Espreso. Global
OPINION

Unbearable cost of defeat for Ukraine

23 December, 2024 Monday
12:16

We sometimes desire peace so much that we don't consider its cost. But in politics, 'peace at any cost' doesn't work

client/title.list_title

There is always a price that cannot be paid. So let me try to show the cost of "defeat" for Ukraine.

There are two basic scenarios for Ukraine’s defeat in the war: crushing and freezing. The first scenario is clear: the Russian army breaks through the front or encircles Ukrainian forces - we are forced to make a peace agreement. These won't be the conditions of Istanbul; it will be much worse. They will take 4 regions, forbid us from having armed forces (only police), force us to return all Soviet and Russian-era monuments, establish Russian as the state language, impose reparations for Donbas, which we will pay for decades. Most likely, they will demand that we hand over our commanders who were particularly successful on the front.

However, this will not be the end of the war. Organized military groups will turn to terrorism and insurgency. And not just against the Russians, but also against the official government. Amid this chaos, the West will wash its hands even more and take away the workforce. In fact, we will have a "failed state," a hollow state. Corruption, arms, human, and drug trafficking will thrive.

Freezing could be another defeat scenario. The key in this scenario is that freezing does not end the war, but continues it without the active phase. In this scenario, there can be both defeat and victory. The logic of defeat is when freezing weakens us but not the enemy, and the logic of victory is when it weakens the enemy.

Freezing means maintaining the front line. For Ukraine, this means we will be forced to keep large military forces to deter Russia. In some ways, we've already experienced this after Minsk. We will continue to spend significant funds on defense in the face of an almost stagnant economy. Migration will intensify, as it will become impossible to hold people in the country by force, and there will be very few reasons to stay.

After freezing, Ukraine will disappear from the West's agenda, meaning its aid will become small and conditional. NATO and EU membership will remain suspended. Meanwhile, Russia's "advocates" like Orbán and Fico will actively push for lifting sanctions, giving Putin the much-needed resources. Ukraine will also be forced to hold elections, which could lead to a major internal split and political confrontation.

When I hear "how much longer will this last," "how much have we lost," I understand that we are all exhausted, and we have already paid a high price. But even in this situation, we need to understand that defeat is an even greater cost. And personally, the greatest cost of defeat for me would be the devaluation of the memory of Ukrainian heroes.

Source

About the author. Viktor Andrusiv, political and public figure, analyst, journalist.

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Wednesday
5 February
12:48
Updated
Ukrainian forces target oil refinery in Russia's Krasnodar region, fire breaks out
12:37
Exclusive
Ukraine targets 30 Russian facilities in January — military expert Zgurets
12:15
OPINION
Exchanging Ukraine’s rare earth metals for U.S. military aid is solid deal. Column by Vitaly Portnikov
11:54
Russian conscription fails to offset battlefield losses — ISW
11:32
Review
Ukraine’s military reform: key goals, objectives. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
11:09
Ukrainian forces repel 35 Russian attacks near Pokrovsk, 12 in Kursk region on Feb. 4
10:31
Exclusive
Russia likely increases Shahed drone warhead to 90kg — Kharkiv official
10:13
Over 45,000 Ukrainian soldiers killed in war with Russia — Zelenskyy
09:55
Russia loses 1,140 soldiers, 52 artillery systems, 9 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
09:36
Updated
Russian ballistic missile strike on Ukraine’s Izyum kills 5, injures 55
2025, Tuesday
4 February
21:45
Gimli robotic complex joins Ukraine's army, aiding in evacuation and resupply
21:30
Exclusive
When could Ukraine hold elections after the war? Lawyer explains
21:12
Ryanair plans to resume flights to Lviv, Kyiv 4-6 weeks after war ends
20:57
Black Sea tankers wreck: IMO holds Russia responsible
20:40
"Don't let them drain resources": military commander reacts to Trump
20:23
Polish Military Institute of Armament Technology, Ukrainian NAUDI agree to cooperate
20:07
Exclusive
USAID funding freeze: Expert Riabtsev on potential risks for Ukraine’s energy sector
19:51
Exclusive
Trump's proposal to get rare metals from Ukraine is political move – analyst
19:35
"We are open to U.S. investments": Zelenskyy responds to Trump's statement on rare earth elements
19:08
Ukraine to introduce mandatory psychological aid training for doctors – First Lady
18:50
Exclusive
Ukrainian forces may have to withdraw from Chasiv Yar – military analyst
18:33
Von der Leyen urges EU to find "most creative way" to use Russian assets for Ukraine
18:15
Exclusive
Western weapons can now strike deep into Russia, but new problem emerges
17:54
U.S., Ukraine did not discuss elections before 2025 — Ambassador Markarova
17:34
Updated
"The situation is critical": IAEA chief visits key substations vital for Ukraine's nuclear power plants
17:14
Russian national hockey team banned from 2026 World Championship
16:55
Ukraine’s HIV response at risk amid U.S. aid freeze
16:33
Support for military aid to Ukraine declines in Poland
16:15
Russia equips Gerbera foam drones with warheads
15:56
Ukraine’s parliament approves defense loan agreement with UK
15:32
Ukrainian troops release GoPro footage of repelling Russian assault, eliminating two squads
15:14
OPINION
Ukraine’s power sector withstands winter challenges, but risks remain
14:55
Ukraine’s embassy facilitates meetings between Zelenskyy, Trump teams — Ambassador
14:33
Hopes for Russian democracy met harsh reality – Ex-MP Kendzior on Ukrainian diaspora in 1990s
13:57
Review
Russian advance slows down, how Ukrainian Armed Forces approaches change. Serhiy Zgurets' column
13:35
U.S. firefighters document impact of Russian strikes in Ukraine, set to release second film
13:16
Exclusive
Ukraine takes key step in reforming Armed Forces management system – military expert
12:55
Norway provides significant aid to Ukraine but profits from war-driven revenues
12:34
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 15-22
Russian forces scale back assaults in Pokrovsk sector: Ukrainian officer explains why
12:14
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 22-29
Russian forces pushing to launch battle for Kostiantynivka, Donetsk region
More news