Espreso. Global
OPINION

Why shouldn't Ukraine apologize for shield on gates of Tsargrad to join EU?

2 September, 2024 Monday
19:40

Liberal Tusk says Ukraine will not become an EU member without resolving Volyn issue

client/title.list_title

That's been said before! (с)

Seven years ago, the nationalist minister Waszczykowski declared: "Ukraine will not enter Europe with Bandera.”

However, after that, the whole of Ukraine sang "Our Father Bandera," and after the invasion, they even placed him somewhere near Shevchenko.

"In Ukraine, there is a very big temptation to explain such unconstructive statements by Polish politicians by their internal competition. This is partly true, but as we can see from the two statements of the two opponents, this is a consensus decision of the Polish elite.”

It's just that some people know how to say it delicately, and some people say it in the Moscow style.

But what is the basis of this ideological consensus?

The foundation is the demand of Polish society. Its deep involvement in historical issues.

I have never seen such an abundance of historical pop in bookstores as in Poland in any European country.

This time I bought two Newsweek and Historia, and that was only because I didn't have the money for more.

My eyes were running wild there.

Now I regret that I did not take the issue about the history of the Polish church.

But Poles buy it. And they do not hesitate to spend money.

Last time I brought Powrót and Niepokorny narod.

I didn't have to look for such specialized historical literature in bookstores.

It's sold right next to the Mariacki Market.

How Poles invest in foreign authors to make them interested in their history is a separate conversation.

Probably the classic case of such competent self-promotion is Norman Davies's A History of Europe.

Do you remember this rough and easily accessible book that could kill you?

When I read it as a student, I was surprised by the excessive emphasis on Polish episodes.

And now, when I pick up Polish school history textbooks, I am sincerely happy for Polish children - how cool and interesting they are.

I read them myself as an exciting adventure.

And I also feel sorry for Ukrainian children, who have not yet been cursed with the "Sarbeyevshchyna" curse.

"I understand why our school children hate history. This will probably continue until those who studied under Sarbey die."

Once I picked up tests for the External Independent Testing in history. I had only one question.

For what?

For what does a child need to know how some prick looked like in a portrait from the nineteenth century?

And when?

When were the authors of these tests born? In 1922, like Sarbey?

I remember when I was a freshman, Professor Chornyi said: "Forget these thousands of dates you learned for the entrance exam, even we don't know them."

I had to memorize three thousand dates to become a prize-winner at the All-Ukrainian History Olympiad.

And another language.

What was the point of all this?

Even then, we were not shoved portraits from the nineteenth century under our noses.

Why torture children?

At the beginning of the invasion, there was an explosion of interest in history in Ukraine.

The same public demand that has kept Poles so busy appeared.

And at this stage, the government had to get involved.

Grants for YouTube channels, government orders for TV channels, co-productions with Discovery, History, or Viasat.

Finally, joint media projects with Poles and Lithuanians-with those with whom we lived in the same state.

(Through such projects, we would also learn how to cut down sharp corners and polish mutual claims, and over time, such platforms would have a tremendous effect - for the new elites).

I'm not talking about mass publication (and translation) of young and creative historians who can not only find but also write well.

Because nowadays all scientific work is not worth a dime if it does not have a media wrapper.

“Yes, back in 2022, we had to create an entire industry from scratch. Along with the production of drones and missiles. The historical pop industry.”

Local History and the Kapranov brothers' channel alone will not make a difference.

But today the state is run by intellectual and managerial ineptitude.

They failed to maintain that fire of interest for 22 years, and it is slowly fading away.

“And, therefore, those for whom it is at the heart of the nation will dictate their terms to us. Those who have a political and social understanding of its importance. Those who, by investing in the past, project the future. These are Bandera and Volyn today.”

But why shouldn't we also apologize for the shield on the gates of Tsargrad in order to join the EU?

How would the ancient Greek say "what's the difference"?

* Published with preservation of the author's style

Source 

About the author: Oleh Manchura, journalist.

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Monday
17 February
12:16
Firefighting at Chornobyl NPP after Russian drone strike halted
11:58
Canada to send more F-16 flight simulators to Ukraine
11:44
Exclusive
Russian forces intensify infantry push in Ukraine’s Chasiv Yar - Ukraine’s 24th Brigade
11:15
OPINION
European leaders stunned: Macron calls emergency summit in Paris
10:56
Russia claims drone attack on Ilsky Oil Refinery
10:39
UK ready to send peacekeepers to Ukraine — UK PM
10:18
Trump says he may meet Putin "very soon" to discuss Ukraine-Russia ceasefire
09:57
Russia launches drone attacks on Ukraine, injuring civilians in Kharkiv, Kyiv regions
09:35
Russia loses 1,530 soldiers and dozens of military vehicles in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Sunday
16 February
21:14
OPINION
Why Lend-Lease is a quintessential Trump issue
20:51
White House sends questionnaire to Europe on Ukraine’s security in case of ceasefire
20:33
How Ukrainian soldiers use Soviet Grad MLRS to defend Chasiv Yar
20:13
Russian forces start demolishing Mariupol's historic center
20:00
Exclusive
Russian propagandists launch new fake claim about student mobilization in Ukraine
19:49
Exclusive
What are the key factors behind Ukraine’s recent Pokrovsk front success?
19:28
Finnish President Stubb outlines three stages for peace in Ukraine
19:14
Investigation reveals Google’s collaboration with autocratic regimes, including the Kremlin
18:49
Ukrainian government delegation arrives in Saudi Arabia to prepare for Zelenskyy's visit
18:30
Interview
Trump's Resource Agreement acknowledges independent Ukraine as a U.S. interest – expert Fried
18:17
No Ukraine-Russia meetings until war-end plan is developed — Zelenskyy's aide
17:45
Russian forces lose rare Tosochka flamethrower for first time in combat
17:20
Russian Foreign Intelligence accuses Ukraine of preparing Baltic Sea terror attack
16:55
Exclusive
Vance's statements fully endorsed by White House, expert says
16:27
Review
Completing the Khmelnytskyi NPP: Why Bulgaria ditched "nuclear samovars" and does Ukraine really need more reactors
15:54
Missiles, bombs, drones: Russia launched over 2,100 aerial attacks on Ukraine in a week
15:20
Ukrainian forces liberate Pishchane village south of Pokrovsk
14:56
Russian forces cross Oskil river to establish new offensive foothold in Kharkiv region
14:35
Russia sets up secret sabotage unit targeting Europe and beyond
13:57
Exclusive
Facebook group in Australia unites thousands of diaspora members to help Ukraine
13:30
IAEA inspects Chornobyl NPP shelter damaged by Russian drone, reports ongoing fire
12:55
Exclusive
Putin's war plans linked to two key factors – journalist Portnikov
12:28
261 battles occur on Russian-Ukrainian front, 71 in Pokrovsk direction – Ukraine's General Staff
11:56
Exclusive
Risky if Trump and Putin’s teams align — journalist Portnikov on Kellogg’s 180-day war end plan
11:28
U.S. pushes for greater control over Ukrainian minerals, including rare earths – media
10:52
Russia loses 5 tanks, 11 artillery systems, 1,730 soldiers in one day of war against Ukraine
10:35
Russian soldiers deliberately damage weapons to sabotage operations near Pokrovsk – guerrillas
2025, Saturday
15 February
19:45
U.S. to mediate Ukraine-Russia talks, no direct role for Europe — Kellogg
19:23
Russia ramps up attacks on Ukraine to boost leverage as Munich Conference unfolds
19:00
Exclusive
U.S. lacks capacity to counter Russia, China — diplomat
18:37
Exclusive
Fixing frontline doesn’t mean renouncing Ukraine’s 1991 borders — diplomat Fried
More news