Espreso. Global
OPINION

Trump and the war in Ukraine: Scenarios

8 December, 2024 Sunday
14:58

Western media is actively discussing what shape Trump’s negotiations with Putin might take over the end of Russia's war on Ukraine

client/title.list_title

Trump wants the war to end, but there’s no concrete plan to guarantee that outcome. Putin, meanwhile, is content with advancing his invasion of Ukraine, even as his domestic problems pile up. The future remains uncertain, but four potential scenarios stand out.

1. No negotiations

Trump might analyze the situation and decide against hosting a summit for ceasefire talks, judging the risks of failure too high.

He could conclude that it’s too soon to strike a deal with Russia, as Moscow keeps escalating its demands and essentially insists on Ukraine’s surrender.

From Trump’s perspective, breaking his campaign promise to end the war might be preferable to returning from failed negotiations empty-handed. Such a failure would deal a significant blow to his reputation as a dealmaker early in his presidency.

2. Putin gets his way

A potential deal might play directly into Putin’s hands — securing Ukraine’s withdrawal from the Kursk region, legitimizing Russian control over occupied territories, easing sanctions, and prompting some European states to pursue better relations with Russia.

Putin could approach the talks offering minor concessions in exchange for guarantees that Ukraine would be left militarily defenseless. This would likely cripple its economy, as foreign investments hinge on security stability. Simultaneously, Putin might push for constitutional changes in Ukraine, like he did with the Minsk agreements in 2014, to retain leverage over Ukraine’s government.

If Trump engages on this basis, he might lean towards Russia’s terms, pressuring Ukraine to agree by threatening to cut off support entirely.

3. Trump achieves partial success

In this scenario, Trump confronts Putin directly, aiming to prevent further Russian aggression and safeguard what remains of Ukraine’s sovereignty.

Trump could deploy every available tool — arming Ukraine further, tightening sanctions, and isolating Russia diplomatically while targeting its allies like Iran, North Korea, and China.

He might propose a ceasefire deal that ensures Ukraine’s independence, including deploying Western troops (mainly European) under U.S. leadership.

In exchange, Trump might offer phased sanctions relief.

After intense negotiations, Putin could accept — partially fearing increased pressure and partially securing Ukraine’s exclusion from NATO. This way, Putin retains a chance of eventually dominating Ukraine entirely.

Ukraine, meanwhile, sacrifices some territory but gains long-term security for most of the country, creating a path to future economic success.

4. Failed negotiations

Trump and Putin might meet, only for talks to break down when neither is willing to budge. Such a failure could be softened by scheduling follow-up discussions.

In the meantime, the war would grind on. Trump could either scale back support for Ukraine, shifting responsibility to the EU, or maintain aid to create the impression that talks haven’t failed outright but are merely ongoing.

It’s hard to predict which scenario is most likely. Trump’s track record from his first term makes him unpredictable. Whether he understands that losing Ukraine threatens U.S. security interests, whether he believes Russia has the right to dominate its neighbors, or whether he’s truly focused on resolving the issue — it’s anyone’s guess. The answers will come soon enough.

Source

About the author. Boryslav Bereza, public figure, former People's Deputy of Ukraine

The editorial staff does not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Thursday
23 January
09:57
U.S. troops should be part of peacekeeping forces in Ukraine, Zelenskyy says
09:35
Russia loses 1,340 soldiers, 6 tanks and 72 drones in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Wednesday
22 January
21:40
On Unity Day, Ukrainian symbols reappeared in the Russian-occupied cities of Crimea
Activists send greetings from Crimea on Ukraine’s Unity Day
21:15
If borders were opened, 70% of Ukrainians would not move abroad, survey shows
21:00
Trump calls on Russia to make deal to end Ukraine war, warns of sanctions and tariffs
20:39
Exclusive
U.S. Presidential change – opportunity for Ukraine that must be seized, says MP Syniutka
20:18
Exclusive
Military expert explains why Russian forces succeed in encircling settlements
19:56
From defense to offense: key steps Ukraine must take to win war
19:37
From 5,700 to 1,110: Decline of Ukraine’s tank force from 1993 to 2013
19:15
Interview
Ukraine has every chance to become success story for EU if it pursues reforms, unlocks its potential — EU Commissioner Andrius Kubilius for Espreso
18:55
Ukrainian forces repel 41 Russian attacks in Pokrovsk sector
18:35
Russia shells Donetsk region 3,829 times over past day, causing multiple casualties
18:17
OPINION
Trump is back. His goal is 'golden age' for the USA, but where does Ukraine fit in it?
17:55
North Korea might send reinforcements to Kursk region, U.S. says
17:37
Russian army attacks Kostiantynivka with bombs, killing and injuring locals
17:16
OPINION
Kremlin's plan: war lasting lifetime of those who started it
16:55
EU Defense Commissioner Kubilius urges NATO to move military goals 14 years ahead due Russian threat
16:31
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 8-15
Russian forces may enter Ukraine's Dnipropetrovsk region as they advance toward Pokrovsk
16:10
Finnish 2S1 Gvozdika, also known as PSH 74, illustrative photo from open sources
Denmark supplies Ukraine with 2S1 Gvozdika self-propelled howitzer
15:49
'Reason behind North Korean troops' involvement': NATO Commander Cavoli assesses Russia's breakthrough potential
15:32
Syria terminates investment deal with Russia over Tartus port control
15:14
OPINION
Donald Trump's promise of strong U.S. leadership must begin with Ukraine
14:55
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 15-22
January 15-22 live war map: Russian forces launch assault on last stronghold in southern Donetsk region
14:43
Trump assigns envoy Kellogg to end war in Ukraine in 100 days — media
14:25
Exclusive
'Prepare for turbulence with mixed proposals': military expert Zgurets on Trump’s war settlement plan
14:06
Exclusive
Russia suffers heavy losses but fails to gain ground in Kupyansk sector — Achilles Battalion
13:50
Exclusive
Around 220 civilians refuse to evacuate Chasiv Yar despite ongoing fighting
13:32
OPINION
Trump's first statements and orders: what they reveal
13:14
Ukraine authorizes Poseidon unmanned aerial vehicle system for military use
12:57
Exclusive
Trump's 'hawks' must not repeat Obama's mistake — Ukrainian diplomat
12:38
Ukraine documents over 7,000 Russian environmental crimes amid ongoing war
12:21
OPINION
Trump: Putin is destroying Russia. Column by Vitaly Portnikov
12:00
Russia violates political prisoners' health rights in Crimea at least 64 times in 2024 — analysts
11:42
Ukrainian forces eliminate 21 North Korean fighters, wound 40 in Russia's Kursk region
11:23
121 combat clashes occur on Russian-Ukrainian front on Jan. 21 — General Staff
11:05
Ukraine will need at least 200,000 peacekeepers to ensure security after ceasefire - Zelenskyy
10:46
Exclusive
Trump has no reason to concede or compromise with Russia — international expert
10:28
Trump administration seeks lasting end to war in Ukraine — U.S. official
10:11
Exclusive
Putin appears to be 'CIA's best agent' — Ukrainian diplomat
09:52
Russia launches drone attack on Ukraine, causing casualties in Mykolaiv
More news