Espreso. Global

Ukrainian commander accuses New York Times of 'criminal manipulation' in article on Dnipro River crossing

18 December, 2023 Monday
15:50

Robert Brovdi (call sign Magyar), a Ukrainian serviceman, platoon commander of the second assault company of the 28th Separate Mechanized Brigade of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, and founder of the Birds of Magyar aerial reconnaissance unit, accused the New York Times of “criminal” manipulation in a recently published article

The New York Times has published an article in which it alleged that Ukrainian authorities claim marines have established strongholds on the Dnipro River, but marines and soldiers argue these accounts are overstated. The article states that soldiers and marines who have participated in the river crossings describe the offensive as brutalizing and futile, with some going further, calling it “a suicide mission.” It alleges that Ukrainian commanders' poor preparation and logistics have led to the decimation of a battalion serving in the direction and that the brutal conditions are degrading morale and soldiers' support. 

Magyar responded to the article in a video, published on his Youtube channel. 

The military believes that the article is a manipulative piece, with a way of presenting information that is fit rather for a Netflix movie than a comprehensive analysis of the overall picture.

“To film the emotional impressions of militaries who returned from the left bank? Okay, okay for a Netflix movie. But to film them for a generalizing piece of cr*p (*conclusion) regarding the position is a shameful criminal manipulation of the readers' consciousness,” he stated.

He further likened the journalists' interviewing manner with Ukrainian soldiers to interviewing someone in a situation where the relatives of a deceased driver blame freeway builders for allowing high-speed conditions.

“It is also exactly as if the relatives of a driver who had just died in a road accident on the freeway appealed to the Builders of that freeway, with accusations that the road provides for movement on it at a speed of 130 km/h, in contrast to roads of ordinary use, where the speed limit is 80 km/h and to blame the death of that driver on the builders for creating conditions for super-fast driving, to ask their impressions and make generalizing conclusions for the whole world…I am talking about misrepresentation (distortion) from a journalistic context and presenting material with a conclusion about the fallacy of the idea of ​​liberation on the example of human suffering, around losses,” the fighter provided an analogy.

Magyar further shared his opinions on what might be the reasons for the New York Times publishing such a piece.

“For what purpose is this done? To explain the impracticality of giving us your weapons? Weapons, 90% of the value of which remains in money, and raises and strengthens your economy, thanks to the presence of sustained orders?” he questioned.

The military then suggested alternative topics for coverage.

“Why not comment on the undisclosed losses that are further burdening this small piece of land? Bunker old man (Putin - ed.) claimed the absence of losses for a distinct 104th airborne division. However, an entire division is now no more, according to the enemy's spokespersons, due to that insignificant bridgehead. Why remain silent about the declassified 810th brigade of marines, which fought fiercely for hundreds of hectares of land, paying with their blood?” he suggested and added “Why overlook the peculiar circumstances surrounding the demise of General Zavadsky, the former commanding general of the fourth tank division and the more recent deputy commander of the 14th army? Did he perish by exploding on an enemy mine or otherwise?... Investigate in that direction, towards that facet of the war! Conduct interviews with the stormtroopers of those who callously occupy Ukraine, capturing their impressions of residing and moving through the territories they have unlawfully seized. Share these insights with the entire world; it will undoubtedly generate significant interest and demand.”

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Friday
1 March
19:20
Exclusive
Navalny's murder might motivate resistance, radicalise protests in Russia — sociologist Eidman
18:57
NATO: Putin's threats to use nuclear weapons is psychological intimidation
18:35
Russian missiles attacks Donetsk region, injuring civilians, damaging police station, hospital, kindergartens
18:14
Ukraine, Netherlands sign security agreement: what does it provide for?
17:50
Exclusive
Map of fighting in Marinka sector
Under heavy fire: Ukrainian officer on situation in Marinka sector
17:25
Frozen Russian assets won't replace US aid to Ukraine - Treasury Secretary Yellen
17:00
Exclusive
Why Scholz is hesitant to transfer Taurus to Ukraine?
16:40
Russian troops bomb residential buildings in Zaporizhzhia region, killing civilian man
16:20
Exclusive
Measuring temperature in chamber: diplomat on China's special envoy's trip to number of countries
16:00
Russia holds significant ammunition advantage, increases artillery shelling in Avdiivka direction
15:40
OPINION
Transnistria: Where there is a trace of Russia, there is war
15:25
Russia makes "powerful breakthrough" to Chasiv Yar to open way to 3 more localities - Khortytsia group of troops
15:07
British intelligence assesses level and prospects of Russian military industry
14:40
Exclusive
Red lines are blurring: military expert Zgurets on possible deployment of NATO troops to Ukraine
14:20
Transition to F-16 not swift, but Ukraine making every effort – Air Force
14:00
Ukraine's Intelligence attacks Russian Pantsir-S1 air defense system in Belgorod region
13:40
Umerov approves action plan to implement cooperation program with NATO for 2024
13:20
OPINION
Putin's message: whom was the dictator addressing?
13:00
Russian pilots feel they are in the sights — Ukraine's Air Force Spokesman Ihnat 
12:40
OSCE launches "Moscow mechanism" to document Russian war crimes
12:25
IL-76 crash: Russia says it's willing to return bodies to Ukraine; Ukraine responds
12:05
Britain urges Germany to send Taurus missiles to Ukraine - Bloomberg
11:45
Japan extends sanctions against Russian companies and individuals
11:27
Review
Does CIA have any bases in Ukraine and what was the purpose of its director's visit? Serhiy Zgurets's column
11:05
Polish farmers fail to provide evidence of Ukrainian grain returning from Lithuania to Poland 
10:47
Updated
Russian media claim attempted UAV attack on defense plant in Nizhny Novgorod region
10:30
No one in Europe is going to send troops to Ukraine - Czech Prime Minister
10:15
Russia loses 3 aircraft, 36 artillery systems and 920 troops in Ukraine overnight — General Staff
09:55
Russia transports its agricultural goods through Belarus to Poland — UP
09:35
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces transform Synkivka into graveyard for Russian equipment — Kupyansk Military Administration
2024, Thursday
29 February
22:10
OPINION
Putin's messages of war: Vitaliy Portnikov's column
21:57
Review
Victorious news on 736th day of war: Ukrainian forces down 3 Russian aircraft, target Russian soldiers in Bakhmut sector
21:40
Russia attacks 22 times in Avdiivka, Novopavlivka directions in one day — General Staff
21:25
Ukrainian army engaged in fierce fighting with Russia's forces in Avdiivka, Kurakhove sectors  - Syrskyi
21:10
Russian forces focus on Avdiivka direction - Ukrainian commander
20:55
Ukrainian Armed Forces adopt 46 new types of weapons since start of year — Defense Ministry
20:40
156,000 km² of Ukraine's territory is mined: State Emergency Service tells how to speed up demining
20:21
"One of the dumbest things I've ever heard": what impressed Carlson most in Putin interview 
19:59
Ukrainian Miss Europe representative complains about Russian harassment during contest
19:37
Updated
No hearse agrees to take his body - Navalny's supporters on funeral challenges
More news