Espreso. Global
OPINION

Ukraine needs elections, but war makes them impossible

5 February, 2025 Wednesday
15:00

I will write about elections seriously once and, until the end of hostilities, I would prefer not to return to this topic

client/title.list_title

Are elections needed in Ukraine? Yes, very much so. Not so much to change the government (which might not necessarily happen), but to reboot the system of political relations. The cycle that began in March 2019 has largely run its course. This is how it usually works here: the system functions for 3-4 years, and then imbalance starts. The great war shifted this, but both the parliament and the executive branch need renewal.

Are elections possible during active war? No, they are not possible. Conducting elections requires conditions in which candidates and voters can freely participate in the campaign and voting process.

"Without a sustainable ceasefire over most of the country, it is impossible to establish the work of commissions, ensure the operation of polling stations, and guarantee proper conditions for counting votes. All of this is an inseparable part of the democratic process. In other words, the legitimacy of the result would inherently be in question."

Trust from citizens and reliable partners is impossible if elections take place under such intense wartime conditions:

  1. If a significant portion of voters cannot vote or is subjected to pressure, elections lose their representativeness.
  2. If people are afraid to go to polling stations because a missile might strike (this is why comparing the war of 2014-2015 with that of 2022 is foolish), and voter turnout is 20-25%, then what real legitimacy are we talking about?
  3. Ensuring observers' access to all polling stations is also impossible without a stable ceasefire.

The ability of military personnel to vote and be elected is a crucial element of legitimacy. Without a stable ceasefire, military personnel who are defending the country and absolutely should have the right not only to vote but also to stand for election will not be able to exercise that right.

"The military is the population group with the highest level of social legitimacy, despite the views of some segments of fools. Most of the military are conscripts, and most of them will not choose a military career. Even professional soldiers may wish to try to change the country through politics."

Only after achieving a stable ceasefire can we talk about the full possibility for military personnel not only to vote but also to conduct election campaigns (if they wish to run). Candidates from among the military must have the same conditions for campaigning. This requires a stable ceasefire.

Kellogg's statement and similar messages from other partners (we ignore Putin’s statements, as who cares?) as well as the noise from internal enemies must receive a clear and direct response: first, the war must end, a stable ceasefire must be established – then elections. It could be three months after a ceasefire is fixed, maybe six – that’s a matter of the quality of guarantees. Under any other conditions, these won’t be elections, but an imitation.

And yes, other countries holding elections during wars are a figment of Kellogg’s imagination. If a war took place on their territory – elections were not held. South Korea in 1952 was not a democracy, and Lee Seungman fabricated the result. The U.S. held elections in 1944 when Roosevelt was re-elected for a fourth term, and there was no war on U.S. soil. As for democratic Britain, it lived with a 1936 parliament until 1945. Somehow, they managed without elections.

To summarize, elections can and must take place under three conditions:

  1. Security first, as it guarantees free voting, transparency, and legality—all of which ensure legitimacy.
  2. Legitimacy is the priority. The conditions of the vote affect the recognition of the results both domestically and internationally. Ukrainians must trust their own electoral process and know that the majority had the opportunity to vote.
  3. Military personnel and those assisting the army must have the right to vote and run for office. This is only possible in the absence of active hostilities.

Therefore, peace and security guarantees first - then elections. Anything else is either fantasy or madness.

Source

About the author. Yurii Bohdanov, publicist, specialist in strategic communications in business, public administration, and politics.

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Thursday
13 February
11:52
Russian forces block water and humanitarian aid deliveries to civilians in frontline areas
11:35
"Putin would say he won": Trump says he'll keep supporting Ukraine
11:16
Russian civilians evacuated to Ukraine after Russia’s deadly strike on shelter
10:54
116 clashes occur at front on Feb. 12: Russia launches over 5,000 strikes on Ukraine
10:33
European countries and Ukraine demand a say in any peace talks
10:15
Exclusive
Russian troops attempt to fully sever Pokrovsk-Kostiantynivka highway
09:56
U.S. envoy Kellogg to visit Ukraine for “tough diplomacy” — U.S. State Department
09:36
Russia loses 1,250 soldiers, 17 tanks, 58 artillery systems in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Wednesday
12 February
22:00
Russia launches record number of strikes on Donetsk region since war started
21:45
Exclusive
Russian army does not hesitate to drop bombs on its citizens: Ukrainian military on Kursk sector
21:33
Exclusive
How Ukraine shoots down ballistic missiles may remain classified
21:21
F-16 with JASSM-ER, illustrative photo
First F-16 photo during combat mission in Ukraine emerges online — what does it reveal?
21:10
Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania: Trump himself will decide to stand by Ukraine
21:00
Zelenskyy and Trump hold talks
20:50
Russia blocks IAEA experts' rotation at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant – Ukraine's MFA
20:40
Zelenskyy: Work on Trump’s plan to end Ukraine war likely to start in February
20:26
Ukraine wins 16 medals at 2025 Invictus Games
20:11
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
Russia is forced to retreat in some areas of Pokrovsk sector
19:51
UK pledges £150 million in military aid to Ukraine
19:36
“I prayed for Trump's protection at rally before assassination attempt” — Jason Sharron, Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania
19:25
NATO membership for Ukraine is unrealistic, says U.S. Defense Secretary Hagseth
19:10
Exclusive
Russia training surviving North Korean soldiers to reinforce troops in Kursk region
18:49
NATO must ensure negotiation results that Putin can’t overturn in six months or year – Rutte
18:11
600,000 Ukrainian children trapped in occupied territories: over 40,000 still enrolled in Ukrainian schools
18:00
Interview
Ukrainian Catholic Church priest in Pennsylvania on beauty of Ukrainian traditions and why Trump can be helpful for Ukraine
17:50
Supporting Ukraine is top foreign policy priority — Sweden’s top diplomat
17:32
'Putin will lose if he attacks NATO': Rutte on Russian threat in Europe
17:15
Exclusive
"Much hinges on Kellogg's meeting with Zelenskyy's team" regarding Trump's peace plan — Ukrainian MP
16:51
NATO Secretary General Rutte announces new military aid for Ukraine
16:37
White House power struggle: Trump ally Vitkoff’s Moscow move sparks clash over Ukraine policy
16:15
China assists Russian drone production with smuggled Western parts — Estonian intel
15:53
Zelenskyy says assassination attempts on him led to deaths in President's Office
15:42
Exclusive
European allies to announce new military aid after Ramstein meeting — Espreso correspondent
15:30
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
February 5-12 live war map: Ukrainian counterattacks yield results 
15:14
Soldier stabbed at Kharkiv recruitment center as Ukraine faces surge in attacks on military personnel
14:55
Updated
Ramstein meeting kicks off in Brussels: Key issues on the agenda
14:54
Russian soldiers seen attempting assault on Ukraine positions on crutches: video
14:32
Ukraine's Security Service uncovers FSB mole within its top ranks
14:15
Leaked video exposes Russian PSYOP: commander admits bombing civilians in Sudzha
13:55
Exclusive
Russia struggles with innovation, lacks time in weapons development — military expert
More news