Espreso. Global
OPINION

Why does Ukraine need long-range ATACMS so much?

22 September, 2023 Friday
19:30

After Ukraine was once again denied the supply of these missiles, strange thoughts began to arise, such as, are they required at all? The UK and France handed over long-range Storm Shadow and Scalp EGs, and that’s good – we're doing fine!

client/title.list_title

The idea, of course, is interesting, especially thickly laced with obsessive-compulsive "stop humiliating yourself in front of Biden!", but absolutely useless.

Ukraine really requires ATACMS and I will try to explain why. And I would like the Oval Office to understand why Ukraine requires them so much.

Ukraine currently has two types of long-range missiles in service – Storm Shadow and Scalp EG. There are also some missiles of Ukrainian production, but nothing is known about them, and I don't think there are as many of them as SS/Scalp EG.

Storm Shadow and Scalp EG are subsonic cruise missiles, and they are perfectly capable of accomplishing their missions, especially considering the extreme difficulty of intercepting these missiles by Russian air defense systems. But they have two very unpleasant nuances.

The first nuance is related to the carrier, which is the Su-24 front-line bomber. First of all, we have a limited number of them. The Su-24s themselves are tied to airfields that are not only occasionally struck by the occupying Russian forces, but also monitored.

Therefore, when the Su-24 takes off, the Russian troops already know about it. It is very difficult to carry out an attack as stealthy as possible, when you are tied to a carrier, and the carrier is tied to a location, even if not one.

But, the second nuance is even more unpleasant – the limited number of missiles.

As good as the Storm Shadow and Scalp EG are, their numbers are small. And the UK and France have a limited stockpile of these missiles, and their production is not fast enough to produce the unlimited strike capability required by Ukraine’s army in a day.

Now on to ATACMS...

First of all, there are more ATACMS in US stockpiles than Storm Shadow and Scalp EG in the UK and France combined. But the most important thing is that this missile allows Ukraine to significantly expand the range of launch locations and increase the suddenness of strikes.

Because ATACMS are employed by M142 HIMARS and M270 MLRSs, there will be no permanent fixation on deployment location and no ability to track the direction of the threat. There are dozens of M142s and M270s along the entire battle line that will be able to employ ATACMS at any time.

Thus, Ukraine will be able to significantly diversify the geography of use of long-range missiles and significantly increase its ability for the army to successfully advance and liberate the occupied territories. By combining ATACMS with other missiles, we will achieve maximum efficiency.

Unfortunately, the absence of ATACMS is a limitation of the Ukrainian army in operations to create conditions for a successful offensive, and the insistent refusal to hand over these missiles is more sabotage of such operations than anything else.

If the US really wishes Ukraine’s victory, then transfer ATACMS!

Source

About the author: Oleksandr Kovalenko, Ukrainian journalist. 

The editors don't always share the opinions expressed by the authors of the blogs.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Sunday
24 November
16:25
Exclusive
No more talk of “ending the war in 24 hours”: politician explains shift in Trump team's tone
15:58
Russian army advances in Kursk, Donetsk, Kharkiv regions – DeepState
15:28
Taiwan’s former president urges U.S. to put Ukraine's needs first
14:58
Exclusive
Why Republicans won’t cut Ukraine support – Russian opposition expert
14:22
Exclusive
Holding Kursk region territory is strategically impractical – Ukrainian Army General Malomuzh
14:17
Updated
Russia shells Kherson region: three elderly people seriously wounded
13:28
Ukrainian forces strike S-400 air defense missile system in Russia's Kursk region
13:06
Russians claim to shoot down 2 missiles, 36 drones across 5 regions
12:27
Exclusive
Putin thinks escalation could strengthen his hand with Trump – journalist Portnikov on nuclear threats
12:05
OPINION
Blockade on Polish border: Who stands to gain?
11:33
Ukrainian air defenses down 50 of 73 Russian drones in latest attack
11:02
Russia loses 1,020 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
10:31
Russia launches drone attack on Ukraine’s Kyiv: air alert lasts over 3 hours
2024, Saturday
23 November
20:10
Putin orders to dislodge Ukrainian forces from Kursk before Trump’s inauguration - Zelenskyy
19:50
Ukraine's ex-top general warns of potential Russian technological breakthrough by 2027
19:30
Exclusive
Kremlin to set Trump its terms for ending war - Russian opposition expert
19:11
Exclusive
Without security guarantees for Ukraine, negotiations are meaningless - U.S. diplomat
18:50
Ukraine can intercept new Russian Kedr missiles capable of carrying nuclear warheads
18:27
Russia steals over 785 Ukrainian cultural heritage artifacts
18:05
Exclusive
Russia's stockpile of such missiles is limited — aviation expert on Dnipro strike
17:40
Russia trains specialists for prisoner torture system - Ukraine’s intelligence
17:15
Exclusive
Biden administration never tried to ensure Ukraine's victory - U.S. diplomat
16:44
OPINION
Ukraine-Russia peace talks: possible as process, unlikely as outcome
16:15
Exclusive
Turbulence before Trump’s inauguration to bring 60 to 90 days of uncertainty - Russian opposition expert Morozov
15:49
U.S. intelligence links Kremlin to killings of Putin’s critics abroad
15:21
Russian general likely killed in Storm Shadow strike on Kursk headquarters - media
14:50
OPINION
Does Trump have plan?
14:20
Russia plans to test-fire ballistic missiles again in coming days - ISW
13:50
Russian attack on Zaporizhzhia: 11-year-old boy injured, 55-year-old man killed
13:25
Admiral Nakhimov nuclear-powered cruiser of Russian Fleet
How Russia's war on Ukraine stalled its Navy modernization - Defense Express
12:55
Russia trades missiles, air defense systems, oil in exchange for North Korean troops - ISW
12:25
Review
New details on Dnipro strike and reasons behind Russian advance in Donetsk region. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:53
Russia planned genocide of Ukrainians long before full-scale invasion - intel chief Budanov
11:26
Exclusive
Russia is modernizing Soviet junk, Americans know how to deal with it - former SBU head 
10:55
Russian troops make significant progress in Klishchiivka - Andriivka section, Donetsk region
10:25
Russia loses 1,420 soldiers, 24 artillery systems, 20 tanks per day - Ukraine's General Staff
2024, Friday
22 November
21:40
Ukraine in talks with partners for new air defense systems - Zelenskyy
21:30
Exclusive
Nothing stops Russia from launching nuclear attack - Defense Express
21:20
118 combat clashes reported at front today, with Russian forces most active in Pokrovsk, Kurakhove, Vremivka sectors
21:10
Russian army aims to capture Donetsk, Luhansk regions this winter - Ukraine's intelligence
More news