Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Shoigu has no power as Secretary of Russian Security Council - Piontkovsky

18 May, 2024 Saturday
15:51

Prominent Washington-based political scientist Andrey Piontkovsky has shared his thoughts on recent changes in the highest echelons of Russian government

client/title.list_title

He said this in an interview with the host of the Studio West program, Antin Borkovskyi.

Piontkovsky noted that the appointment to the position of Security Council Secretary, which Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu was transferred to, means nothing.

“This position of Patrushev, the position of the Security Council Secretary, is an empty position. It was important because Patrushev played this crucial role as a war ideologist, he had been instilling in Putin for 10 years this concept that we can defeat states that are much stronger than us by blackmailing them with nuclear weapons. And now this Security Council is a bunch of pensioners, Medvedev and Shoigu will make some strange speeches there, it doesn't matter,” he explained.

The political scientist also commented on the arrests of high-ranking officials such as Ivanov and Kuznetsov, which he believes are related to Russia's failures in the war against Ukraine.

“Putin understands that this is due to his realization that blackmail has failed. Now he is thinking about how to stay in power. Now he will try to impose on the West and Ukraine some version of what he calls Korea. And yet he will have to publicly admit that the main goal of the war-the destruction of the Ukrainian state-has failed and will never be realized. He will have to name the culprits, the Defense Ministry will be named guilty, and there will be a huge trial of generals. And he still has some personal close relations with Shoigu. And if Shoigu cannot be put in the dock, because everyone remembers their joint trips to the Tuvan taiga and how close they were, then he simply put Shoigu in a warm place on his retirement - he took traitors and thieves in the Defense Ministry out of the upcoming trial. This is my explanation. This is an empty place, Shoigu has no power there,” Piontkovsky emphasized.

Piontkovsky's comments lift the veil on the complex internal maneuvers within the Russian government and make it clear that even within the Kremlin itself there are doubts about the success of their aggressive foreign policy.

“He needs a long war, he repeats this every day. That this fool Belousov, who is supposedly, as we are told, the only person in Russia who does not steal (although this is highly questionable, as data on Belousov's palaces have already emerged), has been put in charge. But now he has a double task, he has realized that the victory over Ukraine in the sense in which he wanted to achieve it-the destruction of Ukrainian statehood-will never happen, and now he needs to crawl away. He wants to preserve the Korean version of territorial gains as much as possible and sell it as a draw. But a draw is not a victory, because the thieves and traitors of the Ministry of Defense were in the way, and there will be a huge trial of them. That's what Putin is doing now and what is the meaning of these two sensational resignations,” the political analyst concluded.

  • On May 12, Russian dictator Putin announced personnel changes in the Kremlin government - Sergei Shoigu is to be replaced as Russia's defense minister by Andrey Belousov, who was the first deputy prime minister in the previous government.
  • According to ISW, Kremlin leader Vladimir Putin has replaced Sergei Shoigu with Andrei Belousov as Russia's defense minister, and moved Shoigu to the post of secretary of the Security Council to replace Nikolai Patrushev, in preparation for a protracted war in Ukraine and a future confrontation with NATO.  

  • UK intelligence doesn't foresee any changes in the course of the war in Ukraine on Russia's part after Sergei Shoigu’s resignation as Defense Minister.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Tuesday
4 February
21:45
Gimli robotic complex joins Ukraine's army, aiding in evacuation and resupply
21:30
Exclusive
When could Ukraine hold elections after the war? Lawyer explains
21:12
Ryanair plans to resume flights to Lviv, Kyiv 4-6 weeks after war ends
20:57
Black Sea tankers wreck: IMO holds Russia responsible
20:40
"Don't let them drain resources": military commander reacts to Trump
20:23
Polish Military Institute of Armament Technology, Ukrainian NAUDI agree to cooperate
20:07
Exclusive
USAID funding freeze: Expert Riabtsev on potential risks for Ukraine’s energy sector
19:51
Exclusive
Trump's proposal to get rare metals from Ukraine is political move – analyst
19:35
"We are open to U.S. investments": Zelenskyy responds to Trump's statement on rare earth elements
19:08
Ukraine to introduce mandatory psychological aid training for doctors – First Lady
19:02
Updated
Russian ballistic missile strike on Ukraine’s Izyum kills 5, injures 52
18:50
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces may have to withdraw from Chasiv Yar – military analyst
18:33
Von der Leyen urges EU to find "most creative way" to use Russian assets for Ukraine
18:15
Exclusive
Western weapons can now strike deep into Russia, but new problem emerges
17:54
U.S., Ukraine did not discuss elections before 2025 — Ambassador Markarova
17:34
Updated
"The situation is critical": IAEA chief visits key substations vital for Ukraine's nuclear power plants
17:14
Russian national hockey team banned from 2026 World Championship
16:55
Ukraine’s HIV response at risk amid U.S. aid freeze
16:33
Support for military aid to Ukraine declines in Poland
16:15
Russia equips Gerbera foam drones with warheads
15:56
Ukraine’s parliament approves defense loan agreement with UK
15:32
Ukrainian troops release GoPro footage of repelling Russian assault, eliminating two squads
15:14
OPINION
Ukraine’s power sector withstands winter challenges, but risks remain
14:55
Ukraine’s embassy facilitates meetings between Zelenskyy, Trump teams — Ambassador
14:33
Hopes for Russian democracy met harsh reality – Ex-MP Kendzior on Ukrainian diaspora in 1990s
13:57
Review
Russian advance slows down, how Ukrainian Armed Forces approaches change. Serhiy Zgurets' column
13:35
U.S. firefighters document impact of Russian strikes in Ukraine, set to release second film
13:16
Exclusive
Ukraine takes key step in reforming Armed Forces management system – military expert
12:55
Norway provides significant aid to Ukraine but profits from war-driven revenues
12:34
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 15-22
Russian forces scale back assaults in Pokrovsk sector: Ukrainian officer explains why
12:14
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 22-29
Russian forces pushing to launch battle for Kostiantynivka, Donetsk region
11:51
Ukraine retakes positions in Kupyansk, Russian command threatens troops with execution for retreating
11:32
OPINION
Where will Putin and Trump meet?
11:15
North Korean troops no longer fighting in Russia’s Kursk region — South Korean intel
10:53
110 clashes reported at front as Russian forces launch over 6,000 attacks on Ukraine
10:34
Russian army continues to suffer heavy losses despite slowing offensive – ISW
10:13
Scholz calls Trump’s proposal to trade Ukrainian rare earths for U.S. aid "very selfish"
09:54
Russian overnight attack on Ukraine: UAV debris hits Kyiv high-rise, fires in Cherkasy
09:35
Russia loses 1,270 soldiers, 92 drones, 18 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Monday
3 February
22:00
Nearly 63,000 people are missing in Ukraine
More news