Espreso. Global
OPINION

On dilemma: either “we are about to lose” or “we need to negotiate something”

Sofia Polonska
7 November, 2024 Thursday
20:03

“Victory has many fathers, defeat is always an orphan”, or a bit about the responsibility of Ukraine and its partners

client/title.list_title

This is a popular topic to discuss nowadays, who is more to blame. “Criminal government”, bad society, bad partners. Of course, this whole discussion is well colored by the political preferences of some of its participants. But the backdrop for finding fault is certainly favorable: the enemy is advancing, our partners have almost all the discourse about negotiations (and not just Trump, in fact), and many Ukrainians believe that we are either “about to lose” or “need to negotiate something.”

Let me just remind you: when Ukraine repelled an attempt to seize Kyiv, and especially after Kharkiv and Kherson, Western military and politicians happily boasted that “we taught them everything.” And then - if Woodworth is to be believed - they easily succumbed to Putin's nuclear blackmail. Now, when we are forced to exchange Russian losses and time on the territory, we can look for the problem in Ukraine and Ukrainians. Of course, Ukrainians do not remain in debt. Especially the government, for whom it is politically natural.

Of course, the government has a lot to criticize for. There are plenty of mistakes (personnel and management) and miscalculations (especially those discovered in hindsight).

There is something to blame ourselves, society and the state for. Because now we are living with the institutions, society, and state that we have built over 30 years. And it is impossible to change it radically during the war.


And yes, without our partners and their money, we would be in trouble. But in many issues, including the supply of weapons, authorization of their use, and restrictions on Russia, both the EU and the US are acting cowardly or outright hypocritical. This is a fact.

And those who repeat the frankly idiotic formula “you have to start with yourself, and help will come” seem to have really listened to too many personal growth trainings. No empire, not even a great one, has ever withstood a world war without external resources, especially when the war was fought on its territory. Neither France, nor Britain, nor the USSR, nor the United States, which emerged from World War II in debt.

And even now there are examples of countries that are acting on their potential much more decisively and consistently than the “big players”. These are the Scandinavian countries, which allocate many times more relative to GDP than the United States or large European countries. And they are not chasing after Ukraine with an attempt to “hang” a guilt complex on the victim of aggression.

The current restrictions on Ukraine and very slow aid will not destroy us as a state. Still, we are getting help, and we are building factories with the Belgians and Germans, and we are creating weapons. So we will make it.

But this specific policy stretches and scales the challenges. Our partners will have to respond to them. I myself have explained many times the reasons for their caution, but this does not change the result. They will shovel out problems not even through Ukraine, but collectively.

So they didn't crush the Wagner Group in Ukraine and didn't drive Russia out of the Sahel, and there is already a war in Sudan. Which will be an even bigger problem for Europe and the United States. There are already 13 million refugees there (there were 10 in August), 500,000 of them are already in the EU, and 25 million are on the verge of starvation. It will burn somewhere else, because the huge Sudan will export radicalism and instability, provoking crisis after crisis in Africa. This will increase both economic and migration pressure.

And the fact that Putin was not beaten quickly leads to the worst-case scenario that our partners fear with regard to Russia. In fact, chaos and collapse during the transfer of power. Putin is trying very hard to turn his country into a territory saturated with hatred and Nazism, which will sooner or later explode. And chaos in Russia is really a global challenge. And who will be responsible for this? Apart from the Russians themselves?

Why? Because they did not give Ukraine weapons and permission to win the war relatively quickly. And even if the war ends tomorrow, Putin's regime will most likely have passed the point of no return. Just like the USSR, which collapsed after the end of the Afghan war. And it will be as usual. What they feared, they got.

And here it will not even be possible to name a few names of the “guilty”. These are systemic policy bugs. Which will have to be treated when this cycle of war and confrontation ends.

Source

About the author. Yuriy Bohdanov, publicist, specialist in strategic communications in business, public administration and politics

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Friday
6 December
21:15
Exclusive
If Russia deploys Oreshnik missile in Belarus, Ukraine will have official right to restore nuclear weapons — political expert
21:00
Russia plans to fine residents of occupied territories for Ukrainian
20:58
Updated
Russian strike on Ukraine's Zaporizhzhia leaves nine dead, children injured
20:50
Zelenskyy expected to attend Notre Dame reopening ceremony - media
20:30
Review
Blackout at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant: dirty bomb risk?
20:10
Ukraine secures 40 high-tech combat vehicles in major European defense deal
19:52
OPINION
West vs. Russia: taming ogre won't work
19:40
Review
How Russia uses AI-generated images to spread propaganda
19:10
Exclusive
When can Putin declare general mobilization? Military expert suggests
18:53
Updated
Russian missile strikes administrative building in Ukraine’s Kryvyi Rih, killing two people
18:53
Negotiations on Ukraine's accession to EU are underway - Vice Prime Minister Stefanishyna
18:36
Putin suggests Oreshnik deployment in Belarus in second half of 2025
18:15
Exclusive
'Brilliant, pragmatic solution': expert on Estonian anti-aircraft missiles to be produced in Ukraine
17:36
China calls on Ukraine, Russia to "restart direct talks"
17:15
UNESCO declares Ukrainian Kobzar-Lirnyk tradition cultural heritage of humanity
16:53
Ukraine begins mass production of Peklo drone-missile
16:30
Can Washington deliver “avalanche” of aid to Ukraine before Trump's inauguration?
16:15
Estonian defense company to test anti-aircraft missiles in Ukraine starting in 2025
15:55
Romania’s Constitutional Court annuls first round of presidential elections
15:36
Council of Europe Chief Berset to name special representative for Ukrainian children
15:16
Exclusive
France’s crisis won’t disrupt aid for Ukraine — political analyst
14:55
OPINION
Carlson-Lavrov interview: Not negotiations yet, just preparations
14:34
Exclusive
Security agreements Ukraine has signed with 27 countries include support for joining NATO
14:19
Western tech curbs slow Russian drones, yet weapons output surges
13:56
Exclusive
We see where Russian troops are planning to attack, amassing forces — Ukrainian officer from Pokrovsk direction
13:45
Review
Ukraine advances near Velyka Novosilka, Russia lacks strategy in Syria. Serhiy Zgurets' column
13:34
Russia loses 53 soldiers for every square kilometer of Ukrainian territory captured this fall - ISW
12:57
Bridge traffic blocked in Crimea, explosions in Kerch
12:36
Exclusive
Ukrainian troops never withdraw without reason – military expert on eastern direction
12:16
Three Ukrainian NPPs restore electricity production after November Russian strike — IAEA
11:55
188 frontline clashes reported: Ukraine fends off 50 Russian attacks near Kurakhove
11:35
White House promises major military support for Ukraine
11:16
Ukraine's mobilization age too high, women should be more involved in army — U.S. General Hodges
10:56
Over 8,000 Ukrainian AWOL soldiers return, 3,000 in one week
10:35
OPINION
Lavrov's interview with Tucker Carlson reveals Kremlin's fear of Trump
10:14
Finland announces 26th defense aid package to Ukraine
09:56
Russia's losses since start of full-scale war in Ukraine exceed 750,000 troops
09:34
Russia captures four more settlements in Donetsk region – DeepState
2024, Thursday
5 December
21:10
Three Ukrainian films among longlist contenders for Oscars 2025
20:51
Budapest Memorandum has not worked: Zelenskyy calls for effective security guarantees for Ukraine
More news