Espreso. Global

Competition for mediators in potential Ukraine-Russia negotiations in full swing

16 September, 2024 Monday
15:16

Oleksandr Kovalenko, a Ukrainian military expert, analyzes the topic of “peace talks” between Ukraine and Russia, and the role of intermediaries in a potential negotiation process

client/title.list_title

The article was published as part of a joint project by OBOZ.UA and the Information Resistance group, citing Oleksandr Kovalenko.

The war in Ukraine, the largest conflict since World War II, presents a unique set of circumstances. Any country aspiring to play a major role in global or regional politics seeks to embed itself in this historic moment.

Thus, nearly every candidate for the role of mediator harbors not only conventional, self-serving interests. The leader of a country taking on this role automatically gains greater authority, recognition, and prominence in the historical narrative. Therefore, beyond the pursuit of material interests, there are also ambitions that current leaders may not have another chance to fulfill.

Turkey

According to Kovalenko,Turkey was the first to mediate Ukraine-Russia talks in 2022, but the process stalled, leaving behind the "Istanbul Agreements," often referenced by Russian propaganda. Despite supporting Ukraine's territorial integrity, including Crimea, Turkey maintains strong economic ties with Russia, ignoring most sanctions and sharing competing interests in Syria and Libya.

Turkey supports Ukraine’s territorial integrity but has economic and territorial interests that may align with Russia's demands in negotiations. Most mediator contenders have economic ties with Russia, questioning their impartiality. Turkey has lost its leading role and is no longer a top mediator candidate.

South Africa

In 2022, the Republic of South Africa joined the competition of peace plans. 

“However, South Africa began to take such initiatives almost immediately after reports surfaced about the transfer of South African weapons to Russia, which is why this option was never considered credible,” Kovalenko emphasizes.

Brazil

In February 2023, Brazil's new president, Lula da Silva, stated his desire to make an "exceptional contribution" to resolving the conflict but repeatedly emphasized that Ukraine should give up Crimea and recognize it as Russian.

For this overtly pro-Russian stance alone, Brazil's initiatives were not taken seriously and were relegated to the category of diplomatic chatter.

China

Since late 2022, China has signaled interest in mediating Ukraine-Russia peace talks with its peace plan. As a major international player, China's role could be decisive, but experts in Ukraine question whose side it will support.

Kyiv views Beijing's peace plan cautiously, despite China's formal support for Ukraine's territorial integrity, driven by its own Taiwan concerns. Though China hasn't recognized Crimea or the "DPR/LPR," its deep ties with Russia and economic interests raise distrust. Still, China holds the greatest influence over Moscow among potential mediators.

Kovalenko notes that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said in a recent interview with the Brazilian outlet Metropolitan that the peace plan proposed by Brazil and China was more in line with Russia's interests and had not been agreed with Ukraine, and therefore was rejected by Kyiv. Along with this interview, there was information that Volodymyr Zelenskyy might meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping in October.

“This suggests that, despite rejecting the Chinese peace plan, Kyiv does not dismiss the initiative entirely and is willing to discuss it at the highest level. Beijing, in turn, shares this readiness, indicating China's strong interest in being involved in the process,” the expert believes.

India

India has recently become active in the peace process, with Prime Minister Modi meeting Putin in Moscow and visiting Kyiv. Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov met with Brazilian and Indian counterparts in Saudi Arabia, and Indian National Security Advisor Ajit Doval is set to visit Russia this week.

Unexpectedly, India, positioning itself as a geopolitical player, has taken on the role of addressing potential peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine. Notably, India is a regional and even geopolitical rival of China, and, like China, has deep economic and energy ties with Russia, including extensive military-technical cooperation.

India, like other countries, seeks benefits from Russia, which raises doubts about its impartiality. However, Indian ammunition was crucial in addressing a shortage when U.S. aid was suspended. This competitive dynamic between India and China could potentially benefit Kyiv.

Azerbaijan

Over the past few weeks, there have been rumors that Baku may offer its mediation services. 

Ukraine and Azerbaijan have had stable relations, with Azerbaijan providing significant humanitarian aid and support during the war. Azerbaijani volunteers assisted Ukrainian refugees, and the country sent crucial equipment during energy attacks. Despite maintaining ties with Russia, Azerbaijan's position is influenced by regional dynamics and neighboring countries.

This summer, Azerbaijan's high-level reception of Vladimir Putin shocked many Ukrainians. The expected negative reaction was exacerbated by the lack of prior diplomatic preparation from Azerbaijan, which failed to mitigate the backlash. Instead of addressing the diplomatic misstep, Azerbaijan adopted an aggressive stance, dismissing Ukrainian concerns and emphasizing its internal policies.

The high-level diplomatic and informational missteps have led to widespread skepticism within Ukrainian society towards the idea of Azerbaijani mediation. This means that, at least in the short term, any process involving Azerbaijan will be met with strong distrust, effectively losing this opportunity.

However, time and certain developments may change this situation and increase Baku's chances of becoming more than just a participant in the mediation group.

Other "applicants"

Apart from the main contenders, others like Hungary's Viktor Orbán, known for his pro-Russian stance, are showing interest but with limited credibility.

Unexpectedly, Pakistan might also emerge as a serious contender, especially given its positive relations with China. This could lead to a potential mediation partnership between the two.

Oleksandr Kovalenko notes that most serious mediators support Ukraine's territorial integrity, but also have strong ties to Russia, raising concerns about bias. Competition among mediators leads to more flexible and historically impactful proposals. China and India have the highest chances due to their influence over Russia. However, other serious players could still emerge.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Tuesday
15 October
21:20
Up to 90% of Ukrainian POWs in Russia were tortured or sexually abused
21:04
Hans Zimmer, composer of Pirates of the Caribbean and Dune, supports Ukraine at U.S. concert
20:50
Ukrainian forces target over 10,000 Russian artillery systems in 2024 worth $8bn
20:33
Exclusive
Russia-DPRK agreement is, in fact, strategic military alliance - Defense Express
20:18
Review
Research reveals network of Canadian websites disseminating pro-Kremlin narratives
20:00
Exclusive
North Korea will help Russia, Ukrainian army will have to destroy large number of manpower - military
19:42
Exclusive
Story is far from over: sociologist Shulga on Kadyrov's ‘blood revenge’
19:25
US pressures Zelenskyy to lower mobilization age, adviser says
19:04
Expensive and embarrassing failure: British intelligence analyses effectiveness of Russian 'Hunter' drone
18:40
Group of North Korean soldiers escape from Russian positions near Ukraine border
18:15
Netherlands proposes to temporarily exclude Hungary from Schengen
17:54
Exclusive
Russian offensive is losing momentum, operational pause inevitable – Ukrainian officer
17:23
80% Ukrainians support law banning Russia-linked religious groups - survey
16:54
Ukraine and Mauritius sign agreement to establish visa-free travel
16:34
OPINION
Georgia: Putin's vendetta to begin in October
16:15
Spanish police seize 13 tons of banned chemicals bound for Russia
15:52
Why would North Korea send military officers to Ukraine to support Russia?
15:20
War is brewing between the Koreas: Defense Express explains why the DPRK-Russia alliance is key
14:59
Russia reportedly forms “special Buryat battalion” with DPRK citizens
14:41
Russia's weekly war spending exceeds annual budgets of 80% of its regions
14:16
Rostelecom warns of possible Google services shutdown in Russia
13:57
Exclusive
Russia's war of attrition isn't going as planned – military expert Zgurets
13:44
Exclusive
From Romanian border to Zaporizhzhia front line: American couple hosts charity race to support Ukrainians
13:23
Exclusive
Russia is pulling more nations into abyss of war – military expert Seleznyov
12:59
EU discusses possibility to keep Russian gas transit through Ukraine
12:45
Russia launches Shahed, missile attacks on Ukraine, resulting in civilian deaths and injuries in Mykolaiv
12:30
Nearly 200 clashes in one day at Russian-Ukrainian, most focused on Kurakhove
11:59
OPINION
Why does Putin need North Korean soldiers?
11:26
“To push for negotiations": ISW names purpose of Russian strikes on Ukraine's port infrastructure
11:09
Exclusive
Large numbers of Russian military surrender due to low morale
10:39
Exclusive
Russian troops attempting to advance toward southern Pokrovsk - NGU reserve major
10:18
Russian Orthodox Church justifies war in Ukraine as "treatment"
09:56
Exclusive
Ukraine holds off Russian troops despite reinforcements in Luhansk region — Military Administration Chief
09:36
Russia loses 1,210 soldiers, 13 tanks and 44 armored vehicles in one day of war in Ukraine
2024, Monday
14 October
21:35
No intact houses, shelters left in Toretsk, Russian forces move into new areas
21:15
North Korea has joined Russia's war on Ukraine, Zelenskyy states
20:50
Exclusive
Ukrainian military: Russia usually deploys regiments in Kurakhove sector
20:25
Ukraine calls on Brazil to arrest Putin if he attends G20 summit 
20:02
Exclusive
Defense Express assesses threat of North Korean soldiers reinforcing Russian army
19:40
Zelenskyy to present victory plan to Verkhovna Rada on October 16 — official
More news