Espreso. Global

Air defense will not make 200,000 Russian troops withdraw from Ukraine

23 September, 2023 Saturday

Washington still cannot decide if it really wants Ukraine to win, while for Ukraine, ‘defending’ means losing

General George S. Patton said: “Nobody ever defended anything successfully. There is only attack and attack and attack some more.” 

In Ukraine, at a minimum, that equates to ATACMS, F-16 fighter jets and HIMARS-delivered cluster munitions. It means M26 dual-purpose improved conventional munitions rockets supporting a push by Ukraine south toward the Sea of Azov and the Crimean Peninsula. 

That is what US retired intelligence officer Jonathan Sweet and economist Mark Toth write in their opinion piece for the Hill

During the 15th Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting held at Ramstein air base in Germany on September 19, US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin called upon allies to provide Ukraine with “additional air defense systems and interceptors” — specifically, Patriot, IRIS-T, HAWK, NASAMS, SAMP/T, and other air-defense systems. 

He opened the meeting by stating, “Air defense is saving lives. So, I urge this group to continue to dig deep on ground-based air defense for Ukraine.” He also emphasized the necessity for air defense to “protect Ukraine’s critical infrastructure, including grain and energy supplies.”   

While that is all true, no amount of air defense is going to kick the 200,000 troops out from occupied Ukraine. That will only be accomplished through offense.

“Air defense weapons will not destroy or damage the Kerch Strait Bridge or any other bridge sustaining Russian forces on the Crimean Peninsula from Russia or Russian occupied southern Ukraine by ground transport or rail. Nor will they affect the sea ports and airfields. Nor, significantly, can they affect Russia’s third defensive line near the village of Robotyne in the Zaporizhzhia region. Russia’s ability to wage war will continue, unabated.”

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley referenced a “very high bar,” when warning that a Ukrainian victory will take a “very long time.” It is a sad irony that the Biden Administration has made that bar higher by failing to greenlight the weapons Ukraine needs for a decisive victory, the authors of the article say.

It has been nearly two weeks since ABC News suggested that the Biden Administration was considering supplying Ukraine with the Army Tactical Missile Systems, or ATACMS. President Joe Biden, in his Tuesday address to the United Nations General Assembly, despite Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in attendance, made no reference to ATACMS. Instead, Biden reiterated his call to world leaders to stand firm against “naked aggression,” and once again “cast solidarity with Ukraine in its war with Russia as a necessary step to deter other would-be aggressors.”

Interdicting drones, ballistic missiles, and hypersonic missiles over the skies of Ukraine will not win the war. Austin and Milley know this. It is merely an extension of the attrition-based battle being waged on the ground, in the trenches — substituting soldiers for missiles, at an unsustainable cost.

“What wins the war is to strike the launch sites beyond Ukraine’s borders; to destroy weapons systems that launch the drones and fire the missiles; to interdict munitions before they are fired; to destroy “third line” defensive fortifications before the lead elements of the assault force arrive.”

The deep fight and interdiction of supply lines are what Ukraine so desperately needs to win this war, the authors conclude.

Read also:
  • News
2023, Monday
4 December
Victorious news of 649th day of war: Ukraine develops its own long-range weapons, German plant to produce €142 million worth of shells for Ukrainian army
Increased winter aid, Ukraine's accession to NATO: Umerov meets with Stoltenberg
Ukrainian Armed Forces repel 15 Russian attacks in Avdiivka sector - General Staff
Defence Express shares what capabilities new missile for Neptune complex will have
What has happened to Ukrainian defense industry since 2014?
Russia builds new military hospital in Crimea - National Resistance
Russia reduces number of assaults with support of armoured vehicles in Bakhmut sector due to  weather
Ukraine receives scarce missiles for air defence, new anti-aircraft systems - Zelenskyy
Russia tries to be more sophisticated: Ukrainian intelligence on IPSO by Russian special services
50 trucks processed in 12 hours at one of Ukraine-Poland checkpoints
Russia wants to show Ukraine as autocracy
Underground kindergarten equipped in subway to be opened in Kharkiv
Blockade of border with Ukraine: cargo traffic decreases tenfold
Hungarian FM Szijjártó confirms that Poroshenko initiated meeting with Orbán
Russia shells kindergarten in Kherson, houses in region, killing civilians
"Even Moscow doesn't know exact number": UK intelligence estimates Russian losses since beginning of war
Ukraine’s Neptune missile
Ukraine modifies missile for Neptune complex
Ukraine needs up to $400 billion to liberate entire territory, General Staff believes
Is West cutting aid to force Ukraine to negotiate?
Historians criticize Polish prosecutor's decision to label Operation Vistula as humane
"This airfield is of greatest interest to Russia among all others": Ihnat on Russian attacks on Starokostyantyniv
"From warehouses to training grounds in trailers": In Mariupol Russia transports ammunition in civilian cars 
Russia will worsen situation for itself: military observer on Putin's decree to expand Russian army
Why are elections in Russia important to Ukraine?
White House: US may run out of money for Ukraine if Congress doesn't act by end of year
Ukrainian infantrymen, supported by tanks, destroy Russian positions. Video.
It's time for Biden to give up election and focus on war in Ukraine and Israel — Piontkovsky
Global arms demand grows, SIPRI reports: are manufacturers ready?
Xi Jinping, Lukashenko meet in Beijing: what they discussed
Defense Ministry finally returns to Ukrainian air defense system development - military expert Zgurets
Russia targets apartment building, hospitals in Kherson: number of victims increased
Bulgarian President vetoes deal with Ukraine to supply armored vehicles
Russia claims UAV attack on oil depot in Luhansk: fire broke out
Map of fighting near Bakhmut
Bakhmut sector: Situation is dynamic, Russian troops receive reinforcements
Orban is playing on both Russia's and EU's side — expert on Ukrainian-Hungarian relations
Ukrainian Air Force shoots down Russian guided missile, 18 out of 23 Shaheds
Uhryniv-Dołhobyczów checkpoint on Ukrainian-Polish border opens for empty trucks
Russian army loses 5 tanks, 12 artillery systems and 770 soldiers per day - General Staff
Russia to spend over $100 billion from new budget on war against Ukraine — economist Neskhodovskyi
In Moscow, production plant for specialized vehicles is on fire
More news