Espreso. Global

Russia has suffered a crushing defeat on the artistic frontline

14 February, 2023 Tuesday
16:54

We have an important reason to celebrate Ukraine's powerful victory on the global artistic frontline. This victory over our enemy, Russia, will have far-reaching consequences. In fact, we are beginning to convince the whole world that the lion's share of the so-called "great Russian culture" is appropriated, stolen from Ukrainians. And this is just the beginning

One of the world's leading art museums, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, has recognized artists Arkhip Kuindzhi, Ilya Repin, and Ivan Aivazovsky as Ukrainian artists. Also, the Museum's website officially mentioned that Kuindzhi's museum in Mariupol was destroyed by Russians. In addition, a painting by Edgar Degas was renamed, also in favor of Ukraine. Why is this important? 

For centuries, the authority of Russian culture has been built by appropriating Ukrainian culture. Russia has been hiding from political bad weather and global condemnation by using our culture, passing it off as part of its own. They say they have "great Russian culture," so they are a superpower. But right now, the reverse process is underway, when the whole world is realizing that the king is naked, and the lion's share of the so-called Russian culture was created by Ukrainians.

In order to prevent anyone from asking where the culture of a huge nation of millions had gone, Russians adopted and massively exported to the world the concept of sharovarshchyna - ersatz reworking, a terrible simplification of Ukrainian folk culture. All of this was based on showcase samples of our folk culture that were not contradictory to Russia. By the way, an alternative to this approach was shown by the Ukrainian Republican Chapel of the Directory, which became a phenomenon of world choral art, performing "Shchedryk" and other hits around the world. 

Having primitivized folk culture and imposed this vision of Ukraine on the world, the Muscovites appropriated all professional artists. Starting with Ukrainian composers Dmytro Bortniansky, Maksym Berezovsky, and Artem Vedel and ending with a whole galaxy of artists of different centuries and generations-from the 18th century in the works of Dmytro Levytsky and Volodymyr Borovykovsky to the 21st century in the works of Ilya Kabakov. 

However, let's go back to Arkhip Kuindzhi. He was the most popular artist in the empire, but he devoted his work almost exclusively to Ukrainian nature and Ukrainians. And because of a series of conflicts with the Russian artistic environment and authorities, he went into voluntary self-isolation and painted without intending to ever present those works while actively supporting other artists. Arkhip was born in Mariupol and lived most of his life in Crimea. His closest social circle included his fellow Ukrainian artists: Ilya Repin, Ivan Kramskoi, Kostiantyn Kryzhytskyi, and many others. This is the perfect portrait of a "Russian artist."

Portrait of Archip Kuindzhi, by Ivan Kramskoy, 1872

 

Russians have always imposed on the world the stance that Kuindzhi should not be called anything other than a Russian artist. They turned a blind eye to his Greek origin and his distinctly Ukrainian themes. And unfortunately, as in the case of Kramskoi, Repin, Aivazovsky, and dozens, if not hundreds, of other artists, they managed to convince the world of this. That is, the works of these artists in museums in different countries, exhibition catalogs, all advertising, and all references to them revolved around their "Russianness." 

But recently there was a real breakthrough: The Metropolitan Museum of Art explicitly called Kuindzhi a Ukrainian, setting an important precedent for other cultural institutions around the world. A few days later, the museum made the same re-attribution for paintings by Ilya Repin and Ivan Aivazovsky from its own collection. This gave an unambiguous hint: now Ukrainian artists who were forced to create in the prison of nations, the Russian Empire, can and should be called Ukrainians.

Of course, the Metropolitan's experts did not change their mind about these artists out of the blue. This was preceded by a lot of hard work. Ukrainian journalist and art historian Oksana Semenyk writes about this change in her post, "I don't know what exactly they paid attention to: Twitter posts, tags, or letters with biographies and explanations, or constant discussions among colleagues and articulation of the problem…” That is, without the purposeful work of Ukrainians, nothing would have happened. 

And this applies not only to artists but also to individual works. The same museum renamed the painting "Russian Dancers" by the French artist Edgar Degas. The work was renamed to “Dancers in Ukrainian Dress.” And also after long reminders. Oksana Semenyk also sent the museum information about research that showed that it was a Ukrainian troupe. And after considering the arguments, the museum responded.

Let me remind you that a similar story took place in March 2022, when the National Gallery in London renamed Degas' painting "Russian Dancers" to "Ukrainian Dancers." At the time, Ukrainian artist Mariam Nayyem said that she had sent letters to the London gallery, as well as to the Getty Museum in Los Angeles and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, where Degas' paintings of dancers in Ukrainian national costumes were named "Russian Dancers." As you can see, constant dropping wears away at a stone. 

And this gives us all a real recipe for fighting on the artistic frontline to establish justice and recognition of Ukrainian culture in the world, as well as to counter Russian cultural disinformation. Identify works by Ukrainian artists on the websites of foreign museums that are labeled as Russian, tag these institutions on social media, and explain why they are Ukrainian. After all, as this story proves, such work really makes sense for the reconstruction of Ukrainian culture.




 
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Friday
26 April
11:42
Review
Changing approaches to EW system development over year. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
11:20
Russian army loses 950 soldiers, 7 tanks and 31 artillery systems per day of war in Ukraine
10:57
Ukraine’s journalist Alla Pushkarchuk killed in battles with Russia, she had been fighting since 2014
10:35
US preparing $6 billion in arms contracts for Ukraine. What they will include?
10:10
Russian army strikes shopping center, kindergarten, residential areas in Kherson region, injuring 6
09:51
Capture of Chasiv Yar will open up prospects for Russia's significant operational progress - ISW
09:30
Exclusive
Ukrainian border guards repel attack of Russian subversive group in Sumy region
2024, Thursday
25 April
21:50
Review
Victorious news of 792nd day of war: European Parliament calls not to recognize Putin's pseudo-election, while oil products continue to burn in Russia
21:30
Russia "pays" foreign workers by moving into renovated houses of Mariupol residents
21:10
Belarus' claim of foiled drone attack is disinformation — Lithuanian army
20:50
Ukraine's agriculture minister, suspected of state land grab, resigns
20:29
USD 1 billion aid package for Ukraine: number of Bradleys, other armored vehicles revealed
20:07
UK accused of 'helping Russia pay for its war against Ukraine' through oil imports
19:46
Exclusive
Artillery ammunition from US may arrive at frontline in few days - Ukrainian Armed Forces Colonel
19:25
Exclusive
Almost impossible to capture Chasiv Yar: Ukrainian officer on problems of Russian army in Bakhmut sector
19:07
Exclusive
Russia’s missile strikes on Ukraine indicate transition to “Aleppo” strategy – expert on international energy, security relations
18:46
Rescuers come under Russia’s repeated fire in Kherson suburbs
18:27
Belarusian leader Lukashenko calls "hot spot in Ukraine" main risk for Belarus
18:04
Russia attacks Kharkiv region: 7 people injured near Balakliya railway station
17:45
Lithuania can help Ukraine bring men of military age back — Defense Minister Kasčiūnas
17:23
Russian agents sentenced to 15 years in prison for guiding Russian missiles at Kherson hospital
17:04
OPINION
How to make West accept Ukraine into NATO without conditions?
16:40
"500,000 Ukrainians 'sentenced' by US Congress to death or injury": Highlights of April 25 disinformation
16:18
Ukraine can increase long-range strikes on Russian territory - British Armed Forces Commander Radakin
16:00
Ukrainian polar explorers show penguins nesting near Vernadsky Research Base
15:42
Review
Modernized Kh-101 missiles: why they are dangerous
15:18
Russian attack on any NATO country will lead to Kremlin's inevitable defeat - Polish Foreign Minister Sikorski 
14:58
Not only aircraft and pilots: Danish Ambassador on promised package of F-16s to be delivered to Ukraine in summer
14:34
Updated
Three tanks with fuel burn in Omsk, Russia
14:23
Arrest of Shoigu's deputy is most serious scandal in Russian Defense Ministry since 2012 - British intelligence
14:05
Exclusive
Russia has lost its calm in Crimea: military expert on Ukraine's ATACMS availability
13:42
OPINION
Will Poland block Ukraine's integration with EU?
13:25
EU prepares sanctions against ships carrying weapons from North Korea to Russia
13:04
Review
US could provide $1 billion monthly aid to Ukraine – military expert Serhiy Zgurets
12:45
Exclusive
Russian army is running out of ammunition near Chasiv Yar: Ukrainian serviceman
12:30
Russia produces more weapons than it needs for war in Ukraine - German Defense Minister
12:16
Exclusive
Russia attacks Cherkasy: 6 injured, critical infrastructure damaged
11:40
China has chosen side, can't claim neutrality in Russia-Ukraine war - US Ambassador to NATO
11:28
Exclusive
Russia groans about Ukrainian artillery: military comments on current situation in Krynky
11:06
Greatest art theft of Russia’s war against Ukraine: How the invaders plundered Kherson museum
More news