Espreso. Global

ISW assesses Zelenskyy's order to continue holding Bakhmut

7 March, 2023 Tuesday
09:18

Further holding of Bakhmut is important for the possibility to destroy combat-ready Russian units, but the city in Donetsk region is not critical

This is stated in the daily report of the Institute for the Study of War (ISW).

American analysts point out that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on March 6 that he had ordered to continue defending Bakhmut and send reinforcements to the city. This happened after his meeting with the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Valerii Zaluzhnyi and the Commander of the Land Forces of Ukraine Oleksandr Syrskyi, who asked for more Ukrainian forces in the area.

"Statements made by Ukrainian officials regarding Bakhmut are likely meant in part to respond to the continued concern expressed by some Americans regarding the costs of Ukraine’s continued defense of Bakhmut. US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin stated on March 6 that he would not view a Ukrainian withdrawal from Bakhmut as a “significant strategic setback,” possibly intimating that he favors such a withdrawal," ISW suggested.

The Institute for the Study of War emphasized that Bakhmut is not intrinsically significant operationally or strategically. The capture of Bakhmut is necessary but not sufficient for further advance of Russian forces in the Donetsk region, and Russian forces have already suffered such heavy losses in the battle for the city that their offensive will likely end after they take it - if not before. Thus, the loss of Bakhmut is not a serious operational or strategic problem for Ukraine, as Secretary Austin and others have noted.

"But Ukraine’s fight for Bakhmut has become strategically significant because of the current composition of Russian forces arrayed in the area. Some Western reports have recently suggested that Ukraine is expending its own elite manpower and scarce equipment on mainly Wagner Group prison recruits who are mere cannon fodder, noting that such an exchange would be to Ukraine’s disadvantage even at high ratios of Russian to Ukrainian losses. That observation is valid in general, although the pool of Russian convict recruits suitable for combat is not limitless and the permanent elimination of tens of thousands of them in Bakhmut means that they will not be available for more important fights," ISW noted.

At the same time, the Institute for the Study of War believes that the Russian forces fighting in Bakhmut now consist of elite elements of the Wagner PMC and airborne units, as well as lower-quality troops. Ukrainian intelligence has supported ISW's assessment that Russian forces near Bakhmut have recently changed tactics and engaged special forces and regular units.

The Russian forces fighting in Bakhmut now consist of elite elements of the Wagner Group and Russian airborne units, as well as lower-skilled troops. Ukrainian intelligence has confirmed ISW's assessment that Russian forces near Bakhmut have recently changed tactics and deployed better-quality special forces and regular units.

 

 
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2024, Saturday
20 April
11:09
Ukraine's ability to shoot down Russian aircraft can't compensate for critical air defense deficit - ISW
10:41
Updated
Ukraine's air defense destroys 2 Kh-59/Kh-69 missiles, 4 reconnaissance UAVs
2024, Friday
19 April
21:50
Review
Victorious news of 786th day of war: Ukraine’s Air Force shoots down Russian Tu-22M3, German drone manufacturer opens factory in Ukraine
21:35
Russian army attacks Ukrainian positions in Kherson region 7 times with little success — General Staff
21:15
Kherson Art Museum identifies more than 100 paintings stolen by Russia
20:57
Exclusive
Putin will continue war until it becomes clear who is next in White House — political analyst
20:36
Exclusive
What parameters should F-16 have to effectively fight Russia: aviation expert explains
20:15
Ukrainian navy explains why Russian forces rarely use Kalibr missiles
19:49
Russia will not cease fire even if talks with Ukraine start - Lavrov
19:26
Exclusive
What could have shot down Russian Tu-22M bomber: military expert suggests
19:13
Updated
Poland detains Russian agent planning assassination attempt on Zelenskyy
19:05
Exclusive
"Ukraine has weapons to shoot down Russian aircraft": Air Force comments on Tu-22M3 downing
18:46
Updated
Slovaks raise €2 million for shells for Ukraine as government fails to back Czech initiative
18:45
G7 pledges to strengthen Ukraine's air defense
18:25
G7 defines specific steps to help Ukraine, says FM Kuleba
18:00
Review
General election in India: Relations with Ukraine and why role of Asian player shouldn't be underestimated
17:40
20 Days in Mariupol team brings Oscar to Ukraine
17:19
OPINION
War will end when world understands its causes and consequences - Ukrainian diplomat
16:57
Ukraine returns 17-year-old girl deported to Russia
16:35
Exclusive
Ukrainian resistance in occupied territories helps army
16:13
Exclusive
Russian army redeploys aviation to Bakhmut sector, Ukrainian forces lack air defenses
15:50
Russia attacks Bilopillya in Sumy region, severely injuring three people
15:30
Ukraine's top diplomat discusses strengthening of air defense with Italian counterpart
15:08
Russia cancels Victory Day parade in Crimea on May 9
14:48
Ukraine needs deeply echeloned air defense system - Ukrainian Air Force
14:27
Updated
Russia attacks Ukraine, killing and injuring civilians in Dnipro and region, including children
13:58
OPINION
Everything is to be decided in Europe and by Europe
13:38
"Situation is critical": Poland's PM says coming weeks could decide fate of war in Ukraine
13:18
Both U.S. congressional parties back bill to aid Ukraine — Ukraine’s PM following meetings with US officials
12:58
Review
Ukraine's dependence on US assistance. Technological solutions and frontline update. Serhiy Zgurets's column
12:38
Explosions heard in occupied Mariupol, Russian military base hit - Advisor to Mariupol Mayor
12:17
Ukrainian photojournalist Yulia Kochetova among winners of World Press Photo-2024 Global Stage
11:57
Ukraine downs Tu-22M3 aircraft in Russia used to launch Kh-22/Kh-32 missiles at Ukraine
11:35
Russians raid and mobilize Muslims in Crimea during Eid al-Fitr holiday
11:15
Russia steps up mobilization ahead of possible summer offensive: ISW names problems that Russia may face
10:55
Air defense systems belong in cities under attack, not warehouses - Zelenskyy on massive Russian attack on Dnipro
10:35
Russia loses 870 soldiers, 9 tanks and 21 artillery systems in one day in Ukraine - General Staff
09:55
"We have no plan B": Ukraine's Foreign Minister comments on expectations from US Congress vote
2024, Thursday
18 April
21:59
Review
Victorious news of 785th day of war: Ukraine has drones able to hit targets in Siberia, Germany will supply more air defense systems
21:38
97% of Russian attacks target civilian infrastructure - Ukraine in OSCE
More news