Espreso. Global

US and Ukraine seek new strategy amidst “failed counteroffensive”

12 December, 2023 Tuesday
13:32

American and Ukrainian military leaders are working on a fresh strategy to boost Kyiv's fortunes and regain support in the face of a failed counteroffensive against Russia

client/title.list_title

The New York Times reported the information.

According to the outlet, President Zelenskyy's urgent meetings in Washington aim to demonstrate solidarity and secure backing both on the battlefield and in Congress. The setbacks, coupled with waning Republican support, prompt concerns of a prolonged stalemate favoring Putin. President Biden emphasizes the importance of sustained assistance, highlighting the evolving dynamics as Russia rebuilds its military strength.

“We can’t let Putin win. It’s in our overwhelming national interest and international interest of all our friends. Any disruption in our ability to supply Ukraine clearly strengthens Putin’s position,” the US President said last week as he pressed Congress for a new round of funding for Ukraine.

Following its unsuccessful drive to Kyiv in 2022, the Russian military is rebuilding its forces, now equipped with more troops, ammunition, missiles, and a fleet of Iranian-supplied battlefield drones, according to US officials.

In response, the United States is intensifying face-to-face military advice to Ukraine, deploying a three-star general to Kyiv for an extended period. War games in Germany next month aim to formulate a new strategy, with the US advocating for a conservative approach focused on holding and building up Ukraine's existing territory and resources. Ukrainians, however, seek an offensive strategy to capture global attention.

The outcome holds significant stakes, with warnings that, without a new strategy and additional funding, Ukraine could lose the war. Some US military voices support a "hold and build" strategy, emphasizing self-sufficiency for Ukraine and deterring further Russian aggression. However, challenges include opposition to additional spending from some Republicans and unrealistic expectations from Ukrainian leaders regarding Western support.

The US aims for a credible threat, hoping Russia may engage in meaningful negotiations by the end of next year or in 2025.

Ukraine explores bold strategies amidst potential 2024 stalemate

Ukrainian officials are innovating strategies, inspired by successful deep strikes on Crimea, aiming to disrupt Russia with attacks on arms facilities, weapons depots, and munitions transport. Described as "very daring," these plans seek symbolic victories while keeping Russia off balance. Without a shift in strategy, American officials warn of a 2024 comparable to the deadliest year of World War I.

The war's toll is evident, with Ukrainian hospitals crowded, and official casualty numbers undisclosed but acknowledged as steep. The 2023 counteroffensive, modeled after the US military, faced criticism akin to past conflicts in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan.

While open to compromise, US officials recognize Ukraine's successes, especially the impactful strikes in Crimea. Gen. Christopher G. Cavoli is playing a larger role in coordination, and Lt. Gen. Antonio A. Aguto Jr. is dispatched to Kyiv, signaling increased US military involvement in advising Ukraine, albeit without permanent advisers on-site.

Robotyne: The harsh reality of Ukraine’s counteroffensive

The Battle of Robotyne symbolizes the shattered aspirations of Ukraine's counteroffensive. Despite US-trained mechanized forces' efforts to push toward the Black Sea, the small village became a bloody stalemate rather than the breakthrough anticipated.

Ukrainian officials initially claimed victory in capturing the hamlet, presenting it as a significant step in disrupting Russian supply routes. However, the reality unfolded differently. The 47th Brigade, part of the nine trained by the US, suffered massive losses, and the town of Robotyne lay in ruins.

The ambitious push, guided by American-trained Ukrainian forces, faced unexpectedly resilient Russian defenses. Despite millions spent on sending tanks and armored vehicles and training Ukrainian units, Russian forces maintained control over nearly 20 percent of the country.

The Battle of Robotyne underscores the gap between US teaching of advanced military tactics and the Russian preparation for a protracted conflict. With winter approaching, Ukrainian forces remain stalemated on Robotyne's outskirts, facing formidable Russian defenses and uncertain prospects for breaking through in the near future.

Challenges and setbacks in Ukraine's counteroffensive: The changing dynamics

Deep Russian defenses, featuring formidable minefields and a variety of drones, have transformed mechanized maneuver warfare in Ukraine. The use of Chinese-made commercial drones, in particular, has altered the nature of battlefield observation, making it challenging for either side to capitalize on breakthroughs without detection.

Russian drones disrupted communications, located mine-sweeping teams, and facilitated targeted strikes. Sharp disagreements between Ukrainian and US generals on strategic priorities further complicated matters. While Ukraine deemed the eastern part of the country crucial, Washington prioritized the occupied southern coastline.

“There are a lot of reasons why the counteroffensive failed, but the Ukrainian critique has some truth to it. There was kind of a collective expectation inflation,” said Eric Ciaramella, a scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. 

The disagreement led to divided forces and a grinding stalemate, with Ukraine unwilling to commit to a single avenue of attack. The absence of air power to protect ground units added to the challenges. Despite successful attacks on Russia's Black Sea fleet and military command posts in Crimea, the overall campaign faced criticism and was not deemed a complete success.

The 2023 campaign showcased a major naval victory by Ukraine, utilizing longer-range British Storm Shadow missiles. While these attacks damaged targets in Crimea and prompted Russia to withdraw parts of its Black Sea Fleet, they did not alter the broader course of the war or result in territorial gains for Ukraine.

Strategic talks held in Germany as US and Ukraine seek a shift in war dynamics

Senior American military leaders, including Generals Cavoli and Aguto, convened with top Ukrainian officials at US Army Europe headquarters in Wiesbaden, Germany, to discuss the outlines of the strategy for the upcoming year. While details remain undisclosed, both sides recognize the critical need to alter the current stalemate, understanding that prolonged deadlock may jeopardize securing additional American funding.

The importance of US assistance in shaping the nature of the conflict is emphasized by analysts. Andrea Kendall-Taylor at the Center for a New American Security stresses that without continuous assistance, the war could take on a radically different character. 

“I don’t think it’s overstating it to highlight how important the U.S. assistance is,” she said. “If the assistance doesn’t continue, then this war takes on a radically different nature moving forward.”

American officials stress that Ukraine doesn't need to reclaim all lost territory; strategic and symbolic victories, coupled with enhanced defense capabilities and domestic weaponry production, may strengthen Ukraine's position for future peace talks.

Preparations for the next year involve managing expectations, with US officials cautioning Ukraine that the approved aid from Congress may not match initial funding levels. The emphasis is on fighting smartly and efficiently, making the right investments.

“If Ukraine and the West make the right investments in pursuit of a long-term strategy, then Ukraine may retake the advantage,” said Michael Kofman, a senior fellow in the Russia and Eurasia program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Tuesday
18 February
21:30
EU plans to provide Ukraine with €6 billion military aid package amid US-Russia talks
21:15
Exclusive
Massive Russian force gathers near Ukraine's Lyman as attacks intensify
21:01
Exclusive
"Signal to world and primarily Europe": MP Tsymbaliuk on US-Russia negotiations
20:42
Ukraine will not legally recognize Russian-occupied territories, says Zelenskyy
20:26
Turkey is ideal for negotiations between Russia, Ukraine, and US, says Erdogan
20:11
Updated
Fox News reports on proposed three-stage peace plan by Russia and US. Lavrov claims he hasn't seen it
19:56
Exclusive
Ukraine prepares for elections, says former SBU officer
19:40
OPINION
How 50% became stumbling block in Ukraine-US relations
19:25
UK Defence Secretary declares world is in "new era of threat"
19:09
How Ukrainian simulators help troops master new weapons
18:50
Exclusive
EU plans to extend sanctions against Russia - Espreso correspondent from Brussels
18:31
US-Ukraine mineral deal terms worse than Germany's post-war reparations – The Telegraph
18:10
Ukraine won't accept Russia's ultimatums: Zelenskyy on US-Russia talks in Saudi Arabia
17:52
Zelenskyy, First Lady inaugurate Ukraine's new Embassy building in Ankara
17:30
Europe ready to ramp up defense efforts for Ukraine amid global pressure — Ursula von der Leyen
17:11
Russia says European peacekeepers in Ukraine would be viewed as “escalatory step”
16:54
Exclusive
Trump appears to be outmaneuvering both Beijing and Moscow, says political analyst
16:36
Exclusive
EU aims to compete with U.S. for global influence – Espreso correspondent from Brussels
16:15
Ukraine’s strike on rare Russian S-350 puts pressure on Moscow’s defenses
15:55
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
Russia's year-long push for Pokrovsk shows no success: military observer explains why
15:27
Exclusive
Europe faces a new reality – Ukrainian MP Knyazhytskyi from Paris
15:12
Lithuania calls for security guarantees before considering troop deployment to Ukraine
15:06
Updated
U.S. and Russia hold over 4-hour talks in Saudi Arabia
14:55
Ukraine allocates over $35 million to maintain Chornobyl shelter
14:31
Russia enhances accuracy of North Korean KN-23 missiles — Ukraine's spy chief
14:22
Reuters streams live from Maidan Nezalezhnosti, Kyiv authorities respond
14:16
Exclusive
If U.S. invades Russia, no one will resist — psychologist
13:53
Ukraine recovers 7,017 fallen defenders' bodies since start of Russia’s full-scale invasion
13:31
Exclusive
Ukraine needs two things to prevent Russia’s northeastern advance — Achilles regiment
12:52
China calls for "all parties" in Russia-Ukraine war to join peace talks
12:37
Poroshenko believes Zhevago is under sanctions because his family owns Espreso TV channel
12:17
OPINION
Ukraine buys time for Europe to wake up
11:55
Exclusive
Security guarantees for Ukraine have nothing to do with peacekeeping forces in war zone — expert
11:34
Firefighting ongoing at Chornobyl NPP following Russian drone strike
11:15
Review
Russia escalates attacks on Ukraine amid latest U.S. statements. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
10:52
Exclusive
"Step toward U.S.-Russia dialogue": expert on upcoming meeting in Saudi Arabia
10:34
Russian UAV attack on Ukraine: Mother, two children injured in Kirovohrad region; debris sparks fires in Kyiv
10:27
Ceasefire between Russia, Ukraine would not end martial law — Defense Committee
09:57
Europe may deploy up to 30,000 troops to Ukraine
09:35
Russia loses 1,170 soldiers, 12 tanks, 181 UAVs in one day of war in Ukraine
More news