Espreso. Global
OPINION

Ukraine's historic victory in Strasbourg

26 June, 2024 Wednesday
16:23

The European Court of Human Rights' judgment in the case against Russia over Crimea, published on June 25, is undoubtedly a historic victory

client/title.list_title

The Court satisfied most of Ukraine's demands, recognizing not just human rights violations, but a systematic practice of such violations by the aggressor. These violations continued from February 2014 until at least September 2022, when the Court terminated its jurisdiction over Russia.

"The European Court confirmed that Russia violated the right to life in Crimea due to enforced disappearances and the lack of effective investigations. It highlighted the cruel treatment of Ukrainian servicemen, ethnic Ukrainians, and Crimean Tatars, as well as journalists."

The Court also found violations of the right to freedom due to the incommunicado detention of Ukrainian military personnel, ethnic Ukrainians, Crimean Tatars, and journalists. Additionally, it recognized the violation of the right to privacy caused by arbitrary raids and searches in private residences.

The European Court found that freedom of conscience was violated through the persecution and intimidation of religious leaders "who do not profess the Russian Orthodox faith," (including Ukrainian Orthodox priests and imams). Arbitrary raids on places of worship and confiscation of religious property were noted, alongside violations of freedom of speech through the suppression of "non-Russian mass media," including the closure of Ukrainian and Crimean Tatar TV stations.

The court ruled that freedom of assembly was violated by the administrative practice of "banning public assemblies and demonstrations supporting Ukraine or the Crimean Tatar community." This included intimidation and arbitrary detention of demonstration organizers. Additionally, the court identified violations of the right to property due to the expropriation of civilians' and private enterprises' property without compensation. It also found violations of the right to education due to the suppression of the Ukrainian language in schools and the persecution of Ukrainian-speaking children.

"The court determined that the so-called "courts" of the occupiers in Crimea cannot be considered "established by law" under the European Convention, highlighting their lack of legitimacy. It also stated that the right to privacy was violated due to the lack of an effective system for renouncing "Russian citizenship.""

Another thing, and this is extremely important, the European Court ruled that Russia violated the prohibition of discrimination against the Crimean Tatars, thereby significantly correcting the January decision of the UN International Court of Justice, which had a strong impact, especially on the Crimean Tatar community.

Why is there such a fundamental difference between the decisions of Strasbourg and The Hague? It's not about the judges or "bad international law," but about personnel issues and the stability of state structures.

"Since 2014-2015, the team of specialists at the Ministry of Justice has only grown, working in the state interests of Ukraine, rather than focusing on profits for "foreign legal advisers.""

I remember very well the tension when we decided to create a separate division in the Ministry of Justice to handle interstate complaints in 2015.

Congratulations to all involved.

To those trying to discredit Ukraine in this case, I have one thing to say: for you, this is just the beginning.

Source

About the author. Borys Babin, Ukrainian scientist, public and political figure, doctor of legal sciences, professor.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Monday
17 February
21:05
Exclusive
It will take 2 years to restore Zaporizhzhia NPP after it is returned to Ukrainian control
20:43
Germany sends more military aid to Ukraine, including Gepard SAMs, Leopard tank ammunition
20:20
Exclusive
Some Kremlin proposals in exchange for Ukraine's capitulation may interest Trump – Professor Eisenberg
20:02
Exclusive
Can European countries buy U.S. weapons for Ukraine? Defense Express explains
19:43
First NATO-Ukraine center opens in Polish city of Bydgoszcz
19:27
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
Russia launches major armored assaults near Velyka Novosilka, southern Donetsk region
19:10
Ukraine seeks to sign U.S. agreement on rare earth resources with security guarantees
18:54
Ukraine and UAE sign economic partnership agreement, including free trade zone
18:38
Russia attacks rescuers delivering water in Donetsk region
18:22
Poland will not send its soldiers to Ukraine, but will support other states – Tusk
18:05
Ukrainian Human Rights Commissioner reacts to viral video of Ukrainian POWs execution
17:49
Zelenskyy: Ukraine progressing in potentially hosting European forces
17:31
"I want to take him to frontlines": Zelenskyy announces visit of Trump's special representative Kellogg
17:14
Stop Orban or reform European Union
16:52
Ukraine unaware of U.S.-Russia talks in Saudi Arabia, will not recognize them
16:36
Moldova says two Russian drones violated its airspace
16:18
Russia to produce 75,000 guided bombs in 2025, posing challenges for Ukraine's defenders
15:53
France’s Foreign Minister Barrot: Russia’s return to G7 is unimaginable now
15:32
Zelenskyy, UAE President discuss prisoner exchange, economic cooperation
15:13
Russia's record use of FPV drones: February 2025 projections
14:50
Exclusive
Arch over Chornobyl NPP pushed onto shelter, no roof material decay – expert
14:32
Fire destroys two Russian Zhitel EW systems set for deployment in Ukraine war
14:15
OPINION
Munich (in)security conference: New challenges and shifts in global politics
13:56
What are Ukrainian F-16s using to bomb Russian targets?
13:45
Updated
Firefighting at Chornobyl NPP after Russian drone strike resumes
13:39
U.S. suggests including Brazilian, Chinese troops in post-war Ukraine peacekeeping force
13:18
Exclusive
Russia's economic growth claims are inflation manipulation, says analyst
12:57
Exclusive
Russian forces escalate attacks across entire frontline amid Munich Security Conference — military expert
12:43
Sweden considers sending peacekeeping troops to Ukraine
11:58
Canada to send more F-16 flight simulators to Ukraine
11:44
Exclusive
Russian forces intensify infantry push in Ukraine’s Chasiv Yar - Ukraine’s 24th Brigade
11:15
OPINION
European leaders stunned: Macron calls emergency summit in Paris
10:56
Russia claims drone attack on Ilsky Oil Refinery
10:39
UK ready to send peacekeepers to Ukraine — UK PM
10:18
Trump says he may meet Putin "very soon" to discuss Ukraine-Russia ceasefire
09:57
Russia launches drone attacks on Ukraine, injuring civilians in Kharkiv, Kyiv regions
09:35
Russia loses 1,530 soldiers and dozens of military vehicles in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Sunday
16 February
21:14
OPINION
Why Lend-Lease is a quintessential Trump issue
20:51
White House sends questionnaire to Europe on Ukraine’s security in case of ceasefire
20:33
How Ukrainian soldiers use Soviet Grad MLRS to defend Chasiv Yar
More news