Espreso. Global

Jenssen hints that allies foresee stalemate in war with Russia

18 August, 2023 Friday
11:16

The story about the words of the Director of the Private Office of NATO Secretary General Stian Jenssen made a splash. Literally, what he said sounds like giving up territories in exchange for NATO membership

client/title.list_title

Of course, the choice of words was bad and clumsy, which is why it was called a mistake yesterday. No one is going to change anything, neither politically nor legally. But there is no smoke without fire, and the very fact of the interview with the head of the office is something outside the rules for the Western world.

“These words indicate that Ukraine's allies allow for a "stalemate" on the battlefield, temporary or longer, and are therefore discussing what this will mean in terms of security models. Of course, we do not like such discussions emotionally, but we must respect our allies and understand their logic, because we have no other allies and we critically need them in the fight for Ukraine.”

The point of the discussion that is being made in some Western circles is something like this. If NATO at some point decides on Ukraine's membership in the Alliance, but at that moment all the territory of Ukraine is not yet liberated, what does this mean? Then NATO decides to extend Article 5 on collective defense to the territory Ukraine controls. At the same time, any further actions to liberate Ukrainian territories will mean that Russia will launch strikes on NATO territory. This raises the question of whether we have to coordinate actions to liberate the territories within NATO, and if so, whether this is a restriction of Ukraine's sovereignty over its territories.

This may sound like casuistry to many, but we have to be prepared for such discussions - not only emotionally, but also rationally. As the saying goes, "the devil is in the details." And no one will be able to "exchange" territories for NATO, Ukrainians will not accept and will not allow such barter.

 

Source

About the author. Pavlo Klimkin, diplomat, former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.


  • On 15 August, NATO Secretary General's Chief of Staff Stian Jenssen has suggested the possibility of Ukraine's territorial concessions to Russia in exchange for membership in the Alliance.
  • The NATO summit took place in Vilnius on July 11-12. The meetings were attended by leaders and government officials from various countries. Lithuania hosted the summit for the first time at the LITEXPO congress center. Security was ensured by thousands of military personnel, and the airspace was protected by air defense systems.
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Saturday
16 November
19:53
Exclusive
Trump won't talk about Ukraine's very sensitive issues in public - politician
19:31
Ukrainian forces destroy Russian command post in Kherson region
19:10
Exclusive
Developing nuclear weapons within two months is realistic - Ukrainian major
18:48
British company BAE Systems to open new plant to produce howitzers for Ukraine
18:29
75 clashes occur on Russian-Ukrainian front, Russia bombs Kursk region - Ukraine's General Staff
18:06
OPINION
Trump as Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, and Intelligence Chief
17:44
Updated
Japan to assist Ukraine in countering Russia-North Korea collaboration
17:25
Exclusive
Hard times ahead: British colonel on Trump administration's potential isolationist policy
17:03
OPINION
Riots in Abkhazia: what does this mean for Ukraine?
16:42
Ukraine develops, tests four new missile types - President Zelenskyy
16:26
Russia kills 5 civilians, injures 7 more in three Ukrainian regions overnight
16:07
Estonia eyes Ukrainian weapons despite export ban, explores joint ventures
15:48
OPINION
Russian dilemma: defeat Putin or face collapse?
15:25
Ukraine ramps up missile development, production amid war with Russia
15:06
Russian gas transit via Ukraine faces shutdown amid political standoff
14:50
Exclusive
Ukraine's surrender will have catastrophic consequences: politician on Russia’s next war front
14:27
Review
Russia aims to reach Kurakhove-Zaporizhzhia route, pressures Pokrovsk: threat to Ukraine. Serhiy Zgurets' column
14:08
War should end in 2025 through diplomatic means, says Zelenskyy
13:49
Estonia to provide new aid package to Ukraine: what it includes
13:31
Returning to Normandy format is unacceptable: Boris Johnson on Scholz-Putin talks
13:14
Russia attempts to solve shortage of junior officers - Ukrainian intelligence
12:55
'Nothing to discuss from weak position': Zelenskyy names conditions for Ukraine-Russia talks
12:33
170 clashes occur at front on Nov. 15: Russian army active in Pokrovsk, Kurakhove sectors - Ukraine's General Staff
12:10
Exclusive
Russia considers Crimea's liberation: Ukraine's Navy on Russian readiness to defend peninsula
11:49
Russian forces seize Ukraine's Maksymivka, Donetsk region - DeepState
11:32
Exclusive
Russian forces push across fronts, betting on victory before collapse - Aidar Battalion former commander
11:11
UN: almost 40% of Ukraine's population needs humanitarian aid
10:53
Russia loses 1,600 soldiers, 28 artillery systems, 8 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
10:34
Russian shelling damages high-voltage line at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant
2024, Friday
15 November
21:20
Borrell informs EU countries of China's first weapon transfer to Russia – media
20:52
Ukrainian president Zelenskyy reacts to Scholz's call to Putin
20:30
Around 30% of Mariupol residents return to occupied territories - Ukrainian official
20:11
Ghost-X
Ukraine's army secretly using American Ghost-X drones with AI since 2022
19:50
Trump's idiocracy: we have already seen example of broken system
19:35
Spec-ops troops rescue 16 Ukrainian soldiers from encirclement in Kursk region
19:20
Russian Kalibr missiles less effective, but still a threat - Ukrainian Navy
18:59
Exclusive
South Korea’s military support for Ukraine tied to Trump’s defense policy - Defense Express
18:52
Updated
Putin, Scholz hold first talks in two years. Germany urges troops withdrawal from Ukraine
18:40
Ukraine's strategic Odesa left vulnerable amid missed defense opportunities - expert
18:20
G7+ countries acknowledge Ukraine’s advancements in energy reforms
More news