Espreso. Global
Review

"Pack" attack’s effectiveness: another Russian Black Sea Fleet ship Sergei Kotov sinks. Serhiy Zgurets’ column 

6 March, 2024 Wednesday
11:40

This cool attack took place last night, March 5, in the territorial waters of Ukraine near the Kerch Strait. The Russian ship was destroyed by MAGURA V5 maritime drones in cooperation with the DIU and the Ukrainian Navy

client/title.list_title

The sinking of the Russian Black Sea Fleet corvette Sergei Kotov

Allow me to begin with a story that, while already familiar to many, deserves mention. It revolves around our maritime drones' successful attack on the Russian Black Sea Fleet's patrol ship Sergei Kotov. This remarkable assault occurred on March 5, within our country's territorial waters near the Kerch Strait. The Defense Intelligence of Ukraine (HUR) has confirmed the operation's success, highlighting that the ship's destruction resulted from a collaborative effort between the HUR and the Ukrainian Navy. The attack was executed using MAGURA V5 maritime drones, whose development and improvement are overseen by military intelligence.

Later, the Defence Intelligence of Ukraine released a video showing the “pack” attack. First, these maritime drones hit the port side of the ship, and then after a short time, the starboard side. The ship becomes immovable and then several more drones strike the sides, even another drone enters the hole and blows up the ship from the inside. This tactic was used before, when the large amphibious assault ship Caesar Kunikov was destroyed on February 14. This "pack" tactic also proved to be quite effective.

The HUR also demonstrated the interception of a conversation in which the commander of a brigade of ships of the Russian Black Sea Fleet reports and says that a helicopter was used to repel the attack. That is, they knew that the attack would happen, but they were unable to repel it. According to the HUR, such a ship costs over $60 million. Among the losses was a K-29 helicopter that was transporting the corvette in the hangar. In terms of manpower losses, there were 7 killed, 6 wounded, and about 50 crew members were evacuated after the attack.

This corvette is one of the newest ships of this project, it was put in use with the Russian Black Sea Fleet in 2022. We can say that there were 4 such ships, and now there are 3 left.

What conclusion can we draw? The Ukrainian Armed Forces have been regularly destroying Russian Black Sea Fleet ships since the beginning of the full-scale invasion. In total, about 15 ships have been destroyed or damaged by missiles, but most of them have been destroyed by naval drones. This strategy not only demonstrates an effective tactic of displacing the enemy but also played a crucial role in the establishment of the grain corridor. We expect more to come, as the enemy still has enough targets for our naval drones.

The situation at the front

The front line is currently facing extreme challenges, with 74 clashes reported, indicating intense combat activity. The most critical situations are unfolding in the Novopavlivka direction and in the area west of Avdiivka. According to the General Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, 28 attacks have been repelled near the settlements of Berdychi, Tonenke, Pervomaiske, and Nevelske. The situation in each of these areas is notably severe.

Oleksandr Shyrshyn, the deputy battalion commander of the 47th Brigade, described the recent days as particularly challenging, as Russia has been aggressively attempting to conduct assault offensives on a daily basis. Initially, the Russian forces deployed a significant amount of equipment and infantry towards Ukrainian combat formations. These attempts were met with strong resistance, resulting in the destruction of the enemy infantry along with their equipment, thanks to the effective use of Bradley infantry fighting vehicles and FPV drones. Observing the loss of much of their equipment, left abandoned in the fields, Russian soldiers have now slightly altered their approach. Instead of large-scale assaults, they are conducting smaller infantry offensives, about 5-7 times a day, indicating a high intensity of combat activity.

The deputy battalion commander of the 47th Brigade noted that the Ukrainian Armed Forces almost fully control Berdychi. Russian forces have established themselves in the first 5-6 buildings of the town, but Ukrainian forces control the remaining area, maintaining their positions. This scenario mirrors the situation in Stepove, where defenders held out for 4 months. The composition of the Russian forces remains the same, although some brigades have been reconstituted once or twice. Captured Russian soldiers report that their ranks are replenished with new recruits every few days, who are then quickly sent into assault operations.

The soldier mentioned that his brigade utilizes all available armored vehicles. Despite the high quality of the equipment, losses are inevitable in war. Thanks to the courage of their crews, who often engage directly and sometimes cross the contact line, they succeed in disrupting enemy formations. Currently, there's a noticeable reduction in Russia’s use of KAB bombs, yet they remain active. Russian troops haven't introduced any novel tactics lately. In Stepove they were employing chemical agents, these tactics have not been documented in Berdychi so far.

Shyrshyn highlighted that there is truth in the criticisms regarding unequipped positions. While certain areas have been equipped with trenches or specific positions dug by excavators, there remains work for personnel to further fortify these positions. Unfortunately, this essential work is not progressing as desired. The reasons for this can be discussed, but it's crucial to recognize that wartime demands extraordinary efforts, including physical labor such as digging trenches. For those in the rear who demand explanations on the absence of a second line of defense, you can volunteer and form a team to assist in trench-digging while the military holds the front line. Given that some soldiers are actively engaged in combat operations, fortification efforts during active fighting pose challenges. However, the brigades currently in the rear can undertake these fortification tasks.

Concluding the conversation with Oleksandr Shyrshyn, I would like to say that his brigade is currently holding the line west of Avdiivka near Berdychi. This is the area where Russian troops are trying to push our defense along the entire line. However, we see that in this area, where the 47th Brigade is stationed, Russia is not succeeding and suffering losses. Although, we should recognize that this defense is based on the courage of those soldiers and officers, one of whom we talked to today.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Sunday
24 November
14:22
Exclusive
Holding Kursk region territory is strategically impractical – Ukrainian Army General Malomuzh
14:17
Updated
Russia shells Kherson region: three elderly people seriously wounded
13:28
Ukrainian forces strike S-400 air defense missile system in Russia's Kursk region
13:06
Russians claim to shoot down 2 missiles, 36 drones across 5 regions
12:27
Exclusive
Putin thinks escalation could strengthen his hand with Trump – journalist Portnikov on nuclear threats
12:05
OPINION
Blockade on Polish border: Who stands to gain?
11:33
Ukrainian air defenses down 50 of 73 Russian drones in latest attack
11:02
Russia loses 1,020 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
10:31
Russia launches drone attack on Ukraine’s Kyiv: air alert lasts over 3 hours
2024, Saturday
23 November
20:10
Putin orders to dislodge Ukrainian forces from Kursk before Trump’s inauguration - Zelenskyy
19:50
Ukraine's ex-top general warns of potential Russian technological breakthrough by 2027
19:30
Exclusive
Kremlin to set Trump its terms for ending war - Russian opposition expert
19:11
Exclusive
Without security guarantees for Ukraine, negotiations are meaningless - U.S. diplomat
18:50
Ukraine can intercept new Russian Kedr missiles capable of carrying nuclear warheads
18:27
Russia steals over 785 Ukrainian cultural heritage artifacts
18:05
Exclusive
Russia's stockpile of such missiles is limited — aviation expert on Dnipro strike
17:40
Russia trains specialists for prisoner torture system - Ukraine’s intelligence
17:15
Exclusive
Biden administration never tried to ensure Ukraine's victory - U.S. diplomat
16:44
OPINION
Ukraine-Russia peace talks: possible as process, unlikely as outcome
16:15
Exclusive
Turbulence before Trump’s inauguration to bring 60 to 90 days of uncertainty - Russian opposition expert Morozov
15:49
U.S. intelligence links Kremlin to killings of Putin’s critics abroad
15:21
Russian general likely killed in Storm Shadow strike on Kursk headquarters - media
14:50
OPINION
Does Trump have plan?
14:20
Russia plans to test-fire ballistic missiles again in coming days - ISW
13:50
Russian attack on Zaporizhzhia: 11-year-old boy injured, 55-year-old man killed
13:25
Admiral Nakhimov nuclear-powered cruiser of Russian Fleet
How Russia's war on Ukraine stalled its Navy modernization - Defense Express
12:55
Russia trades missiles, air defense systems, oil in exchange for North Korean troops - ISW
12:25
Review
New details on Dnipro strike and reasons behind Russian advance in Donetsk region. Serhiy Zgurets' column
11:53
Russia planned genocide of Ukrainians long before full-scale invasion - intel chief Budanov
11:26
Exclusive
Russia is modernizing Soviet junk, Americans know how to deal with it - former SBU head 
10:55
Russian troops make significant progress in Klishchiivka - Andriivka section, Donetsk region
10:25
Russia loses 1,420 soldiers, 24 artillery systems, 20 tanks per day - Ukraine's General Staff
2024, Friday
22 November
21:40
Ukraine in talks with partners for new air defense systems - Zelenskyy
21:30
Exclusive
Nothing stops Russia from launching nuclear attack - Defense Express
21:20
118 combat clashes reported at front today, with Russian forces most active in Pokrovsk, Kurakhove, Vremivka sectors
21:10
Russian army aims to capture Donetsk, Luhansk regions this winter - Ukraine's intelligence
20:55
Russian troops execute five Ukrainian prisoners of war in Donetsk region
20:40
Exclusive
Russian forces likely control part of Ukraine's Kurakhove - military observer
20:23
Exclusive
Russia has already launched missiles at Ukraine with same warhead weight as recently
20:08
Russia’s Kedr ballistic missile: new threat or just another Oreshnik?
More news