Espreso. Global
OPINION

Trump unlikely to strike a deal with Putin. Zelenskyy pushes for NATO

16 January, 2025 Thursday
11:58

During his visit to Warsaw, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy highlighted the security guarantees Ukraine seeks if the war with Russia comes to an end

client/title.list_title

Among these guarantees, Zelenskyy pointed to Ukraine's NATO membership, substantial military aid, and support for the Ukrainian army. He also mentioned deploying a peacekeeping contingent along the potential contact line between the two opposing armies. However, Zelenskyy stressed that a single contingent of troops — an idea the U.S. President-elect Donald Trump has spoken about, and one that French President Emmanuel Macron is actively pursuing — would not be enough to guarantee Ukraine’s security. He argued that NATO and EU membership provide far stronger safeguards.

As is well-known, Zelenskyy's stance sharply contrasts with that of Donald Trump and his team. At a recent press conference at Mar-a-Lago, Trump acknowledged Russian President Vladimir Putin’s concerns about Ukraine potentially joining NATO. Trump has also entertained plans, floated before his election, to freeze Ukraine’s NATO membership for the next 10 or even 20 years.

At the same time, Zelenskyy's position also directly opposes that of Vladimir Putin. Putin, for his part, rejects any truce unless it involves "lasting peace" with Ukraine. To Moscow, this means Ukraine’s demilitarization and formal recognition of Russian control over occupied Ukrainian regions. Putin insists that Ukraine's NATO membership shouldn’t just be delayed — it should be permanently off the table, noting that 10 or 20 years are insignificant in the grand scheme of history.

So, neither Zelenskyy’s position aligns with Trump’s plans, nor does it resonate with Putin’s demands. This only underscores the complex challenge awaiting the incoming U.S. president.

Trump now appears far more pragmatic than during his election campaign, when he confidently promised to end Russia's war against Ukraine within 24 to 48 hours of taking office.

It remains unclear when, or even if, a meeting between the U.S. president-elect and Russia's president will happen. And whether such a meeting would lead to any tangible progress on the Russian-Ukrainian war is anyone’s guess. Meanwhile, Zelenskyy, speaking from Poland, has mentioned that his team is preparing for a meeting with Trump as well.

From a logical standpoint, it seems crucial for the new U.S. president and Ukraine's president, or at least their respective teams, to meet and align on a joint strategy for ending the war before any conversation between Trump and Putin takes place.

That said, it’s clear Trump operates on his own logic, which may not align with Ukrainian expectations. He might believe that a direct discussion with Putin could radically change the situation, especially if he convinces the Russian leader to end the war on terms that would let Trump save face. On the other hand, the likely outcome of such talks can already be anticipated. Without prior coordination between Washington and Kyiv, no cohesive stance on security guarantees for Ukraine is likely to emerge, even if the war pauses or ends.

It’s absolutely obvious that Trump is unlikely to reach a genuine agreement with Putin. For Putin, simply meeting the U.S. president is a perceived sign of weakness on Washington’s part. This would embolden him to escalate demands, creating more conditions that would be unacceptable or unachievable for the U.S.

In light of this, preparations for a Trump-Zelenskyy dialogue are essential, whether it occurs before or after Trump’s potential talks with Putin.

The security guarantees Zelenskyy is demanding must have the backing of Kyiv's European partners. That’s why it’s critical for him to align his approach with European leaders. It’s no coincidence these guarantees are being discussed in Warsaw, as Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk raises concerns about Europe’s new challenges, particularly Russia’s use of hybrid terror to pressure the West into pulling support for Ukraine during the ongoing Russian-Ukrainian war.

The timing of NATO’s announcement of a new operation to secure the Baltic Sea, just ahead of Zelenskyy’s visit to Poland, speaks volumes. With the threat of hybrid attacks from Russia and China along this key route, and past incidents already on record, tensions in Europe are clearly escalating. Relations between European nations and Russia are deteriorating further, and European leaders are increasingly aware of the risks Europe faces, especially if U.S. pressure on Moscow eases or Washington opts for side deals with Putin, bypassing not only Ukraine’s but also Europe’s interests.

A united diplomatic effort to articulate Ukrainian and European positions to Donald Trump and his team could be crucial. Considering their uncertainty over handling the Russian-Ukrainian war, this could help the new U.S. administration and its diplomatic corps shape more pragmatic strategies for confronting the Kremlin in the years ahead.

Source

About the author. Vitaliy Portnykov, journalist, Ukraine's National Shevchenko Prize laureate

The editorial staff does not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Monday
10 February
11:30
Exclusive
Russian army lacks strong reserves in Pokrovsk sector — Ukrainian officer
11:12
Three key factors critical to stabilizing Russian-Ukrainian front — Ukraine’s top general
10:55
Russia can’t ignore heavy losses in Ukraine much longer — NATO military chief
10:37
Ukrainian forces destroy Russian troops trying to raise flags in Toretsk, Donetsk region
10:16
Russia launches overnight drone attack on Ukraine, hitting residential area in Sumy
09:54
Russia’s Krasnodar region reports drone attack: Afipsky oil refinery likely targeted
09:35
Russia loses over 850,000 soldiers in Ukraine since start of invasion
2025, Sunday
9 February
21:30
Drone Line: Ukraine's new large-scale military initiative
21:00
Zelenskyy: Russia pushes for elections in Ukraine to install puppet president
20:30
Zelenskyy: Putin plans to move on Poland, Hungary, Baltics after Ukraine
20:00
Invisible, cheap, and dangerous: Why Russians want to copy Ukraine's Chaklun drone
19:30
Why Hungary will supply Russian gas to Transnistria
19:00
Zelenskyy predicts Ukraine will recover Russian-occupied regions
18:30
Russian forces destroy gas facility in Kharkiv region
18:00
Germany spots suspicious drones over training base
17:35
Partisans identify Russian oil depot in Smolensk region
17:05
"Death to Ukrainians": The Day Muravyov’s army stormed Kyiv
16:35
Higher education and homes: Zelenskyy unveils military recruitment benefits for young men
16:05
Russia deploys Italmas drone – how dangerous is it?
15:35
16-hour battle: Ukraine's 47th brigade repels Russian, North Korean attacks in Kursk region
15:05
Russian tanker carrying 130,000 tons of fuel oil sinks in Leningrad region
14:37
North Korea uses Ukraine war to test military potential, experts say
13:40
Prince Harry honors Ukrainian heroes at Invictus Games 2025 opening
13:17
Exclusive
Russia can't keep advancing: It is running out of reserves
12:30
Russian spy ship ablaze near Syria, but how did it get there? – Defense Express
12:30
Exclusive
War will last years, until Russia's economy is exhausted: What Trump might ask Putin
12:00
Exclusive
Trump compares Ukraine to Gaza: Will he suggest resettling Ukrainians at his meeting with Zelenskyy?
11:30
How Ukrainian Air Defense and drone operators take down Russian military aircraf
11:00
Nuclear plant region in Western Ukraine hit by large-scale Russian attack
10:35
Russia loses aircraft, 24 artillery systems, 1,460 soldiers in one day in Ukraine – General Staff
2025, Saturday
8 February
20:00
Review
AIM-120 missiles: how Ukraine’s F-16s, NASAMS counter air, missile threats
19:40
Debate on peacekeepers in Ukraine are “inappropriate and premature”, says Scholz
19:26
Russia's artillery superiority decreased fivefold over past year - Ukraine’s top general
19:05
Putin expands Russian army for war, and not just against Ukraine — Zelenskyy
18:55
Updated
Ukrainian forces shoot down Russian Su-25 in Donetsk region
18:41
Exclusive
Ukraine’s defeat may prove to be strategic catastrophe for West - Russian opposition politician
18:18
Russian airstrike on Ukraine’s Zaporizhzhia region injures family
17:51
Ukraine’s Kursk operation aims to prevent Russian advance on Sumy, Kharkiv regions - Zelenskyy
17:24
Exclusive
Attacks on Ukrainian military enlistment offices signal new phase of war - Ukrainian officer
16:30
Captain involved in killing 59 civilians in Hroza village, Kharkiv region, dies in Russia
More news