Espreso. Global

Sanctions loopholes and French news anchor help Russian disinfo, propaganda to stay on air in Europe

10 June, 2022 Friday

Eutelsat is in no hurry to shut down Russian state TV and radio companies, or the Russian Defense Ministry, in fact, it is dragging its feet and waiting for a political decision from the French government or the EU

A Russian-language Estonian online platform called Mozhem Obyasnit (We Can Explain) and the Verstka publication take a deep dive into the story in a joint investigation.

Russian TV continues to broadcast in Europe despite the sanctions. They are assisted by their longtime partner - French operator Eutelsat. It is quarter owned by the French government, and Russia also has a stake in it. Its share, apparently, is a sizable one comprising 4 out of the 5 satellites Eutelsat operates. Only one of them belongs to France, the rest are Russia’s, operated by Eutelsat but owned by Moscow.

Thanks to this network of five "shared" satellites, Russian state channels continue to broadcast in Europe, North Africa and the Middle East. Thus, using the Hotbird 13 satellite, people in Germany can still watch any Russian state broadcasting channels, for no charge. 

In early May, CEO Eva Berneke said Eutelsat will remain "neutral" regarding the political conflict in which Russia was involved (she did not use the word "war"). She also said that the decision to exclude Russian providers remains a matter solely for the French authorities. So far, the French satellite company has stated that no regulatory or other competent authority has asked them to stop broadcasting.

Note that other operators have turned off the broadcasts of all Russian propaganda and disinformation channels, as they use satellites owned by the United States.

Their decision to stop broadcasting was sparked by a new package of US sanctions adopted in early May against pro-war Russian media. The White House explained that the sanctions apply to the three most popular Russian TV companies, which are directly or indirectly controlled by the state: Perviy Kanal (Channel One), the Russian State TV and Radio Broadcasting Company (VGTRK - Ed), (Russia-1, Russia-24, Kultura) and NTV.

EU sanctions did not oblige all countries to block all Russian state TV or radio broadcasting companies. The ban (in early March - Ed.) only specified Russia Today and Sputnik. As for the VGTRK, Brussels has so far only imposed sanctions on its leadership and staff. Therefore, formally, France is acting in accordance with the sanctions, but the government is in no hurry to completely block Russian propaganda and disinformation.

However, activists may push the government to move further on this issue. A petition against Russian propagandists using Eutelsat satellites is now being actively circulated in France. The idea is to kick the main Russian providers off Eutelsat satellites and replace them with others that broadcast independent international programs. Then the Kremlin's monopoly on information in Russia could be broken.

But there is another factor that could influence the operator's decision - US sanctions, which the company continues to ignore. However, if Eutelsat postpones blocking Russian channels that have already come under US sanctions, it risks falling foul of secondary US sanctions itself. So far, Washington has not applied them to anyone - it has only threatened several banks. But Eutelsat may be the first company to see those threats become reality.

Read also:
  • News
2023, Thursday
30 March
Russia reduces number of ships in Black Sea due to storm, weather is critical for aviation and drones - Ukraine’s Defense Forces
They are looking for guerrilla fighters: Russians announce several objects and residential buildings in Melitopol are mined 
Price civilians pay for the war - Ukrainian photographer wins World Press Photo award for his Mariupol photos 
Germany to allocate additional €12 billion for long-term military assistance to Ukraine
General Milley: Russia, China, Iran will threaten global security for years to come  
Russian Volunteer Corps shared video of operation in Bryansk region on March 2
US intends to bring Russia back into compliance with nuclear weapons treaty - State Department
About 6,000 Wagner mercenaries fight in Bakhmut, Donetsk region — General Milley
Center for Countering Disinformation publishes Russia’s fakes for March 29 
US finds "no serious violations" related to aid for Ukraine
Ukrainian Armed Forces have killed at least 172.9 thousand Russian invaders since beginning of full-scale war
Ukrainian Defense Ministry tells about Ukrainian and Russian losses on the battlefield 
Russia launches 5 missile and 25 air strikes on Ukraine, FSB carries out humiliating filtration in Crimea - General Staff 
Victorious news of 399th day of war: trap for Russian bomber, explosion in Crimea, Mi-8 helicopters from Croatia
Yevhen Hulevych from Lviv: from intellectual projects to philosophy of trenches and death near Bakhmut
Russian propaganda launches new narrative of fighting ‘Satanism’ in Ukraine
Hungary will continue to block EU sanctions on Russian nuclear energy, expand cooperation with Russia – Szijjártó
The West is about pragmatism. Therefore, do not be overly optimistic
Russia called up over 500,000 troops last year – Bloomberg
Iranian foreign minister calls for diplomatic settlement of Ukraine war at meeting with Lavrov
China may start producing ammunition for Russia and sell it through DPRK – military expert Katkov
Peskov says West's ‘hybrid war against Russia’ will last long, Ukraine responds
Analysts refute Russian claim of Ukrainian refugees raising crime rate in Poland
2023, Wednesday
29 March
Pushing Pushkin
Ukrainian war correspondents speak against restrictions on some media to report from ‘red’ zones
Russian bread factory starts producing drones for Russian military – media
Russian troops dig trenches, build fortifications in Crimea; Ukrainian Armed Forces repel 48 attacks in a day – General Staff
Russia's deployment of nuclear weapons in Belarus challenges NATO – MEP Auštrevičius
Slovakia condemns Russian atrocities against women and children in Ukraine
Kvitka ‘Kasey’ Cisyk: 25 years without legendary voice of American-Ukrainian woman
US estimates Russian casualties in Ukraine at 220,000 killed and wounded 
Ukrainian guerrillas discover Russian troops, adjust fire on them
ICC to determine whether Russia's abduction of Ukrainian children is genocide – Ukrainian Ombudsman
Ukrainian marines target 8 Russian soldiers and mortar in one day
Albina Deriugina, the legend of rhythmic gymnastics, dies
Zaluzhnyi discusses arms supplies, cooperation with Commander of Allied Forces Europe
Ukrainian army has potential to throw knockout punch to Russian troops – military expert Dan Rice
Ukrainian military adapts to Shahed drones launch from different directions 
You can't sit on two chairs
Ukrainian troops eliminate 12 Russian soldiers and subversive boat near Dnipro Islands
More news