Espreso. Global
OPINION

Who benefits from manipulating numbers of civilian casualties in Ukraine?

26 December, 2023 Tuesday
13:00

In recent days, I've encountered frequent comparisons of the "statistics" related to civilian casualties in the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine, citing figures like 10,000 over a year and a half. This is often contrasted with Israel's conflict with Hamas in Gaza over a month and a half

It's disheartening to witness the blatant manipulation employed by grown-up people. While I won't make claims about Gaza's statistics due to uncertainty about their accuracy and the percentage of civilian casualties (I'll note that Ukrainian "statistics" only include civilians), I can speak about Ukraine.

The data in question comes from the UN, specifically the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission, deployed since 2014. Their comprehensive data on losses during the Russian-Ukrainian war from 2014 to 2022 is considered the most thorough, accurate, and reliable.

The Mission, by default, refrains from trusting data provided by official bodies of any conflicted party, and this skepticism is understandable. Whether it's the Ministry of Health in the de facto occupation administration in Donetsk or Luhansk, or the Ministry of Health in the de facto government of Hamas in Gaza, the Mission takes every claim through verification. Their standard of proof is exceptionally high, demanding documentary evidence for each case and confirmation of the identity of every victim. In a low-intensity armed conflict, where field teams could investigate each incident, document cases, and interview victims or their close relatives, this approach was effective.

Due to the standard of proof, the entire system ceased functioning after February 24 of the previous year. Notably, during the initial weeks, the Mission faced near-paralysis while relocating staff – and thank god it did, while OSCE's Special Monitoring Mission neglected the safety of local employees and left them in Donetsk.

In the altered circumstances, the previous methodology became impractical. The UN Mission attempted to persist with this approach, disregarding its absurdity and inadequacy.

Despite significant efforts, numerous cases post-de-occupation in Kyiv, Chernihiv, Sumy, and later Kherson and Kharkiv regions were documented. Instances of shelling in populated areas away from the front line were recorded. However, the statistics fail to account for the victims of the Mariupol capture and various other unaccounted-for incidents. Much more is not taken into account, but to understand that the "statistics" do not reflect anything, it is enough to realize that Mariupol is not taken into account at all.

The Mission acknowledged the insufficiency of the data but continued to publish it, albeit with disclaimers of incompleteness – this is still misleading. These disclaimers only appear as footnotes in the report, while the statistics circulate in the information space, devoid of these hypocritical warnings. Unfortunately, the Mission persists in what amounts to information manipulation. This is regrettable.

Source

About the author. Vyacheslav Likhachev, researcher of far-right movements, human rights defender

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Friday
1 March
21:55
Review
Victorious news on 737th day of war: destroyed Russian equipment near Synkivka, explosions in Crimea
21:40
OPINION
Putin is too old to build regime 2.0
21:20
Ukrainian soldiers target elite Russian assault group in Avdiivka sector
20:58
Russian army tries to break through Ukraine's defense 25 times in Novopavlivka sector
20:36
Exclusive
France destroys Putin's 'red lines' - analyst of National Institute for Strategic Studies
20:12
Ukraine's army shoots down 228 UAVs in February, including 116 Lancets
19:42
Netherlands announces new military aid package for Ukraine: what it includes
19:20
Exclusive
Navalny's murder might motivate resistance, radicalise protests in Russia — sociologist Eidman
18:57
NATO: Putin's threats to use nuclear weapons is psychological intimidation
18:35
Russian missiles attacks Donetsk region, injuring civilians, damaging police station, hospital, kindergartens
18:14
Ukraine, Netherlands sign security agreement: what does it provide for?
17:50
Exclusive
Map of fighting in Marinka sector
Under heavy fire: Ukrainian officer on situation in Marinka sector
17:25
Frozen Russian assets won't replace US aid to Ukraine - Treasury Secretary Yellen
17:00
Exclusive
Why Scholz is hesitant to transfer Taurus to Ukraine?
16:40
Russian troops bomb residential buildings in Zaporizhzhia region, killing civilian man
16:20
Exclusive
Measuring temperature in chamber: diplomat on China's special envoy's trip to number of countries
16:00
Russia holds significant ammunition advantage, increases artillery shelling in Avdiivka direction
15:40
OPINION
Transnistria: Where there is a trace of Russia, there is war
15:25
Russia makes "powerful breakthrough" to Chasiv Yar to open way to 3 more localities - Khortytsia group of troops
15:07
British intelligence assesses level and prospects of Russian military industry
14:40
Exclusive
Red lines are blurring: military expert Zgurets on possible deployment of NATO troops to Ukraine
14:20
Transition to F-16 not swift, but Ukraine making every effort – Air Force
14:00
Ukraine's Intelligence attacks Russian Pantsir-S1 air defense system in Belgorod region
13:40
Umerov approves action plan to implement cooperation program with NATO for 2024
13:20
OPINION
Putin's message: whom was the dictator addressing?
13:00
Russian pilots feel they are in the sights — Ukraine's Air Force Spokesman Ihnat 
12:40
OSCE launches "Moscow mechanism" to document Russian war crimes
12:25
IL-76 crash: Russia says it's willing to return bodies to Ukraine; Ukraine responds
12:05
Britain urges Germany to send Taurus missiles to Ukraine - Bloomberg
11:45
Japan extends sanctions against Russian companies and individuals
11:27
Review
Does CIA have any bases in Ukraine and what was the purpose of its director's visit? Serhiy Zgurets's column
11:05
Polish farmers fail to provide evidence of Ukrainian grain returning from Lithuania to Poland 
10:47
Updated
Russian media claim attempted UAV attack on defense plant in Nizhny Novgorod region
10:30
No one in Europe is going to send troops to Ukraine - Czech Prime Minister
10:15
Russia loses 3 aircraft, 36 artillery systems and 920 troops in Ukraine overnight — General Staff
09:55
Russia transports its agricultural goods through Belarus to Poland — UP
09:35
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces transform Synkivka into graveyard for Russian equipment — Kupyansk Military Administration
2024, Thursday
29 February
22:10
OPINION
Putin's messages of war: Vitaliy Portnikov's column
21:57
Review
Victorious news on 736th day of war: Ukrainian forces down 3 Russian aircraft, target Russian soldiers in Bakhmut sector
21:40
Russia attacks 22 times in Avdiivka, Novopavlivka directions in one day — General Staff
More news