Espreso. Global
OPINION

If not NATO, what are alternatives for Ukraine security guarantees?

3 February, 2025 Monday
11:58

One of the key issues in the peace talks will be Ukraine’s NATO membership

client/title.list_title

I’m glad that many politicians are finally being honest about the fact that this decision has never had solid backing from partner countries. The chances were always slim, largely due to the positions of individual nations — Turkey, Germany, Hungary, and, depending on elections, others. But more importantly, NATO has never been an effective defense mechanism.

In a world of hybrid threats, the organization has lost its way, with joint exercises being the most it has managed. Yes, Article 5 is a critical defense measure, but it only works with unanimous agreement. Putin just needs one ally to stall NATO, and today, he has more than one. That’s why its effectiveness has been in doubt since the Soviet collapse.

For Ukraine, the real issue in ending the war is security guarantees, ensuring this doesn’t happen again. NATO may be a weak guarantee, but it’s still a guarantee and a deterrent.

So the real question now is: If not NATO, what other security guarantees exist?

The most promising alternative to NATO could be a fully developed EU security and defense policy — essentially, a true European army. While such a policy technically exists today, it remains underdeveloped. Its focus is on funding defense projects, crisis response, and peacekeeping operations. However, it lacks a dedicated governing body, and there is no real integration of military forces into a single structure.

The weak defense policy is largely because most (though not all) EU members are in NATO, making duplication unnecessary. Simply put, Trump isn’t wrong when he accuses Europe of relying on U.S. defense spending. Now that he’s back, the push for a real European defense policy may gain momentum.

How does this impact us? Putin has never been particularly concerned about Ukraine joining the EU. Unlike NATO membership, this issue is relatively straightforward. If Ukraine joins the EU, it participates in all its policies, including defense. That means the Ukrainian Armed Forces could become part of the so-called "European army." If the common defense policy includes collective security commitments, Ukraine would gain protection under this framework.

As an EU member, Ukraine could also host military contingents from other member states, collaborate on joint production, and more.

This has serious implications, especially considering Trump’s isolationist stance, not to mention his talk about buying Greenland. European leaders need to finally show some backbone and stop clinging to the illusion of U.S. protection. As Washington scales back its military role in Europe, Ukraine's strategic importance will only grow. Ukraine's armed forces could serve as the backbone of this new European defense policy, and its industry could supply its military needs.

In the end, Putin might get what he wants — Ukraine staying out of NATO — but that wouldn’t leave Ukraine defenseless. It’d secure protection within the EU rather than NATO. Trump would achieve his goal of reducing U.S. involvement in European security. And as for nuclear deterrence, France already has nuclear weapons within the EU. Plus, given the UK’s position, it wouldn’t be surprising if Britain aligned itself with such a defense policy, even outside the EU. Meanwhile, the U.S. would still play a role in European security, even with its reduced presence in NATO.

Source

About the author. Viktor Andrusiv, political and public figure, analyst and publicist

The editorial staff does not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Thursday
13 February
10:54
116 clashes occur at front on Feb. 12: Russia launches over 5,000 strikes on Ukraine
10:33
European countries and Ukraine demand a say in any peace talks
10:15
Exclusive
Russian troops attempt to fully sever Pokrovsk-Kostiantynivka highway
09:56
U.S. envoy Kellogg to visit Ukraine for “tough diplomacy” — U.S. State Department
09:36
Russia loses 1,250 soldiers, 17 tanks, 58 artillery systems in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Wednesday
12 February
22:00
Russia launches record number of strikes on Donetsk region since war started
21:45
Exclusive
Russian army does not hesitate to drop bombs on its citizens: Ukrainian military on Kursk sector
21:33
Exclusive
How Ukraine shoots down ballistic missiles may remain classified
21:21
F-16 with JASSM-ER, illustrative photo
First F-16 photo during combat mission in Ukraine emerges online — what does it reveal?
21:10
Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania: Trump himself will decide to stand by Ukraine
21:00
Zelenskyy and Trump hold talks
20:50
Russia blocks IAEA experts' rotation at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant – Ukraine's MFA
20:40
Zelenskyy: Work on Trump’s plan to end Ukraine war likely to start in February
20:26
Ukraine wins 16 medals at 2025 Invictus Games
20:11
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
Russia is forced to retreat in some areas of Pokrovsk sector
19:51
UK pledges £150 million in military aid to Ukraine
19:36
“I prayed for Trump's protection at rally before assassination attempt” — Jason Sharron, Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania
19:25
NATO membership for Ukraine is unrealistic, says U.S. Defense Secretary Hagseth
19:10
Exclusive
Russia training surviving North Korean soldiers to reinforce troops in Kursk region
18:49
NATO must ensure negotiation results that Putin can’t overturn in six months or year – Rutte
18:11
600,000 Ukrainian children trapped in occupied territories: over 40,000 still enrolled in Ukrainian schools
18:00
Interview
Ukrainian Catholic Church priest in Pennsylvania on beauty of Ukrainian traditions and why Trump can be helpful for Ukraine
17:50
Supporting Ukraine is top foreign policy priority — Sweden’s top diplomat
17:32
'Putin will lose if he attacks NATO': Rutte on Russian threat in Europe
17:15
Exclusive
"Much hinges on Kellogg's meeting with Zelenskyy's team" regarding Trump's peace plan — Ukrainian MP
16:51
NATO Secretary General Rutte announces new military aid for Ukraine
16:37
White House power struggle: Trump ally Vitkoff’s Moscow move sparks clash over Ukraine policy
16:15
China assists Russian drone production with smuggled Western parts — Estonian intel
15:53
Zelenskyy says assassination attempts on him led to deaths in President's Office
15:42
Exclusive
European allies to announce new military aid after Ramstein meeting — Espreso correspondent
15:30
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
February 5-12 live war map: Ukrainian counterattacks yield results 
15:14
Soldier stabbed at Kharkiv recruitment center as Ukraine faces surge in attacks on military personnel
14:55
Updated
Ramstein meeting kicks off in Brussels: Key issues on the agenda
14:54
Russian soldiers seen attempting assault on Ukraine positions on crutches: video
14:32
Ukraine's Security Service uncovers FSB mole within its top ranks
14:15
Leaked video exposes Russian PSYOP: commander admits bombing civilians in Sudzha
13:55
Exclusive
Russia struggles with innovation, lacks time in weapons development — military expert
13:39
Exclusive
Lithium extraction in Ukraine with U.S. partnership may take 5–10 years, expert says
13:14
Wizz Air ready to resume flights with Ukraine within six weeks after ceasefire
12:54
Review
Trump, Zelenskyy, and rare earth resources: what Kyiv offers Washington
More news