Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Former Deputy Defense Minister explains why Ukraine does not disclose war losses

6 February, 2024 Tuesday
18:40

Ukraine's former Deputy Minister of Defense Hanna Malyar said that safety of the military is one of the reasons why the government does not disclose the number of Ukrainians killed at the front

client/title.list_title

She said this in an interview with Espreso.

When asked whether she shares the idea of David Arakhamia, leader of the Servant of the People faction, who is trying to convince Zelenskyy to publish data on Ukraine's losses in the full-scale war, Malyar said that at first she did not understand the motives for hiding this information from the public until the military explained it to her.

She emphasized that the issue of concealing the number of Ukrainian casualties is not about freedom of speech or people's access to information. The primary reason for this is that "the military, when planning their operations, rely on information about the number of combat-ready people in adversary units".

"They have limits on how many per cent are already incapacitated - both the killed and the wounded are equally incapacitated for them. When there is a battle or an operation is planned, they count the number of units, and they calculate the losses for themselves to determine what other tasks this unit can be sent to," explained the former Deputy Minister of Defense of Ukraine, adding that knowing the conditional number of losses, the enemy calculates the capabilities of the unit to be attacked.

Malyar noted that Russia also hides its casualty figures from Ukraine. However, given that Kyiv is also fighting Russia on the information front, Ukraine publishes their figures.

"This is our war with them. But the military asks us not to disclose our figures, it's a state secret, that's why I'm explaining it."

In addition, Malyar explained the background of the case in 2022, when the Commander-in-Chief announced the number of Ukrainian losses - 9,000 dead.

"We had civic initiatives that believed that the state did not want to say how many people died. So they started collecting information from the relatives of the killed. Although this information cannot be concealed after the victory, because it is payments. And they came up with a similar figure in comparison with our data" she said.

Then, according to Malyar, the authorities had to publish the number of casualties to prevent similar cases in the future, as it would be "very dangerous for the Armed Forces themselves"

"So they decided that they would say this, and then explain to the public that these figures should not be announced, because it is important for the military. And then we carried out an information campaign, and tried to explain the best we could," stated the former Deputy Minister of Defense of Ukraine.

  • On 22 August 2022, Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Valeriy Zaluzhnyi said that almost 9,000 Ukrainian servicemen had been killed in the war with Russia. 
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Wednesday
17 July
21:00
Review
Victorious news of 875th day of war: 95 Ukrainian defenders released from Russian captivity, Ukrainian military destroys 28 Russian ships since 2022
20:40
Ukraine launches Saving Lives of Servicemen program, focusing on training, medical care, recreation
20:17
Russia loses stocks of Soviet-era tanks - media
19:55
Russian forces destroy civilian river crossing in Kharkiv region
19:32
Review
99 clashes occur at front, Russia focuses on three directions - Ukraine's General Staff
19:12
Russia strikes at social infrastructure in Donetsk region, there are casualties
18:50
"Krynky had impact on entire war zone": military expert on Ukrainian troops' withdrawal
18:24
Ukrainian military destroys 28 Russian ships since all-out war began
18:00
Exclusive
Russian group surrenders in Lyman sector - Ukrainian military
17:39
Russian military sets up firing points on Crimea beaches - Atesh partisan movement
17:17
Exclusive
"It happened earlier": military expert on Ukrainian army's withdrawal from Krynky, Kherson region
16:55
European Parliament adopts resolution to support Ukraine, condemns Orban's visit to Russia
16:35
China says it appreciates Hungary's 'mediation efforts' on Ukraine and Russia
16:13
United States allocates $182 million for demining Ukraine
15:50
Ukraine returns 2 children from occupied Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia regions
15:33
95 Ukrainian defenders released from Russian captivity
15:22
Russian fake in Europe: 'Ukrainian child trafficking managed by Olena Zelenska'
15:00
Germany may halve military aid to Ukraine in 2025 - media
14:39
Belgium allocates €150 million for Ukraine's reconstruction
14:20
Exclusive
July 10-17 live war map: Russia deploys resources without achieving desired results
14:00
Trump contemplates easing sanctions against Russia to end war in Ukraine
13:41
Exclusive
Urozhaine is under Russian control: DeepState on situation in Donetsk region
13:22
Japan to transfer $3.3 billion of frozen Russian assets to Ukraine
13:04
Exclusive
Clear sky for F-16s: military expert Zgurets on systematic work to weaken Russian air defense
12:46
Review
Ten years since MH17 tragedy: memory and truth
12:25
Ukrainian air defense downs 4 Russian reconnaissance UAVs
12:07
Greece considers selling old F-16s to help Ukraine - media
11:50
Exclusive
Russian 'meat' assaults halt in Pokrovsk direction — Ukrainian military
11:31
Review
Another unexpected US ban emerges alongside restrictions on weapon use. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:12
Germany to allocate €10 million to rebuild Kyiv's Okhmatdyt hospital
10:54
Exclusive
Other countries must join war in Ukraine to defeat Russia – diplomat Chaly
10:33
Updated
Russian army attacks in 11 frontline areas, 112 combat clashes occur over past day - Ukraine's General Staff
10:13
Russian troops advance near 4 settlements in Donetsk region – DeepState
09:55
Ukrainian forces target Russian air defense systems to prepare for F-16 deployment - ISW
09:34
Russia loses 1,110 soldiers, 43 artillery systems, 11 tanks in Ukraine per day
2024, Tuesday
16 July
21:22
Review
Victorious news of 874th day of war: partisans disclose secret military center in Crimea, Ukrainian troops hit Russian air defense system in Donetsk region
21:05
Russian losses in Kharkiv sector reaching divisions, but they keep storming - 3rd Brigade
20:45
OPINION
How should Ukraine talk to European right?
20:24
Exclusive
Ukraine is likely to receive up to 20 Mirage-2000 fighter jets from France - Defense Express
20:01
Russia uses medical check-ups as pretext for deportation, brings doctors from Yakutia to Ukraine
More news