Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Shoigu has no power as Secretary of Russian Security Council - Piontkovsky

18 May, 2024 Saturday
15:51

Prominent Washington-based political scientist Andrey Piontkovsky has shared his thoughts on recent changes in the highest echelons of Russian government

client/title.list_title

He said this in an interview with the host of the Studio West program, Antin Borkovskyi.

Piontkovsky noted that the appointment to the position of Security Council Secretary, which Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu was transferred to, means nothing.

“This position of Patrushev, the position of the Security Council Secretary, is an empty position. It was important because Patrushev played this crucial role as a war ideologist, he had been instilling in Putin for 10 years this concept that we can defeat states that are much stronger than us by blackmailing them with nuclear weapons. And now this Security Council is a bunch of pensioners, Medvedev and Shoigu will make some strange speeches there, it doesn't matter,” he explained.

The political scientist also commented on the arrests of high-ranking officials such as Ivanov and Kuznetsov, which he believes are related to Russia's failures in the war against Ukraine.

“Putin understands that this is due to his realization that blackmail has failed. Now he is thinking about how to stay in power. Now he will try to impose on the West and Ukraine some version of what he calls Korea. And yet he will have to publicly admit that the main goal of the war-the destruction of the Ukrainian state-has failed and will never be realized. He will have to name the culprits, the Defense Ministry will be named guilty, and there will be a huge trial of generals. And he still has some personal close relations with Shoigu. And if Shoigu cannot be put in the dock, because everyone remembers their joint trips to the Tuvan taiga and how close they were, then he simply put Shoigu in a warm place on his retirement - he took traitors and thieves in the Defense Ministry out of the upcoming trial. This is my explanation. This is an empty place, Shoigu has no power there,” Piontkovsky emphasized.

Piontkovsky's comments lift the veil on the complex internal maneuvers within the Russian government and make it clear that even within the Kremlin itself there are doubts about the success of their aggressive foreign policy.

“He needs a long war, he repeats this every day. That this fool Belousov, who is supposedly, as we are told, the only person in Russia who does not steal (although this is highly questionable, as data on Belousov's palaces have already emerged), has been put in charge. But now he has a double task, he has realized that the victory over Ukraine in the sense in which he wanted to achieve it-the destruction of Ukrainian statehood-will never happen, and now he needs to crawl away. He wants to preserve the Korean version of territorial gains as much as possible and sell it as a draw. But a draw is not a victory, because the thieves and traitors of the Ministry of Defense were in the way, and there will be a huge trial of them. That's what Putin is doing now and what is the meaning of these two sensational resignations,” the political analyst concluded.

  • On May 12, Russian dictator Putin announced personnel changes in the Kremlin government - Sergei Shoigu is to be replaced as Russia's defense minister by Andrey Belousov, who was the first deputy prime minister in the previous government.
  • According to ISW, Kremlin leader Vladimir Putin has replaced Sergei Shoigu with Andrei Belousov as Russia's defense minister, and moved Shoigu to the post of secretary of the Security Council to replace Nikolai Patrushev, in preparation for a protracted war in Ukraine and a future confrontation with NATO.  

  • UK intelligence doesn't foresee any changes in the course of the war in Ukraine on Russia's part after Sergei Shoigu’s resignation as Defense Minister.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Saturday
18 January
19:38
Exclusive
'Only another Pearl Harbor can wake up America': diplomat on Washington’s blind spot to threats
19:16
Exclusive
'Not fear of Russia, but habit of seeing Moscow as global player': analyst on Biden’s Ukraine policy
18:54
Russian forces attack Ukraine’s Kherson region with artillery, killing three civilians
18:35
89 clashes occur on Russian-Ukrainian front on January 18 - General Staff
18:13
OPINION
Two cores of Russian network in Ukraine
17:51
Exclusive
Key to victory lies with Zelenskyy: time to appoint competent experts, not friends - Colonel Grant
17:30
Slovenia funds three pyrotechnic vehicles for Ukraine’s Emergency Services
17:12
Nigeria joins BRICS as partner country
16:53
Exclusive
'Sign of weakness for U.S.': Manhattan University professor on potential Trump-Putin meeting
16:36
Guerrillas torch two communication towers near Russia's Krasnodar
16:14
Exclusive
Future events depend on Putin’s decisions, not Trump or Musk - British Colonel Grant
15:58
OPINION
Russia-Iran: has Putin outplayed everyone?
15:37
Exclusive
U.S. alone cannot provide Ukraine with everything needed to defeat Russia - diplomat
15:15
North Korea prepares second wave of troops to aid Russia in Ukraine war
14:56
OPINION
Will Trump mobilize 18-year-olds?
14:33
Russia attacks Ukraine's Kyiv, Zaporizhzhia with ballistic missiles, causing casualities
14:12
Exclusive
Global pressure mounts: next week could see united demand for Putin to end aggression
14:08
Updated
Ukrainian forces target Russian oil depot in Tula region, air defenses in occupied territories
13:49
OPINION
Putin's regime at risk: Russia running out of reserves, war funds
13:30
Ukrainian special forces strike Rosneft oil depot in Russia’s Kaluga region
13:07
Review
Russian forces employ 'bait' tactics for assaults, Putin plans major covert mobilization amid heavy losses. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
12:45
Russia seizes 18,000 hectares of land in occupied Luhansk from Ukrainians without passports
12:24
Ukraine reports 174 clashes at front, repels 79 Russian assaults in Pokrovsk sector
12:01
Exclusive
Russian forces relentlessly attempt to flank Pokrovsk: Ukrainian army repels nearly 70 attacks daily
11:40
Interview
Support for Ukraine drops when war fades from news — Anton Bogdanovych, Ukrainian community leader in Sydney
11:03
Russia attacks Ukraine with drones, missiles: explosions heard in Kyiv, Zaporizhzhia
10:49
Updated
Russian missile strike on Ukraine’s Kryvyi Rih leaves five dead, several injured: rescue operations completed
10:35
Russia loses 1,340 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Friday
17 January
21:20
Belarusian volunteer Maria Zaitseva killed near Bakhmut
20:55
Russian oil tankers under construction added to U.S. sanctions list
20:32
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 8-15
Russian forces resort to 'Zhiguli' cars for assaults on Ukrainian positions
20:10
Finnish party drops candidate over calling Ukraine war 'special military operation'
19:51
Ukrainian paratroopers capture 7 Russian soldiers in operation near Kurakhove
19:29
Zelenskyy awards Hero of Ukraine title to defender Dmytro Maslovskyi, who died in hand-to-hand combat
19:10
Exclusive
Military expert Zgurets addresses claims of 'manipulation' in WWII-era mine report
18:50
OPINION
Rubio understands Putin’s true goal
18:31
Russia’s Putin, Iran’s Pezeshkian sign strategic partnership agreement
18:10
Press release
Serhiy Zgurets' materials are reliable, free of manipulation: Espreso on controversy around publication on outdated mine procurement
17:54
In Kryvyi Rih, man lost his second wife in Russian attack, having buried his first during Kherson's occupation
17:35
97 clashes reported on Russian-Ukrainian front on Jan.17: tense situation in Pokrovsk sector
More news