Espreso. Global
Exclusive

Military expert: NATO membership could pose risk to Ukraine’s security

4 December, 2024 Wednesday
16:40

Military expert Ivan Stupak believes that joining NATO will not guarantee that Russia won’t repeat its aggression against Ukraine

client/title.list_title

He shared this opinion on Espreso TV, stating:

"Let's be honest, we're not going to join NATO anytime soon - unless the situation changes dramatically in the next six months to a year. Ukraine is still not ready in terms of material and technical readiness, and we don’t yet meet the standards required for NATO membership. Countries like Finland and Sweden, for instance, were already ready for membership for decades; they just needed to formalize the decision legally."

Stupak emphasized that Ukraine should focus on self-reliance when it comes to defense. He pointed out that even NATO membership would not guarantee full protection from a Russian invasion.

"One more point about NATO membership - it's an interesting dilemma. In my view, joining NATO could actually pose a risk to our security. The problem is that it might make our society complacent, leading people to believe that once we're under NATO's umbrella, we are safe and that the Alliance will step in if there's an emergency. It’s a bit reminiscent of the Budapest Memorandum. In such a scenario, NATO countries might not commit to defending Ukraine if Russia were to invade again. We could end up waiting, hoping that NATO will protect us. So, in my personal opinion, Ukraine should rely on itself for defense."

  • At the NATO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Brussels, Luxembourg's Foreign Minister Xavier Bettel opposed Ukraine's membership in the coalition.
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Wednesday
8 January
19:23
111 clashes reported on Russian-Ukrainian front, mostly in Pokrovsk, Kurakhove sectors
19:07
Ukrainian troops repel Russian attack in area of Pokrovsk-Kostiantynivka highway
18:51
Belarus begins territorial army training near border with Ukraine
18:36
Ukraine ready to replace Hungary in EU, NATO over Russia tensions, MFA says
18:20
Updated
Russian forces attack Zaporizhzhia, killing at least 13
18:15
Ukraine registers its first medical cannabis-based medications
17:57
Precision strike: Ukrainian forces hit Russian command post in Donetsk region
17:38
Exclusive
Over 1,300 Ukrainian marines still in Russian captivity
17:16
Key shifts in U.S. policy toward Ukraine under Trump: military, aid, info wars
16:53
Ukraine’s strike on Engels reveals Russia's depleted air defenses
16:15
OPINION
Trump traps himself: Why peace won’t happen in January or in six months
15:51
How unverified claims on Ukrainian losses echo Russian narratives in Western media
15:31
Endured interrogations, threats, persecution: 17-year-old teenager returns from occupied Kherson
15:18
OPINION
Russia-Ukraine war could go further
15:09
Exclusive
January 1-8 live war map. Kurakhove near collapse, crisis in Toretsk, Ukraine deploys drone ‘carriers’
14:55
Exclusive
Strategic support for Ukraine until 2027: Zgurets talks expectations for Ramstein
14:33
Strike on Kristal oil depot near Engels targets specific fuel and “grounds” Tu-160s
14:15
Kherson region suffers casualties after Russian drone attacks
13:55
U.S. National Security Council delegation visits Kyiv ahead of "Ramstein" talks
13:49
Shandong port in China bans U.S.-designated vessels
13:34
Exclusive
"U.S. should prioritize Russia's Arctic projects": Ukrainian official on Trump's Greenland remark
13:15
Impunity for past crimes fuels Iran and Russia's ongoing violations: Ukraine on PS752 downing anniversary
12:52
Updated
Ukraine confirms drone strike on Russian oil depot in Engels, Saratov region
12:37
OPINION
Trump's sympathy for Putin, not Ukraine, is serious
12:23
Exclusive
Russia deploys small infantry groups in forested areas of Lyman-Kupyansk, Siversk fronts — Rubizh brigade
11:57
Review
Will January 9 Ramstein be last, and what's on agenda? Espreso explains
11:38
Hackers breach Russian registry with personal data — media
11:16
Exclusive
Russia tries to advance toward Myrnohrad, Donetsk region – official
10:55
Review
Ukraine’s offensive in Kursk region weakens Russia’s position. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
10:34
OPINION
Trump's fiery rhetoric and his "understanding" of Russia
10:14
Ukrainian army repels 41 assaults near Pokrovsk and 32 near Kursk amid 176 clashes on Jan. 7
09:35
Russian army loses 1,660 troops, 4 tanks and 19 artillery systems in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Tuesday
7 January
21:50
Trump rules out pre-inauguration meeting with Putin
21:40
Over 7,600 Russian troops killed and wounded near Pokrovsk last week
21:24
Ukraine receives first KF41 Lynx IFV from Rheinmetall for testing
21:17
Updated
Belarus builds up military presence near Ukraine's border. Kyiv reacts
20:59
OPINION
Don't Look Up: The West seen the movie, but failed to learn its lesson
20:43
Exclusive
Why Ukrainian army may occasionally receive low-quality ammunition
20:26
Ukrainian Armed Forces hit Russian marines' command post in Kursk region
20:07
Ukrainian forces hold out in Kurakhove, deny Lozova capture, spokesman reports
More news