Espreso. Global
OPINION

Why is G20 joint statement dangerous for Ukraine?

12 September, 2023 Tuesday
21:05

We are entering a new stage in the fight against the Russian aggressor, when emotions will no longer have such a powerful effect as in the first days of the full-scale invasion

client/title.list_title

In the days leading up to the G20 Summit in New Delhi on September 9-10, the world was watching the diplomatic struggle over the wording of the "Ukrainian part" of the final joint statement with great concern. Several times, the negotiators approached a "deadlock" and the prospect of refusing to approve the final document as a whole, which would be a sign of the failure of the summit and the foreign policy fiasco of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Consultations took place at all levels, including the Group's leaders.

The compromise satisfied all the participants of the summit, but disappointed Ukrainian diplomacy, which, not without reason, saw significant foreign policy risks and threats.

First, the compromise wording of the "Ukrainian part" of the statement was a significant step backwards in the G20's position on the protracted war compared to the last Bali summit, which condemned Russian aggression against Ukraine and called for the immediate withdrawal of Russian troops from the temporarily occupied territories. This text also undermines the consensus on UN General Assembly resolutions condemning Russian aggression and calling for its immediate cessation.

"There is a threat that the "Indian common denominator" of the G20 will become a new benchmark for many UN members, especially those in the Global South, and will be actively and effectively used, first and foremost, by Russian diplomacy in its efforts to dilute the next initiatives of the Ukrainian side."

Second, the diminishing potential of Western diplomacy to influence the positions of the Global South on such an acute international issue as Russia's brutal violation of the UN Charter, in particular the principle of territorial integrity, and its numerous war crimes on the territory of Ukraine is of great concern. Whether it was a "goodwill gesture" by the West in favor of Modi, especially in the context of the 2024 Indian elections, or a real failure of Western leaders to convince their "southern" counterparts, the "Indian common denominator" marginalizes the issue of Russian aggression against Ukraine on the agenda of world leaders.

Third, the results of the G20 summit not only significantly complicate the tasks of Ukrainian diplomacy and the President of Ukraine during the next session of the UN General Assembly, but also undermine the inviolability of the principle of "nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine" and further efforts to successfully hold the Global Peace Summit, and call into question the effectiveness of the much-publicized format of diplomatic advisers. After all, it is clear that the field for diplomatic maneuvers has now narrowed considerably, and advisers from the Global South will be reluctant to go beyond the new consensus position of the G20.

"Fourth, the symbolic circumstance of the illegal elections of the aggressor in the temporarily occupied territories of Ukraine adds to the threat to the "Indian common denominator". The fact that they took place on the days of the G20 summit in New Delhi casts an additional shadow over the outcome of the event regarding Ukraine. And this shadow is not only threatening, but also dangerous."

The circumstance that seemed to unite the world to put even more pressure on the aggressor did not and was lost. Just as the achievements of the G20 Foreign Ministers' meeting in March this year, also under the Indian presidency, were lost, when the common language indicated a tendency to gradually increase pressure on Moscow, not the other way around.

Fifth, the controversial outcome of the summit is a signal that the space for domestic political mistakes is shrinking for our country. Any internal, even the smallest, miscalculation will be exaggerated by Russian propaganda to undermine Ukraine's international position.

We hope that Ukrainian diplomacy will carefully analyze the causes and consequences of such an ambiguous decision and adjust its strategic and communication approaches.

Obviously, we are entering a new stage in the fight against the Russian aggressor, when emotions will no longer have such a powerful effect as in the first days of the full-scale invasion. Accordingly, the presence of Lavrov or any other Kremlin emissary will not be as disgusting as it used to be. Therefore, efforts should be stepped up to counter Russian diplomacy's attempts to use the "New Delhi precedent" to further destroy Russia's current level of isolation. The classics of international relations suggest that with each new day of the war, more and more "arguments" will be heard about the need to bring Russia back to the diplomatic table. For this, for example, it is enough to look at the example of Syrian Assad and the normalization of relations with him, despite the position of the United States.

The world is changing, and we must take this into account if we are to achieve the long-awaited and necessary Victory for Ukraine.

Source

About the author: Kostiantyn Yelisieiev, Ukrainian diplomat, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Ukraine.

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Monday
7 October
17:48
Russia attacks Ukrainian seaport, damaging civilian ship
17:30
Ukraine won't extend gas transit from Russia, says PM Shmyhal
17:14
Ukraine integrates NATO gender equality standards into Armed Forces
16:55
Ukraine’s 3rd Brigade retakes positions in Kharkiv region, frees captive Ukrainian soldiers
16:36
Russian losses in Ukraine war reach record levels in September — UK intelligence
16:16
Fico says Slovakia is “cool” towards Ukraine's NATO membership
15:54
Ukrainian hackers attack Kremlin's state TV broadcasters
15:30
Updated
Russia attacks Ukraine with guided bombs, explosions leave 20 injured, including 2 children
15:16
Russia charges 14 foreign journalists for illegal border crossings
14:55
Exclusive
Can F-16s counter Russian guided bomb launches: aviation expert explains
14:35
Infographics
Bomb to long-range weapon: what are AGM-154 JSOWs and why they are important for Ukraine
13:57
Ukraine stuck in limbo as results of Zelenskyy’s U.S. visit remain unclear
13:35
Russia seeks to foster acceptance of Putin among Italians
13:16
Exclusive
Ukraine's population totals 35.8 million as of July 2024 — government
12:58
Exclusive
Only destroyed cars and houses left: volunteer on evacuation from Kurakhove sector
12:39
Exclusive
Russia's next move: Focus on Kurakhove – military expert Zgurets
12:18
Updated
Russia attacks Ukraine with UAVs and missiles: Kinzhal missile fragments fall in Kyiv
11:48
SU30Leaks saga continues: Thales responds openly, Safran dodges specific questions
11:17
OPINION
The West - Russia: wishful thinking
10:59
Google bans African Stream media over possible Russian ties
10:15
Russian intelligence recruited Irish MP as propaganda agent
09:56
Russia loses 14 tanks, 64 artillery systems and 1,160 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
09:40
Ukrainian Defense Forces strike oil terminal in Russian-occupied Feodosia
2024, Sunday
6 October
22:15
Interview
Russian elite still has a choice, but Putin does not - Feygin
21:46
Poland's army chief says country needs to boost its army
21:19
Russia drops three guided bombs on Kostiantynivka, killing one and injuring several
20:55
Taiwan weighs abandoning submarine fleet in favor of Ukraine's drone strategy
20:21
NATO lacks 49 brigades, needs force four times Germany's army to meet minimum standards
19:56
Russian soldiers shoot three Ukrainian prisoners of war at close range in New York village
19:38
Russian attack on Kramatorsk outskirts injures at least 4 people, including child
19:20
2017 meeting with Putin helps explain roots of Trump’s attitude to Ukraine - media
18:57
Exclusive
Month after Russia's missile attack: what houses on Konovalets Street, Lviv look like. Photo report
18:23
Trump's suspicion that Zelenskyy backs the Democrats resurfaces in the presidential campaign
17:56
Russia fires 20 missiles, 800+ guided bombs, up to 400 drones at Ukraine in one week
17:23
Artifacts Russian forces stole from Ukraine surface on the international black market
16:58
OPINION
Russia's shadow fleet: today's sanctions fall short
16:25
Zelenskyy, Syrskyi congratulate military on Ukraine's Territorial Defense Day
15:55
Russian opposition activist Dadin is killed fighting for Ukraine – reports
15:27
OPINION
Moldova's choice: will Russia's Trojan horses win?
14:59
Exclusive
“West knows how to count money": Expert explains why Russia might keep occupied Ukrainian territories
More news