannot be trusted.

The issue not only lies in emphasizing the conflict in history but also in the one-sided dimension through which it is viewed – attributing blame solely to Ukrainians while presenting Poles as victims.

This goes beyond distorting the historical truth regarding the longstanding confrontation between the two nations. It also solidifies a relational model where one side, claiming victimhood, absolves itself entirely of responsibility for its own mistakes. Meanwhile, the opponent's perspective is dismissed outright: everything they assert is a falsehood and an intentional cover-up of crimes.

In political discussions about the past, another destructive element has persisted, extending far beyond history into current relations: the belief that Poland can, and even must, impose its perspective on Ukrainians for cooperation to be possible.

But just the opposite is true: with an "my way or the highway" approach, it is impossible to build equal relations, which are the key to fruitful cooperation.

Can a proper understanding of our difficult past help to resolve the current difficulties in our relations?

I am sure it can.

Because the main conclusion from our common past remains extremely relevant: in the Polish-Ukrainian confrontation, the third party always wins, and this third party has been and can be Russia.

Source

About the author. Volodymyr Viatrovych, historian, Member of the Ukrainian Parliament.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Friday
23 May
18:21
Ukraine, U.S. officially launch Investment Fund under minerals agreement
18:00
Review
Living legend of Ukraine’s liberation struggle: Story of 94-year-old Ihor Oleshchuk
17:49
Updated
Russian ballistic missile strike on Odesa port leaves one dead, multiple injured
17:22
Updated
Ukraine returns 390 military, civilians as part of POW exchange with Russia
17:16
Russian troops execute two Ukrainian POWs in Donetsk region
16:55
Exclusive
U.S. Republicans may lose patience after Russia snubs Vatican talks
16:32
How Ukraine’s Energia plant strike mirrors WWII targeting dilemma faced by allied forces
16:13
Ukraine aims to start exhumation work in Poland this year
15:54
OPINION
Europeans are Ukraine’s key allies, top EU leaders publicly declare
15:33
Updated
Ukraine confirms strike on Energia plant in Russia’s Lipetsk region
15:30
EU begins closed-door talks on 18th sanctions package against Russia – media
15:10
Orban opposes Ukraine’s EU bid, claims it would "soak up resources like a sponge"
14:46
Russian FM rejects Vatican as “unrealistic” venue for peace talks with Ukraine
14:18
Russia revives claim of illegal Soviet Union's collapse: ISW explains why
14:01
Exclusive
Ukrainian drone activity near Moscow signals key development — military expert
13:43
OPINION
Trump and Putin: bond dating back to 2016
13:09
Ukrainian Raybird-3 drone to hunt Russian air defenses with new tech
12:50
Exclusive
Russian forces ordered to advance wherever possible — Ukrainian military
12:32
German firm skirts sanctions, ships tech to Russia through Slovenia
12:14
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces seek to establish 'buffer zone' inside Russia from Sumy region
11:57
Russian guided bomb strike kills utility worker in Ukraine's Kupiansk
11:40
Russia won’t get frozen assets back until it pays reparations to Ukraine — G7 statement
11:23
OPINION
Trump believes Putin
11:05
EU must prepare for possible Russian offensive — General Robert Brieger
10:46
Ukraine shouldn’t expect return to pre-war borders, Zaluzhnyi says
10:28
Exclusive
Russia producing 100–150 missiles monthly, poised for deployment — expert
09:51
Russia loses 1,050 soldiers, 43 artillery systems, 2 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
09:34
G7 ministers vow to ramp up pressure on Russia if it rejects ceasefire
2025, Thursday
22 May
21:40
Over 20% of Ukrainians say they are fully willing to defend country in combat — poll
21:20
Armored assaults return: Ukrainian brigade thwarts Russian push in Kharkiv sector
21:05
Exclusive
Ukraine may destroy at least three Russian Tu-95MS bombers soon
20:55
Updated
Putin announces work on creating 'buffer zone' along Ukrainian border. Kyiv reacts
20:35
Trump finds ending Russia-Ukraine war more complex than he thought
20:18
Exclusive
U.S. diplomat Herbst: Congress would pressure Trump if aid stopped
20:12
Updated
Ukraine, Russia trade POW lists in bid for 1,000-for-1,000 swap
19:59
OPINION
On Putin’s readiness to end war and Trump as mediator
19:20
Ukraine retrieves nine children from Russian-occupied territories, including sisters held indoors for nearly three years
19:06
69 battles recorded on Ukrainian front, Russian forces active near Pokrovsk
18:50
Exclusive
Russia may be forced to negotiate with U.S. after summer offensive falters — political scientist
18:31
Russia moves to link occupied Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant to its power grid
More news