Espreso. Global
Review

Avdiivka’s final hours: amassing of Russian troops, withdrawal of Ukraine’s army. Weekly military summary

17 February, 2024 Saturday
14:58

Russia, relying on its superiority in artillery and aviation, used every opportunity to make it impossible for Ukraine's soldiers to conduct controlled withdrawal

client/title.list_title

Frontline situation: Avdiivka

The Russian occupation forces were trying to surround the Ukrainian grouping, including the Zenit position, from which the troops were withdrawn. Now Russia was trying to reduce the area through which Ukraine's grouping was logistically supplied, in particular, east of Avdiivka. But the 3rd Brigade, which has entered this difficult area, again ensured that this corridor would not become narrower. The brigade is also to ensure the gradual withdrawal of Ukrainian units. 

Now we are all watching with concern what is happening in and around Avdiivka. One third of all combat clashes over the past day took place in this area of the frontline. On the morning of February 16, the commander of the Tavria operational and strategic grouping of troops, Oleksandr Tarnavskyi, said that units were being reinforced, troops were being maneuvered, and resources of ammunition and other means of destruction were allocated to the units holding Avdiivka. Powerful fortifications are being prepared, taking into account all possible scenarios.

Later, Tarnavskyi said that Ukrainian units had withdrawn from the Zenit position on the outskirts of Avdiivka. This position was in a situation where the Russian forces were advancing from both sides. Therefore, it was decided to withdraw the military from these positions. Tarnavskyi noted that this decision was made to save personnel and improve the operational situation.

Map of fighting in Avdiivka, Donetsk region

Commander-in-Chief of the Ukrainian Armed Forces Oleksandr Syrskyi and President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy also told about the need to save the lives of Ukrainian soldiers. But when we use this phrase too often, it is important that it does not turn into a "situation assessment site" where everyone is talking only about saving personnel. This should be taken extremely seriously and responsibly.

Map of fighting in Avdiivka, Donetsk region

Russia has 50,000 troops concentrated around Avdiivka. Until a certain time, when Russia was deploying its reserves to Avdiivka, Ukraine's artillery was actively working and destruction of Russian forces was significant, so holding this area was absolutely logical and rational. The task of defense is to inflict maximum losses on the enemy. The Ukrainian brigades that worked in Avdiivka fulfilled this mission. Now, when the Russian army is fighting in Avdiivka itself, it is difficult to ensure the superiority of Russia's losses.

It is worth noting that the flank overhangs around Avdiivka were formed not yesterday, but four months ago, when Russia launched an active offensive. Ukraine realized that there was a flanking threat. The main flanks were held, and Russia then concentrated its efforts primarily on one section of the front and used its main advantage. It was not only an advantage in manpower and ammunition, but also an advantage in aviation. The Russian occupation forces actively used the guided aerial bombs. These bombs significantly influenced the fact that it was and is extremely difficult to defend Avdiivka. Also, certain areas of action were aimed at cutting logistics routes. Currently, one of the main supply routes through Orlivka to Avdiivka is not functioning. The other two routes are operating, but it is much more difficult to use them.

Chasiv Yar

Map of fighting in Bakhmut area, Donetsk region

The Russian army is trying to get to Chasiv Yar, but now it is concentrating its main efforts on approaching Ivanivske. Russian troops tried to move from Bohdanivka to Chasiv Yar, then there were efforts from Khromove. But now the main concentration of efforts is on Ivanivske to continue moving along the highway. There have been no changes on the map in recent days, there is a certain accumulation of Russian forces there, as always. Ukraine's artillery is working there, even in conditions when the reserves are being used quite rationally. The lack of ammunition is now being compensated by FPV drones. This area remains challenging, as do a number of other areas. But we are confident in the actions of the Ukrainian brigades holding the line. Most likely, Russia's losses in this area will not be much less than in other areas, including near Avdiivka.

Vuhledar

Ukraine war map: fighting in Donetsk region

The dynamics around Vuhledar will depend on what happens around Marinka. The Russian troops are trying to move from Marinka to the west, to Heorhiivka. They are trying to capture Novomykhailivka, then cut the road from Marinka, Pobieda and further to Kostiantynivka. Later, if the Russian army is able to advance there, in particular to this road, it will be able to move from the north towards Vuhledar and create an overhang over Ukrainian units that are currently holding Vuhledar. Thus, this may affect changes in this section of the front.

We have been watching Novomykhailivka being held for a long time. Probably, the dynamics will change only after Russia manages to level the front line in Avdiivka itself. After Avdiivka, there will be a certain release of the Russian forces that will remain alive there. Aviation, which is currently operating primarily in the Avdiivka direction, will also be partially released. 

Then we can expect the risk that this potential will be directed to the area of Russia's advance from Marinka. But everything will depend on how Ukraine's General Staff will use its reserves rationally, how it will receive assistance from its partners, how Ukraine's commanders will act, and how they will be able to find a balance between performing combat missions, holding the line, and saving the lives of their personnel. Each story is unique, and the general phrase "save lives" is actually extremely difficult to realize when each area is incredibly difficult.

Zelenskyy on US assistance

At a joint press conference with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, the President of Ukraine said that the US support will not "fall away." Zelenskyy said that the United States would not "fall away" because he is confident in the help from this powerful country. 

But at the current stage, European countries are providing Ukraine with military aid packages that, to some extent, compensate for the lack of American assistance. When speaking about the German military aid, today it is divided into two components: operational and long-term needs.

The German leader announced the preparation of a new package of aid to Ukraine worth EUR 1.1 billion, including 120,000 rounds of ammunition for large-caliber artillery. This is a significant assistance, missiles for the IRIS-T complex, which Germany supplies to Ukraine.  This is something Ukraine desperately needs. 

The supply of 36 self-propelled howitzers was also mentioned. These howitzers will not be supplied "tomorrow", these 36 vehicles in two versions, including the well-known PzH 2000 and the 155 mm RCH, will be produced over three years, starting in 2025. They will be delivered in accordance with the production rates and contracts that were signed earlier.

Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Tuesday
18 March
21:40
Russians amassing their forces in Toretsk, trying to launch assaults from there
21:10
Ukraine's General Staff denies claims about "Russian advance into Sumy region"
20:55
Valuable art still not evacuated from Sumy museums
20:40
High mercury, pollutants found in rivers in Russian-occupied parts of Ukraine
20:20
Updated
Trump and Putin hold phone call, agree to limited ceasefire in Ukraine
20:10
Exclusive
U.S. has no peace plan for Ukraine, says Polish politician
19:51
White House: Russia agrees to energy, infrastructure ceasefire in Ukraine
19:35
OPINION
Ukraine's role key to Europe’s future defense system
19:14
Russia prepares for future conflict with Europe, warns von der Leyen
18:55
Zelenskyy arrives on visit to Finland
18:31
U.S. aid to Ukraine used effectively, says Ukrainian audit
17:55
Ukrainian national guard captures five Russians in one of hottest combat zones
17:35
Russian army destroys oil refinery in Kharkiv region with drones
17:17
Ukraine should be in "strongest position": Starmer spoke with Trump ahead of his call with Putin
16:57
Over 90% of Denmark’s support for Ukraine goes to defense equipment – Ambassador
16:34
Exclusive
"Wants to be linked to victories only": international affairs expert on why Trump skipped Saudi Arabia talks
16:15
NATO secretary general says he has "every trust" in Trump's ability to reach Ukraine peace deal
15:55
EU regrets it can't open negotiation clusters with Ukraine without Hungary's consent
15:34
Ukraine and 7 EU countries file UN complaint over Russia’s satellite interference
15:13
German reforms are necessary due to "Putin's war against Europe" — Merz
14:42
Ukraine's Consulate General officially opens in Mumbai
14:22
Exclusive
Two possible scenarios of agreements between Trump and Putin, expert says
14:04
Putin seeks halt to U.S. weapons supplies to Ukraine in ceasefire proposal with Trump
13:43
Crimea is Ukraine: Partisans hold resistance campaign on anniversary of Russia’s annexation of Crimea
13:29
Ukrainian troops withdraw from disadvantageous positions in Donetsk region – military
13:05
Russia to ramp up information warfare with new PSYOP units, Ukraine's intel says
12:56
Review
Kursk operation evolves, Neptune missile's upgrades for modern combat. Serhiy Zgurets' column
12:20
Updated
"We had to get Ukraine to do the right thing": Trump comments on dispute with Zelenskyy in Oval Office (CORRECTED)
12:18
Exclusive
Russia is trying to bite off any part of Ukraine's land: military expert on Zaporizhzhia front
12:05
OPINION
Call with Putin: Trump will definitely lie about victory
11:43
We believe war against Ukraine can end this year — Ukraine’s FM
11:22
Lammy, Kallas lead talks on seizing Russian assets ahead of potential peace talks to end war in Ukraine
10:59
Exclusive
Ukraine Russia war live map, March 8-15
Ukrainian commander discusses efforts to halt Russian movement on Oskil River in Kupiansk
10:47
Putin trying to extract preemptive concessions from Trump in war-end negotiations — ISW
10:18
Exclusive
"U.S. will act decisively, retreat isn’t in Trump’s playbook" — Ukrainian MP on Russia stalling peace talks
09:55
Russia loses 1,560 soldiers, 8 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Monday
17 March
21:30
Exclusive
Russia aims to establish a ‘buffer zone’ in Sumy region - General Romanenko
21:10
White House: Trump-Putin talks bring peace closer than ever
20:50
Russia shifts focus, launches offensive in Kursk to gain leverage ahead of peace talks — Ukrainian MP
20:29
Russian forces intensify assault on defensive line in Zaporizhzhia sector
More news