Espreso. Global
OPINION

"Kara-Murzas" to replace "Navalnys". Why is Russian opposition Ukraine's enemy? 

8 August, 2024 Thursday
16:42

... And the world saw new stars of the Russian opposition - Vladimir Kara-Murza, Andrei Pivovarov and Ilya Yashin

client/title.list_title

Well, maybe not stars necessarily - at home in Russia their influence is minimal. However, Western elites are clinging to the illusion of democracy in Russia—a narrative they have constructed themselves.

Speaking about the high-profile prisoner exchange between the United States and Russia, the most valuable character for Joe Biden was journalist Evan Gershkovich. 

This child of Soviet Jews who migrated to the United States was put behind bars for nothing. Interestingly, in his pardon letter, he requested an interview with Putin and the Wall Street Journal.

For Putin, the exchange was highly advantageous—indeed, "incredible." The Kremlin's killers and spies were returned to Russia, while Western liberals, who have begun to defend the "great country," were sent to the West.

According to German journalists I know, many people listened to the request to lift sanctions against the Russians here and now, because they are innocent. And many wondered whether it was worth handing over the killer Vadim Krasikov, who shot Zelimkhan Khangoshvili, the hero of the national liberation movement of Ichkeria, in front of Berlin schoolchildren. 

For his first interview, Ilya Yashin—whom I previously knew not for his opposition activities but for his past relationship with Putin's goddaughter Ksenia Sobchak—brought a significant message. He spoke about the hardships faced by sociable FSB special forces operatives, lamenting their difficult "business trips" to Zaporizhzhia and Kharkiv. Yashin noted with a sense of regret that the situation had reached a dead end. Perhaps, if his new friends had managed to capture Kharkiv, the beleaguered oppositionist might have been more content.

Well, we must finally draw conclusions. We should never invite such clowns to Kyiv and treat them to local delicacies. No matter how generously you treat them, they will continue to search for Nazis and SS flags in Kyiv's Podil district.

Another pocket oppositionist, Andrei Pivovarov, went on a big interview with Current Time TV and immediately showed the nature of a typical Putin larva.

Khodorkovsky's associate said that it was unacceptable for an oppositionist from Russia to support not only the Ukrainian Armed Forces, but also those Russian volunteers fighting on the side of Ukraine.

"And maybe these people are not supporters of democratic ideals, but it is unacceptable for me to wish them (the occupiers - author) to die, to help that spread. But I'm not ready to support those people who are fighting against Russia with weapons in their hands," said the "good Russian" Pivovarov. 

The pocket oppositionist also considers it unacceptable when Russians abandon the tricolor, which has become a symbol of Russian aggression. 

"The tricolor is our flag and we cannot give it away. You cannot give it up," the Putin oppositionist said.

What is the moral of these confessions that Russia is hopelessly sick and that the West still has a firm grip on Solzhenitsyn, Steinbeck, and Marvel movies that portray Russians as superheroes, hardworking bees, and sexy spies with the body of Scarlett Johansson? 

This has already happened. And Dmytro Dontsov wrote about it well in his collection Moscow Poison. 

"Every time," Dontsov writes in his article "The Russian Predator - Yesterday and Today," "when Russia faces a new political upheaval, a changing of the guard, a change in its leadership, there is a frenzied advertising of the 'new Russia' around the world... It is worth emphasizing the boundless naiveté of those foreigners and some Ukrainians who still believe in some third, fourth, or tenth Russia, which will surely be free and give freedom to others. Russia does not change, it has been the same for 350 years and it is the same today. Our task is not to fight this or that regime in the USSR, but to fight Russia as such, and its barbaric and violent spirit..."

It is to be expected that the Western media will continue to drag out the effigies of the Russian opposition for the next six months. They will even occasionally suggest that Ukrainian human rights activists and journalists seek reconciliation dialogue on public panels. 

But it's worth remembering once and for all. All these gatherings were possible before 2014. Then they all felt comfortable when Russia was tearing Crimea apart. And when it went to invade the Ukrainian city of Donetsk with tanks. 

They, these public Russians, had already run around Kyiv during the two previous Maidans. They were expressing their views on whose Crimea was and how to move forward with relations with Russia. We remember Sobchak with Krasovsky, who was proposing to strangle Ukrainian children, hugging Yevhen Karas and becoming friends. 

Therefore, the task of every visionary in Ukraine is to convey the idea to Western elites that there is no point in keeping Lenin's corpse in a refrigerator in the hope that it can be revived. 

The Russian mantra that we have the largest territory, and therefore we should be the ones to manage security in Eastern Europe, must be shattered by attempts to increase these territories by genociding the neighbors. 

And finally, since our thinkers and philosophers once gave birth to this monster, gave it shape and color, we have to kill it. Because this project has exhausted itself, and Ukrainians should no longer work for this killing machine. The biggest mistake of the seventeenth century must be corrected so that we have a chance to move forward.

Exclusively for Espreso

About the author: Maryna Danyliuk-Yarmolaieva, journalist

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Wednesday
19 February
20:53
OPINION
Zelenskyy fires back at Trump’s remarks with strong response
20:38
Trump calls Zelenskyy “modestly successful comedian”, “dictator without elections”
20:25
Threat from Belarus: how fast can Russia build a strike force?
20:10
Ukrainian soldier does more for U.S. and European security than all NATO armies
19:54
Exclusive
Trump’s stance raises questions about air defense missile supplies – Defense Express
19:38
Putin lies about Russian troops crossing into Ukraine from Kursk region
19:22
What Russia may get from North Korea in March: Shells, ballistic missiles,KN-25 MLRS
19:06
Ukrainian defense industry covers 30% of military needs — Zelenskyy
18:50
Putin's reelection was illegitimate - Ukraine's disinformation center
18:35
Elections during wartime are Russia’s try to defeat Ukraine – Zurabishvili
18:20
"Ukraine doesn’t want peace": Russia’s latest fake narrative led by Putin’s ally
18:04
Exclusive
Ukraine’s battlefield success may turn peace talks upside down — military analyst
17:55
Updated
U.S. envoy Keith Kellogg arrives in Kyiv, holds high-level talks
17:47
North Korean troops in Kursk region told they’re fighting South Korean soldiers
17:31
Trucks and thermal imagers: Ukraine receives new military aid package from Lithuania
17:14
OPINION
Ukraine between predators: How to counter Putin and Trump
16:52
Ukraine’s former top general names key factors for Ukraine’s victory over Russia
16:43
Updated
EU approves 16th sanctions package against Russia
16:32
UK’s “air policing” proposal to Ukraine: Will it make a difference?
16:14
"War cost us $320 billion": Zelenskyy responds to Trump’s aid reimbursement demands
16:07
Ukrainian President names countries opposing Ukraine’s NATO membership
15:54
Exclusive
Russia may test NATO's Article 5 response with localized war in Estonia — Ukrainian officer
15:36
OPINION
U.S.-Russia talks in Riyadh: key takeaways
15:24
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 12-19
February 12-19 live war map: new encirclement in Kurakhove sector
15:12
Belarus sells rapeseed oil from Ukraine's occupied Kherson region to EU – investigation
14:53
Ukrainian paratroopers repel Russian assault in Kharkiv region: video
14:36
Zelenskyy: If Ukraine joins EU and NATO tomorrow, I will no longer be needed
14:28
Trump claims Zelenskyy's approval rating in Ukraine dropped to 4%, Zelenskyy responds
14:15
Exclusive
New Ukraine-EU defense alliance signals revival of Europe's defense industry — military expert
13:54
Ukraine’s Air Force confirms precision strike on Russian troop dislocation in Zaporizhzhia region
13:32
Elections in Ukraine immediately after ceasefire are unrealistic – Ukrainian MP
12:56
Affiliate Material
I wasn't afraid of causing pain — it helped the wounded: combat medic Lidiia Zabolotska's story
12:35
Russia in Riyadh lies about not targeting Ukraine’s energy sector as it strikes Odesa – Zelenskyy
12:13
OPINION
Ukraine expects unity from Europeans, Europeans expect unity from Ukraine
11:57
Zelenskyy delays Saudi Arabia visit to avoid legitimizing U.S.-Russia talks
11:36
Review
Kurakhove pocket: Ukrainian Armed Forces hold ground under extreme conditions. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:10
UK may supply Ukraine with Typhoon fighter jets if ceasefire is reached
10:36
Russia remains unwilling to negotiate on Ukraine following talks in Saudi Arabia — ISW
10:15
Russian drone attack causes power, water, and heating outages in Odesa, leaves 4 injured
09:54
Russia’s Syzran oil refinery on fire after drone strike
More news