Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Military expert: NATO membership could pose risk to Ukraine’s security

4 December, 2024 Wednesday
16:40

Military expert Ivan Stupak believes that joining NATO will not guarantee that Russia won’t repeat its aggression against Ukraine

client/title.list_title

He shared this opinion on Espreso TV, stating:

"Let's be honest, we're not going to join NATO anytime soon - unless the situation changes dramatically in the next six months to a year. Ukraine is still not ready in terms of material and technical readiness, and we don’t yet meet the standards required for NATO membership. Countries like Finland and Sweden, for instance, were already ready for membership for decades; they just needed to formalize the decision legally."

Stupak emphasized that Ukraine should focus on self-reliance when it comes to defense. He pointed out that even NATO membership would not guarantee full protection from a Russian invasion.

"One more point about NATO membership - it's an interesting dilemma. In my view, joining NATO could actually pose a risk to our security. The problem is that it might make our society complacent, leading people to believe that once we're under NATO's umbrella, we are safe and that the Alliance will step in if there's an emergency. It’s a bit reminiscent of the Budapest Memorandum. In such a scenario, NATO countries might not commit to defending Ukraine if Russia were to invade again. We could end up waiting, hoping that NATO will protect us. So, in my personal opinion, Ukraine should rely on itself for defense."

  • At the NATO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Brussels, Luxembourg's Foreign Minister Xavier Bettel opposed Ukraine's membership in the coalition.
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Wednesday
4 December
21:30
Ukraine to get $50 billion secured by frozen Russian assets soon – Blinken
21:20
Russian aerial bomb hits residential building in Kupyansk, killing one person
21:07
Can Ukraine acquire Russian weapons abandoned in Syria?
20:52
Romanian presidential front-runner Georgescu plans to halt aid to Ukraine
20:35
Speaker Johnson won't put $24 billion Ukraine aid package to vote in Congress
20:14
Russia inflicts $17 billion in damage on Ukraine's healthcare system
19:48
Ukrainian refugees should be motivated to work or return home - Scholz
19:20
119 combat engagements take place along frontline on Dec. 4: Ukrainian troops repel 25 attacks in Pokrovsk sector
18:57
Russian drone attack on Dnipropetrovsk region kills elderly woman
18:36
Exclusive
How many people have been enlisted in Russian army in occupied territories of Ukraine?
18:10
Why new medical evacuation version of Novator-2 armored vehicle is vital for NGU brigades
17:49
Russia destroys 330,000 properties, infrastructure in Ukraine since 2022
17:25
Russia is not conducting assaults in Siversky sector: Luhansk military grouping explains reason
17:05
Exclusive
Russian army realizes shortage of our soldiers at front - Ukrainian commander
16:18
Trump's Ukraine plan: Concessions to Russia, NATO membership off the table
15:54
Russian forces amass 300 boats near Kherson, pushing to secure island zones - Ukrainian military
15:36
Underestimating Trump is big mistake - U.S. government official Kellogg
15:24
Air defense dilemma: can NATO deliver what Ukraine desperately needs?
15:15
Exclusive
November 27–December 4 live war map: Russian offensive stalls on Pokrovsk-Kurakhove front
14:55
Exclusive
Poor-quality mines for Ukrainian forces are sabotage, not theft - Ukrainian major
14:34
Ukraine to receive $35 billion in EU aid sourced from Russian assets
14:16
Luxembourg opposes Ukraine's NATO membership, warns of potential tensions
14:01
Russia may be involved in hundreds of “suspicious incidents” in Europe – Czech Foreign Ministry
13:45
U.S. interests align closely with Ukraine's vision of victory - military expert
13:27
Exclusive
Ukraine's Border Guard Service buys ammunition through Polish intermediary - military expert Zgurets
13:08
OPINION
War in time is gradually replacing war in real space
12:46
Denmark to allocate €6 million for rebuilding Ukraine's energy infrastructure
12:30
Palianytsia missile-drone enters mass production - Ukraine's Defense Minister
12:11
Review
Situation on right bank of Oskil River, Ukraine's Kharkiv region, changes significantly. Serhiy Zgurets' column
12:02
Review
How Russia blames European governments for war in Ukraine
11:49
Exclusive
Situation deteriorates in both Kurakhove and Pokrovsk directions - military expert
11:28
Ukrainian guerrillas reconnoiter Russian defense structures near occupied Yevpatoria
11:10
Ukraine's population drops to 35.8 million - Ombudsman
10:53
192 clashes occur at front as Russian troops push in Ukraine's Pokrovsk, Kurakhove sectors
10:31
North Korean troops fighting for Russia report food shortages - Ukrainian intel
10:12
Russia claims to have downed 24 UAVs: media report blasts near Ryazan air base
09:54
Exclusive
Russian forces expand flanks in Ukraine's Kharkiv region - local official
09:35
Russia loses 1,670 soldiers, 31 armored vehicles, 7 tanks in one day of war in Ukraine
2024, Tuesday
3 December
21:25
6,000 Ukrainian soldiers who went AWOL, voluntarily return in November
21:10
U.S. allocates $825 million in new memorandum to support Ukraine's energy system 
More news