Espreso. Global
OPINION

Traditional wars are becoming a thing of the past

9 September, 2024 Monday
13:55

I’m reading The New Rules of War by Sean McFate. To give you some context, the author is a former military officer with experience in private military companies, and now he teaches strategy at Georgetown, one of the top universities for training public servants

client/title.list_title

His logical but somewhat contradictory arguments shed light on the half-hearted efforts of Ukraine's allies in ramping up arms production.

What’s the difference between a global power and a regional one like Ukraine?

It’s that the U.S. sees a tangled web of conflicts, each unique in its own way. Genocide in Rwanda. Civil war in Syria. The rise of non-state militant groups like Hezbollah and ISIS. Israel’s long conflict with the Arab world. Drug cartels in Mexico. And a whole list of countries like Iran, North Korea, and China.

For example, McFate questions why the U.S. views the drug cartel wars in Mexico as mere gang violence. In his view, this is a new form of warfare that, in terms of casualties, surpasses the U.S. wars in Iraq or Afghanistan.

Each of these conflicts demands its own tactics. And those tactics need funding and focus.

In the book, McFate argues that traditional wars are a relic of the past. He suggests that unconventional warfare now dominates the world stage — something that big powers are ill-equipped to handle. He points to the U.S. losing wars in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan despite its technological superiority and arsenal.

In his view, the U.S. should invest less in aircraft carriers and F-35s, and more in flexible, effective tools like information warfare, propaganda, and, yes, the greater use of mercenaries.

Meanwhile, each party involved in these unique conflicts views their war as the most important one. For instance, when the West began to back Ukraine actively, many Third World countries felt left out. Why, they ask, are their conflicts ignored while Ukraine's war draws global attention?

On one hand, it’s good that Ukraine’s war isn’t being overlooked, like so many others. But on the other hand, the existence of these other conflicts prevents the West from fully focusing on our crisis.

Why should the West bother producing artillery shells if traditional wars are over?

Because for the past 30 years, the U.S. has lived under the illusion that it's the unchallenged superpower, with no real competitors left. During this sheltered period, an entire generation of experts and politicians grew up without ever considering the possibility of a traditional war. That one day, their country might face a foe with similar economic and military power.

Incidentally, the British Empire once fell into this same trap. After years of dealing with tribal skirmishes in Africa and weak nations in Asia, they were completely unprepared for a full-scale continental war with Germany.

Source

About the author: Pavlo Vernivskyi, economist, expert 

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by the blog authors.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Thursday
13 February
15:35
China suggests Putin-Trump summit as solution to end war against Ukraine
15:16
Russia denies talks of recognizing Crimea, occupied territories as Russian in Trump-Putin call
14:53
Secret Gravehawk air defense system for Ukraine unveiled – and it's not what you'd expect
14:40
Ukraine’s parliament work blocked by MPs protesting political repression
14:21
Ukraine's role crucial in peace talks after Trump-Putin call, NATO chief says
13:56
Zelenskyy imposes sanctions against Ukraine’s former President Poroshenko
13:38
Exclusive
"Unprecedented case in nuclear energy history": Expert on Ukraine buying reactors from Bulgaria
13:15
Poland warns Ukraine not to expect NATO invitation to “fall from the sky”
12:54
Trump's ex-advisor: Kremlin drinks vodka straight from bottle after Trump-Putin talk
12:35
Around 7,000 civilians remain in Ukraine’s Pokrovsk as evacuation continues
12:15
Review
Return to pre-war borders is unrealistic: New Pentagon chief's statements at Ramstein and Ukraine's stance. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:52
Russian forces block water and humanitarian aid deliveries to civilians in frontline areas
11:35
"Putin would say he won": Trump says he'll keep supporting Ukraine
11:16
Russian civilians evacuated to Ukraine after Russia’s deadly strike on shelter
10:54
116 clashes occur at front on Feb. 12: Russia launches over 5,000 strikes on Ukraine
10:33
European countries and Ukraine demand a say in any peace talks
10:15
Exclusive
Russian troops attempt to fully sever Pokrovsk-Kostiantynivka highway
09:56
U.S. envoy Kellogg to visit Ukraine for “tough diplomacy” — U.S. State Department
09:36
Russia loses 1,250 soldiers, 17 tanks, 58 artillery systems in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Wednesday
12 February
22:00
Russia launches record number of strikes on Donetsk region since war started
21:45
Exclusive
Russian army does not hesitate to drop bombs on its citizens: Ukrainian military on Kursk sector
21:33
Exclusive
How Ukraine shoots down ballistic missiles may remain classified
21:21
F-16 with JASSM-ER, illustrative photo
First F-16 photo during combat mission in Ukraine emerges online — what does it reveal?
21:10
Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania: Trump himself will decide to stand by Ukraine
21:00
Zelenskyy and Trump hold talks
20:50
Russia blocks IAEA experts' rotation at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant – Ukraine's MFA
20:40
Zelenskyy: Work on Trump’s plan to end Ukraine war likely to start in February
20:26
Ukraine wins 16 medals at 2025 Invictus Games
20:11
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, February 5-12
Russia is forced to retreat in some areas of Pokrovsk sector
19:51
UK pledges £150 million in military aid to Ukraine
19:36
“I prayed for Trump's protection at rally before assassination attempt” — Jason Sharron, Ukrainian priest in Pennsylvania
19:25
NATO membership for Ukraine is unrealistic, says U.S. Defense Secretary Hagseth
19:10
Exclusive
Russia training surviving North Korean soldiers to reinforce troops in Kursk region
18:49
NATO must ensure negotiation results that Putin can’t overturn in six months or year – Rutte
18:11
600,000 Ukrainian children trapped in occupied territories: over 40,000 still enrolled in Ukrainian schools
18:00
Interview
Ukrainian Catholic Church priest in Pennsylvania on beauty of Ukrainian traditions and why Trump can be helpful for Ukraine
17:50
Supporting Ukraine is top foreign policy priority — Sweden’s top diplomat
17:32
'Putin will lose if he attacks NATO': Rutte on Russian threat in Europe
17:15
Exclusive
"Much hinges on Kellogg's meeting with Zelenskyy's team" regarding Trump's peace plan — Ukrainian MP
16:51
NATO Secretary General Rutte announces new military aid for Ukraine
More news