Espreso. Global
OPINION

Russia will collapse just like Soviet Union did

7 January, 2024 Sunday
19:50

At about this time 32 years ago, the Soviet Union ceased to exist

This marked the second stage of the empire's collapse. The initial stage occurred in 1917 when Poland, Finland, Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia (the last three for a brief period) seceded from the empire.

The second stage of the collapse brought independence to 14 republics, including Ukraine.

I don't know when and how the war will end, but in the event of a Russian defeat, the third stage of disintegration is very likely to be the result. Most likely, the final one, though perhaps the penultimate one.

Today we have a situation that resembles 1991 in almost every way:

  1. An unsuccessful imperial war – its goals have not been achieved.
  2. The economic crisis – there is not enough money for redistribution, and this is the most important "staple" for Russia.
  3. The collapse of ideology and attempts to create a common identity.
  4. Lack of basic security for the masses and elites.
  5. Demonstration of the insufficient capacity of the security forces to reduce fear.

But in addition, there are several factors that did not exist in 1991:

  1. Sanctions: the West was helping Russia back then, now it's the other way around.
  2. The Internet: a means of communication and self-organization, even when under control.
  3. The presence of major players with their own interests: China, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, etc.
  4. Estonia, Ukraine, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, etc. as success stories and role models.
  5. Lack of career prospects for local elites, which were given great importance in Soviet times (the career journey is often overlooked when considering the list of imperial "staples," but it played a crucial role in the downfall of many empires).

All these factors contribute to the collapse, while there are no new factors supporting preservation.

What lessons can we derive from 1991 that are applicable to our present circumstances?

  1. No empire lasts forever. The USSR was immeasurably more powerful than the current Russian Federation, but it collapsed nonetheless.
  2. Unity and legitimacy erode gradually and then plummet suddenly to zero. 
  3. An empire is incapable of presenting a vision of the future; this task falls solely to new leaders. 
  4. The dismantling of an empire is often instigated by the old elites, but liberation movements also play a crucial role. Despite their limited legitimacy, the old parliaments serve as a focal point. 
  5. The path from independence to a capable state is long and difficult, but it is important to start.
  6. The passive majority plays no role. The main role belongs to the old elites and an active minority, which can be very small. The passive majority wants stability and security, it accepts the agenda and the picture of the future developed by a microscopic active minority and broadcast by the old elites to the public.
  7. The West seems to lack comprehension, ensnared by Moscow-centrism and the allure of a "great culture." Fearful of the repercussions, it attempts to cling to the empire until its final days, and then accepts reality.
  8. The empire needs to be destroyed, otherwise it will seek to recover.

Source

About the author. Valeriy Pekar, lecturer at the Kyiv-Mohyla Academy.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Friday
23 February
21:40
Review
Victorious news of 730th day of war: destroyed Russian Tor-M2 and Strela-10, €1.8bn in military support from Denmark
21:25
Updated
Ukraine’s forces target another Russian A-50 radar aircraft
21:20
Ukrainian army repels 18 Russian attacks in 5 directions - General Staff
21:00
DPRK supplies Russia with 1.5 million ammo produced in 1970s-1980s - Ukrainian intelligence
20:45
Canada announces additional sanctions against Russia
20:15
Russian army destroys almost 500 tons of grain overnight in Donetsk region
19:50
Ukrainian officials arrive at Poland's border, but do not meet with Polish counterparts
19:30
Updated
Russia’s missiles, attack drones kill at least four in Ukraine
19:12
Exclusive
Japan provides record aid to Ukraine, thus supporting US and EU - Zhevago
18:50
Ukrainians, your fight is our fight: Polish media thanks Ukraine for resisting Russian aggression
18:20
Ukraine war is giant Ponzi scheme: fake news for February 23
17:50
Russian forces use chemical weapons in Tavria sector - General Tarnavskyi
17:20
What long-range weapons can Germany provide to Ukraine?
16:50
Russia can use almost 300 combat aircraft against Ukraine - intelligence
16:20
Situation in eastern Ukraine isn't critical - Ukrainian military
15:51
Exclusive
Putin promises to give Transcarpathia to Orban as loyal ally - former Aidar battalion commander
15:30
Zelenskyy arrives in Lviv, signs security agreement with Danish PM Frederiksen
15:10
Biden announces new sanctions on Russia for second anniversary of full-scale invasion
14:55
Exclusive
Russian troops afraid to move around Avdiivka even after capturing city - military expert Zgurets
14:36
British intelligence explains why Putin needs to "clean up" information space in Russia
14:13
Exclusive
Scholz holds key: Military expert Zgurets reveals number of Taurus missiles Ukraine could acquire
13:58
Zelenskyy names reasons for Zaluzhnyi's resignation and change of military command
13:34
Pro-Soviet narratives imposed on deported Ukrainian children in camps in Belarus - Skhemy
13:14
 OSCE opens Living The War exhibition on Russian war crimes
12:50
Review
Ukrainian drone development during war and UAV strikes on Russian troops. Column by Serhiy Zgurets
12:14
OPINION
Putin prepares to annex Transnistria
11:53
EU countries seek to raise $1.5 billion to buy ammunition for Ukraine — media
11:33
Exclusive
Moldova faces serious challenges of 'PMR' annexation to Russia, Ukraine must be prepared - Ukrainian officer Lapin
11:05
Russia is becoming more open about repressions of Ukrainians in occupied territories - ISW
10:44
Russia loses 1,000 soldiers, 49 artillery systems and 32 UAVs per day in Ukraine - General Staff
10:25
Exclusive
Russian troops regroup in Avdiivka direction after significant losses - NGU spokesman
10:05
US to impose sanctions on over 500 Russian targets on second anniversary of full-scale invasion - media
09:43
"World is not really ready for Putin to lose power": Zelenskyy answers when war will end
2024, Thursday
22 February
22:10
Review
Victorious news of 729th day of war: weapons for Ukraine to strike behind enemy lines, Russia’s mass casualties at training ground
21:55
Russian troops try to breach Ukraine’s defense 31 times in Marinka direction, storm left bank’s bridgehead
21:40
Putin considers Biden's calling him a 'crazy SOB' as 'adequate reaction'
21:23
UN confirms over 30,000 civilian casualties in Ukraine as result of Russian aggression
21:05
Navalny's mother says authorities demand secret funeral, blackmailing her
20:50
Russia may unleash massive air assault on February 24: how many missiles, Shahed drones does it have?
20:31
Lavrov's plane denied refueling in Brazil: he will fly to meet with President da Silva as 'fellow traveler'
More news