Espreso. Global

Ukraine might benefit if Сongress rejects Biden's funding extension request - Ukrainian expert

15 September, 2024 Sunday
19:18

As the September 30 deadline approaches, U.S. President Joe Biden faces a critical decision about $5.4 billion in aid for Ukraine. This sum must either be utilized by the deadline or extended through Congressional approval

client/title.list_title

Ukrainian expert Resurgam has explained that while the White House has the capacity to allocate an additional $10.7 billion - comprising $5.3 billion from reassessments of previous years and $4.1 billion for USAI - the $5.4 billion allocated under the Presidential Drawdown Authority (PDA) presents a unique challenge. Resurgam points out that unlike USAI or FMF funds, PDA does not involve actual money but is merely an authorization, not a direct source of funding.

According to Resurgam, "Because of how PDA operates, there can be a ‘cash gap’ between the equipment provided to Ukraine and the replacement equipment."

For instance, Resurgam explains, "Suppose Ukraine received 10 Bradleys from U.S. stockpiles under the PDA, with their total value estimated at $100 according to the formula. Biden's PDA limit was $1,000. This means he used $100 of the PDA limit, leaving him with $900 in presidential authority. However, to replace the Bradleys taken from the stockpile, you don’t just order replacements at the nominal $100 value used under the PDA. Instead, you need to order new Bradleys, which cost $300 each. As a result, the actual funds available for replacement are not $900 but $700. This discrepancy arises because the PDA authorization used only $100, but the cost to replace the equipment is higher.”

Resurgam further elaborates on the dilemma, stating, “Biden can use the PDA to provide weapons from stockpiles, but these weapons won’t be replaced in the stockpiles at the same rate they are provided. The PDA is more about authorizing the use of U.S. military stockpiles without needing additional approval, rather than about replenishing those stockpiles with the same quantity of equipment.”

The expert notes that during the 2022/23 aid revaluation, over $5.3 billion under the PDA program remained largely unutilized due to the lack of real funds for replacement and maintenance. “For example, a U.S. plane carrying Bradleys can't fly if there's no money to refuel it,” Resurgam adds.

In theory, President Biden could allocate equipment using these funds, but Resurgam warns this would mean the equipment provided to Ukraine wouldn't be replaced, leading to real financial challenges and potential Congressional scrutiny. “At the critical moment in 2023/24, Biden wasn't prepared to take on that political responsibility. The same issue will likely affect the aid package for 2024,” Resurgam states.

The current package faces a similar "cash gap," where Biden has some authority but lacks the actual funds to fully utilize it without facing political consequences for depleted stockpiles. Resurgam explains that if Congress does not approve Biden’s request to extend the $5.4 billion from the PDA, the White House will face a tough decision: “1. Let the available authority ‘expire’ without using it. 2. Use all available resources now, which might lead to a share of the potential financial gap for 2024, which could be beneficial for us.”

Resurgam warns that letting these funds go to waste, especially when Biden has a way to use them without needing Congress, would be a major political scandal right before the election. “This scandal would come at a time when Democrats are launching ads featuring Harris aimed at the Polish-Ukrainian diaspora in key states, and when the media is already scrutinizing Biden over issues like long-range strikes. It would also be a blow right before Biden’s meetings on September 22-23 with Zelenskyy and the ‘Ukraine support group.’ This would give Republicans a powerful opportunity to attack not just Biden, but the Democrats as a whole, affecting their chances in the Senate and the House of Representatives.”

In modern international politics, Resurgam notes, “There’s a rule that’s almost Machiavellian: 'If you want something and they’re not willing to give it to you, make the consequences of ignoring your request worse than the trouble of granting it.'”

In this scenario, if Congress extends the $5.4 billion, Biden would still struggle to fully use these funds due to the specifics of the PDA and the resulting financial gaps. “Some of these funds might remain unspent and be carried over as ‘available presidential authority’ into 2024, but without real money to back them up, this would put Biden in a position where he’d need to take political responsibility for providing weapons that won’t be replaced with new ones,” Resurgam concludes.

If Congress does not extend the funding, Biden and his team will find themselves in a difficult political position. Resurgam suggests, “It might be easier for Democrats to push Biden to approve the full amount now, even though it means he’ll have to take political responsibility for the funding gaps in 2024. This is preferable to deferring the issue to future years, as happened in 2022 and 2023. Back then, Biden had the authority on paper, but using it carried potential political risks he was not prepared to handle alone.”

Resurgam adds that if Biden doesn’t use the funds now, some of them could end up as “dead weight” due to these funding gaps. “This would expose Democrats to severe criticism right before the election, which could undermine Biden’s efforts, especially in a tight race where every percentage point of support counts. This could ultimately impact Biden’s decision about whether to run for re-election.”

Finally, Resurgam notes that while the PDA doesn’t specifically require the replacement of supplies sent to Ukraine, other U.S. strategic defense documents do set a “critical limit” on stock levels in military warehouses.

“Maintaining these stock levels is crucial, even though it’s not explicitly required under the PDA terms for Ukraine,” Resurgam concludes.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Tuesday
8 October
15:50
Pope Francis grants privilege to Ukraine's Greek Catholic Church: Bychok on being proclaimed cardinal in Rome
15:34
Ukraine will receive Mirage 2000 fighters from France in early 2025
15:25
Updated
Russia strikes Kharkiv city center: 21 wounded, including a teen
15:14
French military prepares for key test against Russia
14:56
Russia attacks Ukraine's Kherson region with drones, artillery: one killed, one injured
14:39
Polish farmers may resume truck traffic blockade at Ukrainian border
14:16
Estonia intends to recognize deportation of Crimean Tatars as act of genocide
13:55
“Ratio of forces almost 1:9”: Ukraine's 72nd Brigade commander on withdrawal from Vuhledar
13:38
EU rolls out new sanctions to curb Russia’s destabilizing actions abroad
13:17
Vatican elevates Ukrainian-born bishop to cardinal in support of Ukraine
12:55
South Korea's Defense Ministry warns DPRK may deploy troops to Ukraine to support Russia
12:37
Exclusive
Unclear why Ukraine leaves working industrial facilities for Russia – expert Sniehyriov
12:16
Taiwan’s President: “Impossible” for communist China to be our motherland
11:47
OPINION
Russia has covert strategy
11:27
172 combat clashes on Russian-Ukrainian frontline: Russia fires 4,420 times at Ukrainian positions and civilian areas
10:59
Russia strikes Palau-flagged civilian ship in Odesa: one dead, five injured
10:43
Exclusive
Ukraine strikes largest Russian oil terminal in Feodosia, says military expert
10:22
Russia loses air defense system, 7 tanks and 1,340 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
09:58
Harris says she will not agree to talks with Putin on Ukraine without Kyiv's participation
09:38
Exclusive
Russian subversive reconnaissance groups raid frontline towns disguised as Ukrainian army
2024, Monday
7 October
21:00
Russia’s S-400 lack or failure: Defense Express analyzes Ukraine’s attack on oil depot in Crimea
20:41
OPINION
Russian bear has been totally sold to Chinese panda
20:20
Review
Mounting Russian drone attacks on Ukraine: enemy capabilities and Ukrainian countermeasures
20:00
Russian military targets Sloviansk in Donetsk region, wounding 5 people, including 2-year-old toddler
19:42
Overview of Russia's budget state
19:22
Exclusive
Ukrainian military: Pokrovsk direction is top priority for Putin, Kurakhove is up next
19:05
Russia won because of its gigantic territory
18:49
Ukraine's military intelligence disables Russian Baltic Fleet ship Alexander Obukhov
18:35
Ukrainian cyber specialists attack Russian judicial system - media
18:20
Russia sentences 72-year-old American for fighting for Ukraine
18:05
What sets Dutch F-16s apart as they join Ukraine’s Air Force?
17:48
Russia attacks Ukrainian seaport, damaging civilian ship
17:30
Ukraine won't extend gas transit from Russia, says PM Shmyhal
17:14
Ukraine integrates NATO gender equality standards into Armed Forces
16:55
Ukraine’s 3rd Brigade retakes positions in Kharkiv region, frees captive Ukrainian soldiers
16:36
Russian losses in Ukraine war reach record levels in September — UK intelligence
16:16
Fico says Slovakia is “cool” towards Ukraine's NATO membership
15:54
Ukrainian hackers attack Kremlin's state TV broadcasters
15:30
Updated
Russia attacks Ukraine with guided bombs, explosions leave 20 injured, including 2 children
15:16
Russia charges 14 foreign journalists for illegal border crossings
More news