Espreso. Global
OPINION

US takes diplomatic stance: distancing from Ukraine to mediate talks with Russia

13 January, 2024 Saturday
16:42

Why do Ukraine's Western partners 'filter' aid, still withholding certain types of needed weapons?

client/title.list_title

It is usually said that this is out of fear of the potential disintegration of Russia. 

Consequently, the idea is for Ukraine to 'not win too much.' But I believe this is only part of the story.

 I would hypothetically decode this logic roughly as follows.

  1. All wars end at the negotiating table. This is an axiom. Therefore, this war will come to an end through negotiations between Ukraine and Russia. (The scenario in which Russia disintegrates so rapidly that there is simply no one left to sit at the negotiating table is not considered or dismissed as catastrophic).
  2. The negotiations between Ukraine and Russia, like most negotiations of this kind, will require a mediator - a 'third party.' For the United States and/or leading EU countries to serve as this 'third party,' they must at least in some way distance themselves from Ukraine.
  3. But if you give Ukraine absolutely everything it asks for, such distancing will be impossible. In that case, Ukraine and Western countries will be perceived by Russia as one party without any nuances or distinctions.
  4. So, in this scenario, someone else (China? Turkey?) will eventually become the 'third party' in the anticipated negotiations. However, it will be less strategically advantageous for the US and the EU compared to if they played that role.

I am not evaluating this logic in any way, I'm just trying to decode it. 

About author: Oleksiy Panych, philosopher, member of the Ukrainian PEN Center, blogger.

The editors do not always share the opinions expressed by blog authors.



 
Tags:
Read also:
  • News
2025, Sunday
11 May
21:13
OPINION
Putin chooses the worst possible option
20:41
Exclusive
Russia’s missile systems at peak combat readiness, but Oreshnik still a question mark — Ukrainian colonel
20:18
Drones hit Russia’s Basalt military plant: What does it manufacture?
20:00
Trump: Ukraine should immediately agree to talks with Russia in Turkey
19:58
Will the “gun” of European-Ukrainian diplomacy finally fire?
19:30
OPINION
If Russia wants peace, it must stop killing
19:08
Interview
U.S. still undecided on direct confrontation with Russia — Colonel Grant
18:51
Exclusive
Putin would welcome U.S. pullback from Ukraine peace talks — Polish diplomat Cichocki
18:27
“Wielding terror as leverage, stalling for time”: Lithuania responds to Putin’s ceasefire stance
17:46
Pope Leo XIV expresses solidarity with Ukraine during first Sunday prayer
17:29
Exclusive
Russian troops step up efforts to “hunt” Ukrainian drone operators – Ukrainian volunteer
17:00
Talks cannot begin until the weapons fall silent, Germany’s Merz says
16:46
Exclusive
Ukraine should build highly trained army – Colonel Grant
16:25
Trump’s Ukraine envoy Kellogg responds to Putin: No negotiations without ceasefire first
16:07
Exclusive
Trump less inclined to follow Putin's lead every day — journalist Portnikov
15:40
Russia intensifies frontline attacks during declared May 8 to 10 “truce” – DeepState
15:17
OPINION
Putin’s late-night statement: Political aikido and Istanbul trap
14:45
Exclusive
Russia will intensify assaults in several directions ahead of May 15 – military expert Sniehyrov
14:17
Turkey’s Erdogan offers to facilitate direct talks between Russia and Ukraine
13:44
Review
Gray imports, Russia’s "shadow fleet," and "lost" cargo: How Moscow skirts sanctions after invading Ukraine
13:22
Updated
Macron outlines condition for Ukraine-Russia peace talks in Istanbul
13:18
Russian-abducted Kherson ex-mayor gives up his prisoner exchange slot to aid sick POW
12:50
Moscow faces deepening budget crisis amid economic slowdown – Resurgam
12:16
Hungary delays talks with Ukraine on national minorities
11:20
Zelenskyy responds to Putin, says ceasefire comes before talks
11:12
Putin proposes direct talks with Ukraine in Istanbul, without ceasefire. Trump responds
10:56
Ukrainian air defenses down 60 Russian drones in nighttime attack
10:30
Russia loses 33 artillery systems, 1,310 soldiers in one day of war in Ukraine
2025, Saturday
10 May
19:40
OnlyFans models in Ukraine ready to pay taxes, but flee due to legal concerns
19:20
Merz on Taurus missiles supply to Ukraine: decisions will be made collectively
19:00
Zelenskyy signals readiness for direct peace talks with Putin
18:40
Proposal to withdraw Ukrainian troops 15 km from frontline is unfeasible - Zelenskyy
18:15
Germany's new leadership may keep Ukraine military aid under wraps - media
17:52
Exclusive
Peace talks with Russia pose risk of Ukraine's capitulation, says expert
17:25
Iran poised to send short-range ballistic missile launchers to Russia - media
16:58
UK PM urges Putin to show commitment to peace during Kyiv visit
16:36
Russian strikes in Sumy region kill 3, leave several injured during May 9 'truce'
16:17
Updated
Ukraine, its European allies back full ceasefire from May 12, urge Russia to comply
16:08
Review
Ukraine to get €2 billion from frozen Russian assets, drone situation on frontlines. Serhiy Zgurets’ column
15:32
Ukraine's intel shows two types of unmanned drones for Black Sea operations
More news