Espreso. Global
Review

Military personal income tax withheld: how will frontline communities survive?

9 November, 2023 Thursday
21:09

What consequences will the retroactive redistribution of military personal income tax have for local communities and will it really strengthen Ukraine’s defense capability?

On November 8, the Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine's parliament, passed amendments to the Budget Code of Ukraine with the aim of "ensuring support for the state's defense capability and the development of the defense industry of Ukraine." The amendment directs the personal income tax paid on military salaries, previously allocated to local and regional budgets, to the state budget for the procurement of drones and artillery systems. The financial impact is substantial, with nearly 26 billion hryvnias earmarked for the remainder of this year and around 94 billion projected for the next year. However, concerns arise about the impact of this reallocation on local budgets, as the amendment treats both relatively secure cities in the west and frontline communities—where military income tax and public sector salaries are crucial—as equals.

The text covers the following topics:

  • Military personal income tax as a gold mine
  • Dnipro city alone lost UAH 4 billion due to changes
  • Communities can no longer eliminate the consequences of strikes quickly 
  • Does the law comply with the Constitution

Military personal income tax as a gold mine

Personal income tax is the main source of local budget revenues. This includes employee salaries and salaries for the military and security forces. Since the start of the full-scale invasion, the number of military personnel has increased significantly, and so has the personal income tax on their salaries. However, community expenditures have also surged. For instance, during the heating season, in the face of power outages, communities have to purchase tons of fuel for generators and the generators themselves.

At the same time, the government's draft law stipulates that the military personal income tax withdrawn from communities this year will be used to purchase drones and artillery systems (approximately UAH 13 billion each).

Next year, 45% will be allocated to the State Special Communications Service for drones, another 45% to the Ministry of Strategic Industry for the deployment of ammunition and weapons production, and 10% to the security and defense sector managers for automatic distribution among military units.

"The Parliament has effectively deprived local authorities of the opportunity to help the Ukrainian Armed Forces and direct funds from municipal budgets to our defenders," said Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko. "By taking away military personal income tax from cities and towns (and retroactively), the Verkhovna Rada and the government are demonstrating that the central government has failed to finance the army. And now it is trying to shift this onto local governments. This is despite the fact that all cities already pay 40% of their communities' personal income tax to the state budget. And Kyiv pays 60%. And all cities also additionally allocate funds from community budgets to help the defenders." 

According to him, this decision will especially hit small towns and cities where military personal income tax used to be a significant part of the budget. 

For instance, in the Yavoriv community with a population of 52,000, the council's military personal income tax revenues as of November 1 totaled approximately UAH 1 billion. Simultaneously, this year, the community budget allocates 374 million for a subvention to the state budget, catering to military units' logistical support upon their request. An additional 365.4 million from the Yavoriv budget is being redirected to the state budget as a reverse subsidy.

Dnipro city alone lost 4 billion due to changes

Many representatives of local communities call the pickets outside local councils with the slogans "first drones, then stadiums" a "long-shot game" played by the authorities. Of course, it wouldn't have gained traction if certain local councils, upon obtaining access to resources, hadn't started spending them on, to put it mildly, inappropriate purchases during the war—such as expensive sports complexes, ski roller tracks, etc. 

“In fact, the problem with non-critical procurement could have been easily addressed by simply regulating what money can and cannot be spent on during martial law. But they didn't even try to do this," says Nina Yuzhanina, a member of the Verkhovna Rada, in a comment to Espreso. "We witnessed how the situation in society was escalating. For instance, the protests against the spending of billions by Dnipro city, allegedly in areas deemed less essential. Maybe they are. But there needs to be regulation. Yet, you can't strip away all military personal income taxes from Dnipro — it struggles from constant strikes: in the city center, on the outskirts, in satellite cities. It's just a ruin there."

Meanwhile, Dnipro Mayor Borys Filatov said that UAH 4 billion were taken away from Dnipro alone.

I take off my hat to our parliamentarians and government officials who have played such a technical trick on local self-government. So, dear colleagues, you have now received an insanely large amount of money. I hope you will manage not only to spend them rationally for the needs of the Ukrainian Defense Forces. But also openly report to the public on the effectiveness of these expenditures," Filatov wrote, calling the activists who protested against non-critical procurement "useful idiots." 

According to Yuzhanina, there was an appeal from the head of the Kharkiv City Council and deputies from the frontline regions, who explained that the funds were being used to build fortifications.

"They've initiated the reconstruction of fortifications, focusing on reinforcing the third line of defense due to the acknowledged potential risks. However, as they engage in these efforts, their resources are being taken away from them. How do you feel about this? I have different opinions on this," says the MP. "If we say that we lack 25.8 billion by the end of this year to buy shells and other needs, then let's find it now, let's find it very quickly. Even based on the 45 billion we have in receivables from the Ministry of Defense. I agree that other items of expenditure should be reviewed, even our salaries should be cut if necessary, but it is unacceptable to take away a source of income from frontline communities."

Communities can no longer eliminate the consequences of strikes quickly 

"We understand that there is a large budget deficit: this year we do not have enough money to buy shells, as the authorities say, not enough to restore or build the defense complex. But since September, when this government bill was submitted, we had to hear from the frontline regions. There, local communities spend not only 100% of this tax, which is paid by distribution to the local budget. They spend more than this," says MP Nina Yuzhanina, "There are a lot of problems on the ground that they solve without waiting for any subventions from the state budget. Upon arrival, local authorities find opportunities to respond as quickly as possible and provide people with some kind of temporary housing."

At the same time, it is the communities where military facilities are located that are more often subject to enemy missile attacks. Russia regularly attacks Starokostiantyniv, Khmelnytsky region, with missiles and drones, and civilian facilities are being damaged. 

"For frontline communities, on the border with Russia, in the area of active hostilities, military personal income tax was the main income, and the basic subsidy for 2021 does not provide compensation for revenues and, most importantly, the funds necessary to maintain infrastructure and social programs," Oksana Prodan, Advisor to the Head of the Association of Ukrainian Cities, told Espreso. "There are communities that will have a budget deficit of up to 40% next year due to the withdrawal of military personal income tax. And these are the ones that need to be rebuilt and restored, because they have suffered the greatest destruction due to shelling. And they continue to be shelled."

Is it possible to challenge the bill in the Constitutional Court?

Although the parliament passed the draft law on the redistribution of military personal income tax on November 8, the money should be withdrawn from local budgets from October 1 until the end of martial law. That is, retroactively, which is legislative nonsense.

"The withdrawal took place "retroactively", and therefore with violations. Moreover, such changes not just in the middle of the budget year, but in the last quarter is also a violation. No proper compensation was provided to the communities for which this will be critical in 2024," says Oksana Prodan.

Meanwhile, Nina Yuzhanina believes that if the law stipulates that the withdrawal should take place on October 1, it means that the Treasury has been withholding these funds since October and not transferring them to the communities.

"I am surprised that the law was adopted retroactively to transfer personal income tax to the special fund of the state budget as early as October 1. This means that since October 1, the Treasury has already delayed these transfers. "It's already November, so at least two transactions have been delayed," says the MP. "I heard that lawyers were quietly talking about the fact that this is a reason to file a lawsuit with the Constitutional Court for non-compliance with the law. But it seems to me that everything will now be covered by martial law and extreme necessity."

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Wednesday
17 April
17:12
OPINION
"Ordinary voters" will lead to punishment
16:54
Russia bans 235 Australian MPs from entering country in response to sanctions
16:35
Russia engages over 1,000 teenagers in making Shahed UAVs — Center for National Resistance
16:09
Updated
Russia launches missiles at Ukraine, kills and injures civilians in Chernihiv
15:41
Russia is preparing provocation against Ukraine over alleged Western arms trafficking in Africa
15:13
Updated
Ukraine Intelligence's drones attack Container radar in Mordovia - media
15:00
Exclusive
April 10-17 live war map: Russian forces mobilize reserves to break through front lines
14:25
OPINION
I brought deported Ukrainian children to speak at UN and it changed the world
13:58
Yana Stepanenko raises over USD 15,000 for military at Boston marathon
13:30
Mi-8 helicopter destroyed in Russian Samara – Ukraine's Intelligence
13:08
Exclusive
"Very severe detonation": Captain of Ukrainian Navy Reserve explains importance of Dzhankoi airfield strike
12:52
Exclusive
Ukrainian drone production volumes have increased significantly - military expert Zgurets
12:25
Updated
Explosions heard near Dzhankoi military airfield in Crimea - Russian media
12:14
Kharkiv Mayor says city could become "second Aleppo" without US help
11:58
Exclusive
Ukraine's armed forces prevent Russia's advance near Chasiv Yar - Rubizh brigade 
11:35
OPINION
Why won't the US and its allies crush Iran?
10:50
"Critical need": US Congress calls to provide urgent aid to Ukraine
10:30
Russian army loses 4 tanks, 15 artillery systems and 710 soldiers per day — Ukraine's General Staff
10:11
Exclusive
Russia currently lacks resources and conditions to quickly capture Chasiv Yar - Information Resistance
09:34
U.S. aid delays limit Ukraine's defense and give Russia flexibility to attack - ISW
2024, Tuesday
16 April
21:20
Review
Victorious news of 783rd day of war: Ukraine blackouts two Russian military plants, IMF predicts Ukraine's GDP growth this year
20:55
Zelenskyy announces request to convene NATO-Ukraine Council meeting
20:30
Support for Ukraine's recovery at Russian assets expense: PACE unanimously adopts resolution
20:05
Exclusive
Patriot can't intercept such missiles: aviation expert explains how Russia destroyed Trypilska TPP
19:40
Exclusive
Russia views operation in Bakhmut area as springboard for summer offensive — Defense Express
19:16
Exclusive
Inviting Russia is illogical, it has nothing to do at peace summit — political scientist Levus
18:52
Ukraine verifies 1,700 civilian hostages held by Russia — Ombudsman
18:25
OPINION
On the aftermath of Iran's strike on Israel
18:00
Ukraine builds underground hospitals in Kherson region — Ukrainian official
17:40
Russia keeps civilian Ukrainians prisoner fearing they may serve as war crime witnesses — Ombudsman
17:11
OPINION
Ukraine emerges as crucial in shaping new world order
16:43
Russia claims Ukraine would use “Olympic truce” for regrouping
16:18
Power substation in Russia’s Bryansk burns down, cutting power to military facilities
16:02
Russia's war against Ukraine: Xi tells Scholz he supports international peace conference with participation of all sides
15:46
Russia attacks Kherson region with KAB bombs: 15 people suffer contusions
15:30
Russian weapons bolster Iran's defense against Israeli airstrikes – WP
15:13
20 Days in Mariupol film to appear on Netflix
14:48
Biden meets Czech Prime Minister Fiala at White House to discuss Ukraine
14:32
Zelenskyy says Russia managed to destroy Trypilska TPP as Ukraine lacked missiles for defense
14:14
SBU destroys radar monitoring sky over Ukraine with drones in Russia - media
More news