Espreso. Global
OPINION

Returning Crimea is much easier than returning Luhansk and Donetsk

13 May, 2023 Saturday
21:02

There are a lot of wrong illusions and fantasies on how we will return the peninsula annexed by Russia

client/title.list_title

Unfortunately, we pay too much attention to Crimea as part of the war. Yes, the return of Crimea is a symbolic defeat for Russia, more so than the return of Luhansk and Donetsk. And to some extent, I am even confused by this excessive interest in Crimea, and the almost complete lack of interest in the return of Luhansk and Donetsk. Sometimes I fear that in the perception of many Ukrainians, Luhansk and Donetsk are not Ukraine. And this is not the case.

At the same time, there are a lot of wrong illusions and fantasies about how we will return Crimea. Most people imagine our tanks breaking into the peninsula and fighting for Sevastopol. In my opinion, such a scenario would be a disaster in terms of our losses, and in fact, there is no need for it.

The main scenario for the return of Crimea is an operational encirclement. If our troops break through to the Sea of Azov and cut the corridor, we can destroy the Crimean bridge, and take control of the sea area with anti-ship missiles, then Crimea and the entire southern group of Russian troops will be in an operational encirclement. Under these conditions, Putin will have two options: either to use a tactical nuclear strike or to start negotiations on withdrawal from Crimea and southern Ukraine.

“The Russian forces conducted a simulation and saw that the consequences of using nuclear weapons would be catastrophic for them. First, they would lose the support of China, which would not be able to justify it and would not benefit from a nuclear escalation in a situation where it is losing in terms of arms. Secondly, it will remove any restrictions for the West”

A nuclear tactical strike is unlikely, although it still has a chance. I have written about this many times. The Russian forces conducted a simulation and saw that the consequences of using nuclear weapons would be catastrophic for them. First, they would lose the support of China, which would not be able to justify it and would not benefit from a nuclear escalation in a situation where it is losing in terms of arms. Secondly, it will remove any restrictions for the West. A small nuclear explosion would make the West a direct participant in the war. The Americans themselves have warned the Russians that they will respond to the use of nuclear weapons with a non-nuclear missile strike, for example, on the Russian Black Sea Fleet. That is, Putin will not gain anything from a nuclear strike, but will only lose even more. That leaves the second scenario, our favourite "goodwill gesture."

The Russians are also well aware of this, so believe me, they are preparing against this scenario. And even if we come to the shore of the Azov Sea, they are preparing to hold the line as long as possible. In any case, I am trying to convey to you the idea that in order to return Crimea, we do not need to break into the peninsula with tanks. In this regard, it even seems to me that it is much easier to return it than to return Luhansk and Donetsk.

Source

About the author. Victor Andrusiv, political and public figure, analyst and publicist

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs. 

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Wednesday
22 January
21:15
If borders were opened, 70% of Ukrainians would not move abroad, survey shows
21:00
Trump calls on Russia to make deal to end Ukraine war, warns of sanctions and tariffs
20:39
Exclusive
U.S. Presidential change – opportunity for Ukraine that must be seized, says MP Syniutka
20:18
Exclusive
Military expert explains why Russian forces succeed in encircling settlements
19:56
From defense to offense: key steps Ukraine must take to win war
19:37
From 5,700 to 1,110: Decline of Ukraine’s tank force from 1993 to 2013
19:15
Interview
Ukraine has every chance to become success story for EU if it pursues reforms, unlocks its potential — EU Commissioner Andrius Kubilius for Espreso
18:55
Ukrainian forces repel 41 Russian attacks in Pokrovsk sector
18:35
Russia shells Donetsk region 3,829 times over past day, causing multiple casualties
18:17
OPINION
Trump is back. His goal is 'golden age' for the USA, but where does Ukraine fit in it?
17:55
North Korea might send reinforcements to Kursk region, U.S. says
17:37
Russian army attacks Kostiantynivka with bombs, killing and injuring locals
17:16
OPINION
Kremlin's plan: war lasting lifetime of those who started it
16:55
EU Defense Commissioner Kubilius urges NATO to move military goals 14 years ahead due Russian threat
16:31
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 8-15
Russian forces may enter Ukraine's Dnipropetrovsk region as they advance toward Pokrovsk
16:10
Finnish 2S1 Gvozdika, also known as PSH 74, illustrative photo from open sources
Denmark supplies Ukraine with 2S1 Gvozdika self-propelled howitzer
15:49
'Reason behind North Korean troops' involvement': NATO Commander Cavoli assesses Russia's breakthrough potential
15:32
Syria terminates investment deal with Russia over Tartus port control
15:14
OPINION
Donald Trump's promise of strong U.S. leadership must begin with Ukraine
14:55
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, January 15-22
January 15-22 live war map: Russian forces launch assault on last stronghold in southern Donetsk region
14:43
Trump assigns envoy Kellogg to end war in Ukraine in 100 days — media
14:25
Exclusive
'Prepare for turbulence with mixed proposals': military expert Zgurets on Trump’s war settlement plan
14:06
Exclusive
Russia suffers heavy losses but fails to gain ground in Kupyansk sector — Achilles Battalion
13:50
Exclusive
Around 220 civilians refuse to evacuate Chasiv Yar despite ongoing fighting
13:32
OPINION
Trump's first statements and orders: what they reveal
13:14
Ukraine authorizes Poseidon unmanned aerial vehicle system for military use
12:57
Exclusive
Trump's 'hawks' must not repeat Obama's mistake — Ukrainian diplomat
12:38
Ukraine documents over 7,000 Russian environmental crimes amid ongoing war
12:21
OPINION
Trump: Putin is destroying Russia. Column by Vitaly Portnikov
12:00
Russia violates political prisoners' health rights in Crimea at least 64 times in 2024 — analysts
11:42
Ukrainian forces eliminate 21 North Korean fighters, wound 40 in Russia's Kursk region
11:23
121 combat clashes occur on Russian-Ukrainian front on Jan. 21 — General Staff
11:05
Ukraine will need at least 200,000 peacekeepers to ensure security after ceasefire - Zelenskyy
10:46
Exclusive
Trump has no reason to concede or compromise with Russia — international expert
10:28
Trump administration seeks lasting end to war in Ukraine — U.S. official
10:11
Exclusive
Putin appears to be 'CIA's best agent' — Ukrainian diplomat
09:52
Russia launches drone attack on Ukraine, causing casualties in Mykolaiv
09:34
Russia loses 1,950 soldiers, 60 artillery systems, 11 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Tuesday
21 January
21:30
Exclusive
Defense Express expert analyzes Russian military production rates amid war
21:10
4,000 North Korean soldiers killed in Kursk region — Zelenskyy
More news