Espreso. Global

Repeats Stalin's actions: ISW analyzes Putin's military personnel policy since full-scale war start 

1 May, 2023 Monday
11:26

Russian dictator Vladimir Putin, with the help of constant rotation in the military leadership of the Russian Federation, tries to shift the responsibility for failures in Ukraine to the generals

client/title.list_title

This is stated in a special report by the Institute for the Study of War, which details changes in the Russian military command after Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

American analysts note that Russian President Vladimir Putin's decision to invade Ukraine without a clear and doctrinal command structure and his reluctance to appoint an overall theater commander had a lasting impact on the Russian command structure in Ukraine.

"Putin’s regular command changes have led to an increasingly factionalized Russian military and disorganized command structures that are degrading the Russian military’s ability to conduct a cohesive campaign in Ukraine," ISW wrote.

The analysts added that the Russian Defense Ministry and the Kremlin have been deliberately vague about most of these command changes.

Experts emphasized that Putin's reluctance to appoint a general commander for the invasion of Ukraine had a cascading effect on the Russian army. In April 2022, Western officials reported that Russia had not had a single commander of its forces in Ukraine since the invasion began on February 24, 2022.

"Putin likely sought to present himself as the commander-in-chief and the mastermind of the successful invasion of Ukraine. Captured Russian military plans revealed that the Kremlin expected Russian forces to capture Kyiv in mere days, and Putin had likely wanted to declare this speedy invasion a personal geopolitical victory," ISW suggested.

They also found commonalities in the behavior of Vladimir Putin and Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin.

"Putin may have been reluctant to appoint a commander for this invasion to avoid crediting a military commander with the military victory in Ukraine – a dynamic similar to the one between Soviet leader Joseph Stalin and Marshal of the Soviet Union Georgy Zhukov during World War II. Stalin had limited and outdated wartime experience and was reportedly jealous of Zhukov’s military exploits and fame," ISW said. 

After analyzing the reshuffles in the Russian army during the full-scale war, the Institute for the Study of War stated that the Kremlin and the Russian Ministry of Defense tried to use command changes to obtain the desired informational effect to compensate for the failures in Ukraine.

"Putin and the MoD have either obscured or carefully announced command changes throughout the war in Ukraine to shield themselves from criticism, set up scapegoats for military failures. Putin’s affinity for rotating personnel and not outright dismissing commanders is emblematic of his style of domestic rule, a style of leadership not well suited for leading a military engaged in a costly war," ISW emphasized.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Wednesday
25 December
20:15
Japan to transfer $3 billion to Ukraine from frozen Russian assets
19:58
Azerbaijani plane crash may become problem for Putin – analyst
19:45
Russia seizes Novoolenivka, Storozheve in Donetsk region - DeepState
19:30
Exclusive
Expert explains U.S. aid options for Ukraine before Trump's inauguration
19:18
Russia behind downing of Azerbaijani plane that crashed in Kazakhstan - expert
18:57
Russian army launches 35 attacks on Ukrainian positions in Pokrovsk sector
18:39
Ukrainian forces strike command post of Russia's 810th Brigade in Kursk region
18:22
7,500 people remain in Ukraine's frontline city of Pokrovsk, as Russian forces advance
18:01
OPINION
We have no history of independent living to draw from
17:40
Ukrainian poet Oleksii Bezpaltsev killed in combat
17:22
Ukraine loses some positions near Kurakhove, says military command
17:04
Exclusive
Kherson faces risk as Russia aims for foothold on Dnipro's islands
16:45
Indian filmmaker Payal Kapadia donates award prize money to Ukraine's humanitarian cause
16:27
Ukraine receives €150 million from EU for school meals and infrastructure recovery
16:09
In Christmas message, Pope calls for Ukraine-Russia talks
15:49
Ukrainian drones attack ammunition depot in Rostov region - media
15:33
How Ukraine repelled Russia’s Christmas Day attack with over 170 missiles, drones
15:17
"Shchedryk" echoes across 17 countries: Vera Farmiga, Barbra Streisand spotlight Ukrainian heritage
14:55
Ukraine downs 59 missiles, 54 drones in Russian attack on Christmas
14:34
Massive missile attack is Putin's answer to illusory "Christmas truce" talks – Ukraine's FM
14:15
Russians in occupied Ukraine target Christmas celebrations, Ukrainians tracked by FSB as saboteurs
13:53
Ukraine approves unmanned aircraft system Shchedryk for use in army
13:37
Russian missile violates Moldova's airspace during missile attack on Ukraine
13:24
Updated
Massive Russian attack on Christmas Eve: victims in Kharkiv, explosions across Ukraine
13:16
Ukrainian pilots complete training on Mirage 2000-5F fighters
12:52
OPINION
Christmas abroad: why refugees choose to return home
12:38
Exclusive
Russia to deploy all reserves for maximum frontline gains in January — military expert Zgurets
12:17
Iranian oil tycoon smuggles arms to Russia via Caspian Sea for Ukraine war
11:57
Russia reports 60-drone attack: explosions in Caucasus, Kazan Airport operations restricted
11:41
Russia loses 1,600 soldiers in day of war in Ukraine
11:20
Russians replace over 35% of Crimea's population under occupation
10:42
"Putin deliberately chose Christmas to attack": Zelenskyy says Russia fired over 70 missiles, 100 UAVs at Ukraine
10:18
Russia’s Christmas attack severely damages Ukraine’s energy infrastructure
2024, Tuesday
24 December
19:00
Exclusive
Oreshnik missile used by Russia was made at least 5 years ago - Defense Express expert
18:45
Exclusive
War may move to new stage if no agreement by May - political analyst
18:33
Updated
Russia strikes Kryvyi Rih, killing 1, injuring 11 civilians
18:30
Shahed production in Russia hits 2,000 drones monthly
18:05
Exclusive
Russia's gas transit cutoff in Transnistria aims to create crisis ahead of Moldovan elections - political scientist
17:25
Ukrainian soldier survives 36 days with tourniquet on leg, undergoes surgery
17:06
Exclusive
Russia moves pontoon units for potential Dnipro crossing in Kherson
More news