Espreso. Global
OPINION

Can state take revenge on its citizens? It turns out that it can

26 April, 2024 Friday
15:44

A little bit about the repression of those Ukrainians who are abroad

client/title.list_title

Ukraine has a problem with mobilization. This makes the law on mobilization extremely important. The goal is to increase the number of people who can be drafted into the army. To increase the number of people who are drafted. And it would be logical if all the actions of the law on mobilization were aimed at this. But at the same time, the law was diluted in terms of the stick that can be used in Ukraine. And seasoned with petty revenge.

We are talking about the fact that the state has suspended the consulate's support for men abroad.

Is this within the framework of the main goal of the law - to increase the number of the Ukrainian Armed Forces? To increase the efficiency of mobilization? Absolutely not. These actions will not force any man who chose to be abroad during the war to return to Ukraine.

These inconveniences, which are created for absolutely all men who are abroad, are in no way comparable to the inconveniences that mobilization will bring them. Moreover, not all men abroad have crossed the Tisza (i.e. illegally crossed the border). Many are there legally.

Thus, the effectiveness of this measure is zero. However, the state uses it and relishes it, focusing on it instead of taking unpopular steps that should produce results. The result is an increase in the number of people mobilized. But it seems that the result is not yet in sight.

What is it then? This is both petty revenge and populism. Because the state shows that it is taking revenge on those who left, which should give pleasure to those who stayed. It plays on the dark sides of human nature. It is trying to gain cheap popularity on a painful topic for society.

It also spreads a split in society. Including the one that will happen after the war. Because Ukraine has a huge demographic problem. And Ukraine is extremely interested in bringing back as many people as possible who went abroad because of the war, including men. These people are needed here. And the last thing we should do is take steps to prevent these people from returning. And we are talking about the hatred of some Ukrainians towards others, which the state cultivates. It is sharpening the corners that should be smoothed out.

And yes, these men are needed in Ukraine. And yes, they chose not to be in Ukraine during the war. And there is no contradiction here. Ukraine needs all its citizens. And not all citizens of Ukraine are heroes. Just like any other country. Ukraine needs not only heroes. Ukraine needs people who will pay taxes to pay pensions. Ukraine will need people who will give birth, and for this purpose, men are still needed. Ukraine needs consumers, so that those who are now making coffee under fire can sell it and increase their business after the war. Ukraine needs these men, even if someone thinks their choice is not moral. But they made it. And they remained citizens of Ukraine.

Yes, they consciously chose to stay outside Ukraine during the war. Among other things, they were afraid that they might be mobilized. But there is no desire to be mobilized among the men who are in Ukraine. So will we also cultivate hatred towards them?

We will harass people who are fighting and their relatives, and those who are not. Is their act more negative than the behavior of deserters who flee the front by the thousands? Should we also hate those who have been booked throughout the war? Where is the line after which the state will say: "We want to hate them"?

And now we are deliberately not talking about the contribution of people who, being abroad and feeling remorseful, guilty, can actively donate. And to do so more than a large number of people who are currently in Ukraine, away from the front.

The last thing Ukrainians should be doing after the war is measuring who has done what. And who is a greater patriot. This should be left to politicians. There are enough problems in society without this.

War is a tragedy. And a trauma. And after the war, when that day comes, society needs to heal these traumas. And the state should play a leading role here. And it is illogical if the state exacerbates these traumas. Especially by taking steps that in no way bring us closer to victory. And this step definitely does nothing to bring victory closer. Except for victory in the upcoming elections. Which we still have to live to see.

About the author. Serhiy Fursa, investment expert, blogger.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Wednesday
29 May
11:50
Alyssa Milano becomes UNITED24 ambassador
11:24
Percentage of Russian weapons with US components is unacceptably high - White House
10:52
Exclusive
Ukrainian troops expand bridgehead on Dnipro's eastern bank in Kherson region — journalist
10:20
Russia loses 1,300 soldiers, 37 artillery systems, and 33 armored vehicles in one day – Ukraine's General Staff
10:03
EU hopes to deliver half million artillery shells to Ukraine by end of year
09:42
Ukraine makes progress in Kharkiv sector, Russia tests Ukraine's response in Donetsk region - ISW
2024, Tuesday
28 May
21:30
Review
Victorious news of 825th day of war: 24-year-old soldier eliminates Russian APC with crew, MoD allows using 10 new robots
21:00
Updated
Ukrainian polar explorers explain why they don't buy drones using funds for Antarctic research
20:35
Ukraine signs bilateral agreement on security guarantees with Portugal
20:15
Exclusive
Defense Express explains why Ukraine has not received F-16s yet
19:50
More than 2,300 hectares of forests burn in Kharkiv region. Many unexploded Russian munitions remain there
19:25
Russia has about 500,000 troops in Ukraine and near its borders - Umerov
19:00
Exclusive
Strategic strikes on Russia's capabilities: aviation expert on destruction of missile warning stations
18:35
Exclusive
Ukraine's government cuts payments to almost all categories of IDPs
18:10
Sweden suspends plan to supply Gripen fighter jets to Ukraine
17:50
Switzerland tightens measures to expel Russian spies ahead of Peace Summit
17:28
Military expert comments on WSJ article about Russian drone plant
17:05
Russia ramps up recruitment of African mercenaries to fight in Ukraine
16:41
Heat is on in Pokrovsk direction: Ukrainian forces repel 7 attacks, 8 battles ongoing – AFU General Staff report
16:15
Exclusive
Russia is completely shifting economy to military — military expert Zgurets
15:45
Threat of ecological disaster: Reservoir in Western Ukraine losing water due to Russian shelling, river fauna at risk
15:18
OPINION
When will Russia collapse?
14:54
Updated
Belgium will supply Ukraine with 30 F-16 fighters by 2028. Ukraine can use them only on its territory
14:16
Ukraine, Belgium sign bilateral agreement on security guarantees and long-term support
13:52
Review
New page in destruction of Russian military targets: Ukrainian Armed Forces strike at Russian missile warning stations. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
12:42
Exclusive
"Attack on nuclear infrastructure": Political technologist Zahorodniy on Orsk radar attack and why Putin is bluffing
12:01
Exclusive
“Riot is brewing among civilians in Mariupol": official shares details
11:35
Russian strike on Kharkiv hypermarket: police identify killed father by child's DNA
10:50
Russia attacks Kharkiv region's Borova at night, causing fires and injuring one civilian 
10:24
In Russian-occupied Luhansk, explosions reported near military aviation school and aircraft repair plant
09:55
Iran supplies Russia with latest bombs – Bild
09:32
Russia loses 21 tanks, 48 artillery systems and over 1,400 soldiers in one day in Ukraine
2024, Monday
27 May
21:47
Exclusive
Ukraine will be able to use Western weapons against Russians on their territory
21:25
Review
Victorious news of 824th day of war: record military aid package from Spain, restrictions on Russian diplomats' movement in Poland
21:05
Russian army storms Pokrovsk direction 21 times, situation is tense - General Staff
20:44
Russian attacks in Kharkiv region: UN confirms 45 civilians killed, 189 wounded
20:23
France to send instructors to train Ukrainian military, says Syrskyi
20:02
Exclusive
Russia will have fewer opportunities to strike at Ukraine after defeat of 'Crimean Triangle'
19:41
Russia attacks Ukraine with over 3,000 guided bombs in month - Zelenskyy
19:20
NATO Parliamentary Assembly calls on Allies to allow Ukraine to use Western weapons against Russia - MP Chierniev
More news